Basically Peanut's lucky hat (Its a red and blue hat with a Bucky Spacebeaver emblem from the episode Hooray for Peanut the cover image actually shows Butter wearing the exact hat im referring to) gets lost at sea after playing baseball so now they have to think of how to get the hat and the ball back
Peanut: *Goes outside to see Flick and Munchy* Hey guys! Ready to play some baseball?
Munchy: You bet we are!
Flick: And im gonna wipe the floor with both of you!
Peanut: Hah no way im a baseball master Flick! Now lets- *Realizing hes forgetting something* wait hold on I gotta go back inside I'll be right back!
Flick: Ok but hurry up! I dont got all day!
*Inside his boathouse*
Peanut: *Looking around* Come on wheres the hat! I left it right here didnt I?
Ernest: Looking for something Peanut?
Peanut: Yeah I am dad have you seen my lucky hat? The red one with the Bucky Spacebeaver emblem on it? Its for a baseball game with Flick and Munchy
Ernest: Have you looked in the closet?
Peanut: Oh yeah- *Opens and its there* boy I feel silly why didnt I check here in the first place
Ernest: Hehe its ok Peanut I do that too sometimes I get so caught up looking for something I dont think to check in the most likely place
Peanut: Thanks dad! *Hugs the hat for a moment and puts it on*
Ernest: Say Peanut mind if I ask what makes the hat so lucky?
Peanut: Oh easy! Remember how I got it at the fair when I was 5?
*Flashback*
Mayor Jeff: Times up everyone! Lets see who made the best babbleberry juice! The winner gets the grand prize!
Peanut: Im for sure gonna win I made it just like how mom does!
Jelly: This has to win! I used mama's method and everything!
Ootsie: Those otters think they have a chance haha!
Bootsie: Once the mayor sees that we made it with the turbo babbleberry juice maker 6000!
Ootsie: Which is twice as good as the turbo babbleberry juice maker 3000!
Bootsie: Then hes for sure gonna make us the winners!
Mayor Jeff: Hand over your cups of juice to the judges everyone!
*After they drink each of their cups they come to a decision*
Mayor Jeff: The judges have decided! The winner of the babbleberry juice taste test is..
Peanut: Please be me please be me..
Mayor Jeff: Jelly Otter!
Jelly: Yaaaaay! I won!
Peanut: But- but we made it the exact same.. didnt we? *Reads ingredient list again that his mom made* aw man I added more sugar than what was on the list.. *Tearing up and walking off stage*
Ootsie: What?!
Bootsie: How did we not win! We made it the poodle way!
Ootsie: This is an outrage!
Mayor Jeff: Dont worry you two you both got second place! As for you Jelly you deserve the grand prize!
Jelly: Oh boy! What is it Mayor Jeff?
Mayor Jeff: I present to you.. this red hat with this cool spaceship emblem on the front!
Jelly: Oh.. neat! *Takes*
Ootsie: *That* was the prize?
Bootsie: A dumb silly hat?
Ootsie: We have WAY cooler prizes at home sis lets get outta here
Bootsie: Agreed *They both leave*
Jelly: *Tries hat on* It doesnt even fit its too big! Maybe I should just get rid of it.. *Walks around with it and hears someone crying* huh?
Peanut: *Hugging Opal* I thought- I thought if I made it just like you then.. I would win the Bucky Spacebeaver hat..
Opal: There there Peanut its ok.. you had fun didnt you?
Peanut: Yeah.. but I really wanted the hat..
Jelly: *Looks at the emblem on the hat* Oh thats what this is? Well its no Commander Casserole but.. poor Peanut he seemed really excited about getting it..
Peanut: At least Jelly gets to have it.. she deserves it more than those Snooties..
Opal: Well im sure theres plenty of hats just like that one here
Peanut: I guess..
Jelly: I got it! I'll give the hat to Peanut! I dont really care about Bucky Spacebeaver but I know how much he loves it! He'll be so happy! *Writes on the bottom of it "You deserve this more than me for being the best brother ever! -Jelly 💜"* and for extra luck mama always gives us a good luck kiss so this is for you big brother! *Kisses the emblem* now lets give you to Peanut! *Runs off*
*Back to the present*
Peanut: And then she came up to me and gave me this hat! And its been my lucky hat ever since!
Ernest: Oh yeah now I remember! Good luck kisses sure work wonders dont they? Thats why your mom always gives me some before I head off to work
Peanut: They sure do and this hat reminds me just how lucky I am to have a sister like Jelly
Ernest: And im sure she feels the same way about you.. now go out there and play ball I didnt mean to keep you waiting
Peanut: Its ok dad I didnt mind telling you why the hat's lucky! But you're right I dont wanna keep Flick and Munchy waiting I'll see you later! *Runs outside*
Ernest: Hit a home run for me son!
Peanut: I will!
*Outside*
Flick: Aw cheese and quackers whats taking Peanut so long I wanna play ball!
Munchy: I dont know.. maybe hes just looking for something
Peanut: Hey guys! Sorry it took me a while I was getting my lucky hat and talking to my dad
Flick: Finally! Now lets play already!
*After a bit of playing and Munchy eating the bats cause of them being wooden Peanut's ready to pitch only for it to end up badly for his hat soon*
Peanut: You ready to lose Flick?
Flick: No way Nuts im in this to win it!
Peanut: We'll see about that! *Throws ball really hard*
Flick: Thats an easy hit! *Hits the ball with the bat and the ball gets inside Peanut's hat and launches with it*
Peanut: My hat!
Flick: Home run for Flick! *Victory dance* in your face Peanut!
Scootch: *Walking out with Pinch when he sees something in the air* Sis! Look!
Pinch: What is it Scootch? *Sees what hes pointing at* oh wow.. I wonder what is.. it looks like a hat of some kind.. maybe its a pretty shooting star hat and you're supposed to make a wish!
*On top of the Crane treehouse*
Cap'n Crane: *Watching over the lake when he sees the hat flying* Watchbird alert! Watchbird alert!
Connie: *Wakes up* Huh- what? What is it dear?
Cap'n Crane: Look Connie! Theres a flying tiny red saucer heading over Lake Hoohaw!
Connie: *Looks through binoculars* Darling.. thats just a hat theres no aliens coming here
Cap'n Crane: A hat? Its not my hat is it? I could have sworn it was right here in this tower
Connie: Feel the top of your head for me will ya dear?
Cap'n Crane: Alright then *Feels his head* phew! My hat is safe and sound!
*Back to Peanut's front yard*
Peanut: Flick you knocked my lucky hat off and now it flew off with the ball to who knows where!
Flick: Oh relax Peanut its just a stupid hat! And it seems my lucky ball trumped your lucky hat so its not so lucky now is it?
Peanut: Whatever Flick lets just see where it went!
*They try looking for it*
Jelly: Hey Peanut whatcha lookin for?
Peanut: My lucky hat! Flick knocked it off of my head with a baseball and now its gone!
Flick: Oh cheese and quackers its just a dumb hat Peanut!
Peanut: Its my favorite hat! Jelly gave it to me as a gift when I was 5!
Flick: *In a mocking tone* Awww your sister gave it to you? So what! You have plenty of hats similar to that one!
Munchy: Its probably sentimental to him Flick like how my wooden boat is for me because my dad gave it to me when I was very young according to my mom so it reminds me of him
Peanut: And besides I wouldnt be laughing coming from someone who keeps his mom's old apron in his room
Jelly: Oh yeah Pinch told us about that
Flick: Wha- how'd you know that?! I mean.. thats not true!
Pinch: Someone call me?
Jelly: Hey Pinch we were just discussing Flick's apron he keeps around
Pinch: Oh yeah! I remember how defensive you got over it when I asked to borrow it
Flick: Lies! I dont keep my mom's apron around! Its not sentimental!
Pinch: Whatever you say.. so what are you guys looking for?
Butter: *Pointing to top of Peanut's head* Hat!
Peanut: She means my lucky hat it got caught in the baseball and now it launched with the ball and we cant find it anywhere!
Scootch: Oh Pinch! Remember? *Pointing up to sky cause a moment ago he saw the hat fly by*
Pinch: You think the hat that flew by our house was Peanut's?
Scootch: Maybe!
Peanut: Well its worth a shot to look.. where did you see it fly off to Scootch?
Scootch: This way! *They follow him to the beach and they see it very far away in the lake*
Jelly: Wow look how far away it is!
Flick: I really hit it out of the park!
Munchy: But what do we do our parents told us to never go out that far!
Peanut: Oh its no use even trying.. my hat's gonna be out there forever..
Jelly: Come on Peanut dont give up so quickly! Theres gotta be a way to get it back!
Peanut: But how? Its all the way out there..
Jelly: I know what we can do to think of how to get it back!
Peanut: Dont tell me.. a noodle dance?
Jelly: You bet! Come on guys lets noodle!
Peanut: Use my noodle? Yes but dancing? No thank you
*They all start dancing including Peanut*
Chorus: Noodle! Use your noodle! Noodle! Do the noodle dance!
Peanut and Jelly: Solve a problem its no strain! Use your noodle thats your brain!
Jelly: Hey good singing Peanut!
Peanut: You too Jel!
*They keep dancing*
Pinch: *Gets an idea* I got it!
Peanut: What- what happened what?
Pinch: *Imagining her idea* Why dont we get this huge magnet in the sky and decorate it with these pretty ribbons and then we can fly it above Peanut's hat and the ball and get both of them back!
Peanut: Good idea Pinch!
Jelly: Now lets get that magnet at your place!
Pinch: Oh.. I dont actually have a giant magnet.. sorry guys
Butter: *Sees the Snooties getting rid of stuff*
Edouard: Now what are we gonna do with all this junk Georgina! We got all these high tech baby toys and we arent even having a third pup!
Georgina: I could have sworn I was gonna have a third kid.. but no worries dear we'll make good use out of these toys im sure
Butter: *Sees one of the toys being a forcefield helicopter designed to collect anything from the water in case the puppy drops a toy in there and remembers the conversation her siblings had with Ootsie and Bootsie the other day*
*Flashback*
Peanut: Wow Ootsie and Bootsie those are a lot of new toys!
Jelly: Are they all for you?
Ootsie: Ugh unfortunately they're not..
Bootsie: Our dad's been stocking up on high tech baby toys because he thinks we're having another sibling
Ootsie: We can afford it clearly but I dont wanna share any of *our* toys with a puppy!
Peanut: A new sibling? Hey you hear that Butter? You could possibly have a new friend!
Jelly: Yeah since you're both babies!
Butter: Yay new friend!
Ootsie: Well at least someone's excited for a third Snootie kid
Bootsie: But that new puppy wont be as good of kids as we are Ootsie! And with mom and dad spending more money on the puppy that means..
Ootsie and Bootsie: Less money to spend on us!
Peanut: Come on you guys having a third sibling isnt bad! Look at us!
Ootsie: You know the old saying Peanut dont you?
Bootsie: Three's a crowd!
Peanut: Think about it even if those toys are for the puppy you still have a ton of new toys to play with together!
Bootsie: Well the toys are really nothing special we'd be bored with them instantly..
Ootsie: Yes like this one remote control helicopter that has a forcefield around it that any object inside it will pull itself onto the toy like a magnet
Bootsie: We have loads of toys like that already
Ootsie and Bootsie: Borrrrring!
Jelly: Well why dont you just put a claw on it?
Peanut: Or a hook?
Bootsie: You should know us by now Otters!
Ootsie: We Snooties only use the latest technology on everything!
Bootsie: Maybe thats how *your* toys work
Ootsie: But not ours! We're much more advanced!
*Back to the present*
Butter: *Trying to get everyone's attention but its not working*
Flick: Peanut can you tell your baby sister to leave us alone we're thinkin here!
Peanut: Yeesh Flick dont yell at her- what is it Butter?
Butter: *Points to the Snootie's place*
Peanut: Hmm? Oh those? They already showed us those toys a couple days ago remember?
Jelly: We cant play with them Butter they wont let us but we'll play later ok?
Peanut: I dont get it we thought of everything! Like a sailboat that because its not windy it wont work and a magnet which we dont have and a plane which we also dont have..
Flick: I could just fly over there and get it!
Munchy: But you're still learning Flick! What if you lose control and end up in the water and drown! *Eating wood out of nervousness for him*
Flick: You worry too much Munch! I'll be fine!
Pinch: But he is right Flick you're not trained enough in flying to go that far
Flick: Why does everyone always reject *my* ideas! Cheese and quackers im using my noodle really hard here!
Jelly: I never thought I'd say this but even after all that dancing im stumped..
Peanut: Its no use.. im never getting my hat back..
Pinch: I know how you feel Peanut one day I lost a dolly my mom gave me when I was a baby and I was so sad when I couldnt find it..
Jelly: But you ended up finding it again didnt you?
Pinch: Yeah but for the time it was lost I was really upset cause it was something sentimental to me..
Munchy: Same with when your dad accidentally crushed my wooden boat you remember how sad I was
Jelly: Or Butter's blanket before it ripped apart.. at least it made a good pillowcase!
Flick: You guys are a bunch of softballs! They're just objects they're easily replaceable!
Peanut: Well how would you feel if that apron you hold on to got lost or damaged
Flick: Uhhhh.. I wouldnt mind its just an old apron! Not like it was the first apron I saw my mom wear when I was just a duckling so it brings back memories and- *they all stare at him*
Jelly: So you *do* have a connection to it
Flick: Ok fine maybe I do! Go ahead laugh at me!
Munchy: We werent gonna laugh we have something we hold onto as well! Its alright to have something sentimental!
Peanut: Like my hat.. *Sigh* lets just go guys I'll get another hat from my dad's store..
Butter: *Tugging onto Peanut's arm* Snooties!
Peanut: What about them?
Jelly: Guys I think Butter might have an idea!
Flick: But shes a baby! What ideas could she possibly have!
Jelly: Beats me but lets hear her out!
Butter: *Pointing to the Snooties and running towards the direction of their boathouse*
Munchy: Should we follow her?
Peanut: I guess we should she might be onto something here!
*They follow her to the Snooties place*
Butter: *Taps on Edouard's leg*
Edouard: Now who is doing that tapping? *Looks down* oh its you Butter
Ootsie: If you see any toys you like here just take em free of charge
Bootsie: They're not of any use to us now
Butter: *Takes the helicopter and shows them the toy*
Flick: We came all the way over here just so you can take some useless junk?
Ootsie: Excuse me its not junk! Its highly advanced!
Bootsie: But he is right about it being useless
Peanut: Hey wait a minute thats the forcefield helicopter!
Jelly: Yeah it is! Butter do you think you can control the toy and get Peanut's hat with the forcefield?
Butter: Yeah! *Turns on and tries flying it over to the hat*
Pinch: Go a little more to the left Butter!
Butter: *Listening to their instructions and retrieves the hat and ball with the forcefield and brings it back to land*
Peanut: You did it Butter! Now thats using your noodle! *Picks her up and kisses her on the cheek*
Jelly: Yeah you're a genius baby Butter!
Butter: *Giggling* Thank you
Flick: Lesson learned.. never underestimate a baby
Jelly: *Takes the hat* Here you go Peanut- oh wait I should do something with it first
Peanut: Do what with it Jel?
Jelly: A good luck kiss of course! Like what mama does! *Kisses the hat in the same spot as before and lets Butter do it too and puts it on Peanut* there! Now its twice as lucky!
Peanut: Thanks Jel.. *Hugs her* you're the best sister ever and so are you Butter!
Jelly: Happy to help big bro!
Ootsie: Yuck.. hey Otters take your sapfest somewhere else please!
Bootsie: Us poodles know not to show cutesy affection in public!
Peanut: Uh ok.. lets go guys
Jelly: At least we got your hat back!
Peanut: Yeah and im so happy to have it again!
*They start to sing a song about the hat and other stuff the others own of sentimental value and how important it is to cherish them*
*Cut to the evening on the dock*
Peanut: So then my hat got sent to the lake from the ball and we were trying to figure out ways to get it back since it was super far out in the lake
Jelly: We were stumped for a while! But thats when baby Butter stepped in and used one of the Snootie's toys to get the hat and baseball back!
Peanut: I wouldnt have gotten my hat back without her *Picks her up and kisses her as she giggles*
Ernest: Sounds like Butter was really using her noodle today huh?
Jelly: She sure was! It was Butter's big idea! (Author's note: AH AH SHE SAID IT SHE SAID IT)
Opal: Why im so proud of you Butter *Picks her up and tickles her* you're very smart just like your siblings!
Peanut: And dont worry dad I got a few home runs for you before and after I lost the hat
Ernest: Hehe thats my son! *High fives him*
Opal: Did you win Peanut?
Peanut: Actually it was Munchy who won! He was so excited
Jelly: Oh so our good luck kisses on the hat didnt make you win huh..
Peanut: Dont worry Jelly I may not have won but this hat is still very lucky to me! *Hugs her* it was given to me by you! Remember?
Jelly: Yeah! I even saw the note I wrote on it all that time ago is still there!
Peanut: Its not only lucky cause of the Bucky Spacebeaver theme but also because it reminds me that I have the best sister in the world.. *Kisses her cheek*
Jelly: Awwww thanks Peanut.. *Kisses him back* and you're the best big bro ever!
Peanut: *Holds Butter* You're the best sister too Butter!
Butter: Yay!
Opal: D'awwww Ernest.. isnt that adorable?
Ernest: Our kids sure do love each other dont they?
Opal: They sure do.. and we love you guys all just the same!
Jelly: We love you too mama!
Ernest: I just had a big idea myself gang you wanna hear it?
Jelly: Sure daddy what is it?
Ernest: So my big idea is we all eat some babbleberry pie and then head off to bed! Does that sound like a good idea?
Opal: Look at you using your noodle Ernest thats a wonderful idea! Wouldnt you agree kids?
Peanut: The babbleberry pie? Yes!
Jelly: But the going to bed part? Not so much..
Opal: You kids did have a long day today you need your rest
Peanut: She does have a point Jel playing baseball and retrieving a hat sure is tiring..
Jelly: Oh alright mama.. maybe tomorrow we can play baseball together! Ya know as a family!
Ernest: Im down for that! I have not played in a long time
Opal: I dont believe I have either.. but the faster we get to bed the more energy we'll have for the game tomorrow
Ernest: Your mother's right so lets head inside now
PB&J: Ok! *They all head inside to get ready for bed*
And thats the end! I had this idea for a while and decided to finally get to work and publish it! What did yall think? Leave a review!