Ch. 10 – Feeling Red


"Letters from Hogwarts are here by the way," Mrs. Weasley said, pointing to the kitchen counter. She moved the rest of the empty plates from the table to the sink as Hermione, Harry, Ron, and Ginny all approached the pile of envelopes, each picking up the one with his or her name scribbled on it.

Hermione grabbed the letter opener on the counter and slit her envelope open, holding out the tool after for the next person to take. Ignored by the two boys, it was grabbed by Ginny. To Hermione's left, Harry picked at his own envelope and ran his finger along the opening, while to her right, Ron nearly tore his in half in the process. She unfolded the parchment and was scanning the list of books that would be required for the N.E.W.T. levels when she heard a sound of surprise. Her head lifted and she found Harry staring at something in his hand.

"What's that?"

He flashed it to her and she recognized the badge that signified one's position as Quidditch Captain.

"Whoa!" Ron exclaimed, snatching the badge out of Harry's hand for examination.

Hermione's face lit up with a smile. "That gives you equal status with prefects! You can use our special bathroom now and everything!" She had no idea why she said such a thing but after it had come out of her mouth, she felt her face turn hot. Thankfully, it seemed nobody else had noticed what her own comment suddenly made her think of. Several weeks had now passed since she had found herself on the Weasleys' kitchen floor, head ringing with the troubling realization that she was in love with one best friend but fated to end up with the other. The idea of being "fated" to do anything—the suggestion that she was not in control of her own actions—was preposterous, of course. But the weeks passed and the consistent sharp pains in her head persisted, accompanied by the now-familiar voice in her head crooning the names of her two best friends. And through it all, wondering more than ever if she was going mad, Hermione could not shake the feeling that somehow, what she had been made aware of in her mind and heart were certain truth. She began to notice certain looks Ron was giving her when she presumed he thought he was being furtive. She became aware of the strange, suggestive comments (not only limited to sharing bathrooms), coming out of her mouth when she was near Harry and the fanciful thoughts she found herself getting lost in. But most terrible of all was the sense of foreboding dread that loomed in the back of her head urgently telling her she was not supposed to feel this way. But how could she control that?

Hermione attempted to nonchalantly go back to scanning the book list when one title caught her eye. "Confronting the Faceless," she read out loud. Say it, the voice in her head hissed.

"I wonder what it's like for Slughorn to come back to Hogwarts after retirement," she said.

"He must have gotten an unbelievably good deal," Ron said, tossing his own letter to the side. "The job is clearly jinxed at this point. But maybe since he's already taught the subject, he has some kind of immunity."

Hermione looked to Harry, expecting him to chime in with his thoughts on Slughorn but to her surprise, it was Mrs. Weasley, who had not left the kitchen and had overheard their conversation, who turned to them and spoke with a puzzled expression. "Horace Slughorn never taught Defense Against the Dark Arts."

Four pairs of eyes looked to her. "What?" Harry said in shock. "What did he teach then?"

Hermione somehow knew the answer before it was said.

"Potions," Mrs. Weasley responded.

"Potions?!" Harry and Ron echoed.

"Mum, are you sure?" Ron asked in alarm.

Mrs. Weasley raised an eyebrow. "Am I sure? Of course I am! He taught your father and me for years. Do you think I'm going senile, Ron?"

"But what about Snape?" Harry blurted out.

"What if he's on some mission for the Order?" Hermione threw out. She did not know where this idea had come from, but this too, felt like something that had been planted in her head, causing her to grow uneasy.

"Well, Mum?" Ginny piped up. "Is he?"

"Even if I knew, I certainly wouldn't tell you all," Mrs. Weasley snapped.

"Do you think he'll even be at Hogwarts this year?" Harry asked the room with a hint of hope in his voice.

Hermione looked at him. "Did Dumbledore mention anything?"

Harry seemed to be thinking back to that night. "All he said was he was a staff member short. He never said anything about two…"

Something clicked in Hermione's mind. "Snape's taking over Defense Against the Dark Arts!" she said with a gasp.

"What?!"

"No way!"

Both Harry and Ron had exclaimed at the same time, turning to her with a mix of disbelief and anger on their faces as if she was the one who had personally appointed Snape to the position.

"After all this time?" Harry said. "Why would Dumbledore let him have the job when he hasn't trusted him so far?"

"But Slughorn's never taught Defense! It makes sense!" Hermione insisted.

"I don't want to believe it," Harry said defiantly. "I'm not going to believe it until we get to Hogwarts and I hear it from Dumbledore himself."

"Why would he not tell Harry though?" Ginny asked. "Especially if they went together to convince Slughorn."

"Probably because Dumbledore knew you would have this sort of reaction," Hermione said to Harry.

"He said he would tell me everything now!" Harry said. His face suddenly turned glum. "But he's definitely kept stuff from me before."

"Harry, this is clearly not the type of information Dumbledore had in mind when he said he would tell you everything," Hermione said. "It's not—"

"Not what?" Harry interrupted. "Not important? We're talking about someone who's wanted this job for years and had it denied to him by Dumbledore himself. Now suddenly, he's supposedly fine with it? Something's going on."

"You know," Ron began. "What if—"

"Shut up, Ron!" Hermione said.

"What? You didn't even let me finish!" Ron snarled.

"Because it was clear whatever was going to come out was rubbish!" Hermione shot back. "How many times have we been over this? Dumbledore trusts Snape!" As the words left her mouth, however, Hermione felt the now-familiar searing pain in her head that caused her to press into her temples. She gritted her teeth in annoyance. Why now? What was so important to draw attention to at this moment?

When the pain had stopped however, a new thought was left in its wake. She turned to Harry. "You know what you should do though?" It was as if someone had taken control and was now guiding the words out of her mouth. "You should buy the Potions book. You won't need an "O" like when Snape was teaching it." She turned to Ron. "You too."

"Come off it," Ron said. "You want us to buy extra books on a hunch you have?"

"It's not a hunch!" Hermione said. "It's the only thing that makes sense, unless you think your mum is lying."

Ron seemed to consider her words. He looked to Harry and shrugged. "I'll do it if you will."

Having listened to their entire conversation, Mrs. Weasley seemed bemused at their disbelief. "I am beyond sure that Horace Slughorn taught Potions and will be teaching Potions once term starts. He taught the subject for years, why would he come out of retirement to teach a different one?"

Harry still seemed as if he did not want to accept it, but there was a hint of resignation in his voice. "Maybe…I should buy the book…"

"Advanced Potion-Making by Libatius Borage," Hermione read out loud from the booklist.

"Get a new copy," she said to the room. She felt a tremor in her head. "Get a new copy," she repeated, though this time, it was more to herself than to anyone else.


Hermione watched Ron open the door and followed him into the compartment. It was now afternoon and they had just gotten back from their prefect duties of patrolling the corridors of the Hogwarts Express, fending off countless questions and attempted interrogations from people they hardly knew about what had happened at the Ministry.

"Hi, Neville. Hi, Luna," she and Ron greeted the two others already with Harry in the compartment.

Ron informed Harry about what they had just seen. Malfoy had been shirking his responsibilities, lazily lounging around with the other Slytherins when he should have been patrolling the corridors. The Slytherin prefect's neglection of duties was unsurprising but what was was that Malfoy did not even seem interested in another of his favorite pastimes: abusing his power and bullying younger students.

Hermione had never shied away from her duties of course. In fact, she had always taken the appropriate amount of pride in her status as a prefect. But as she had walked along the corridors with Ron, staring at the back of his head and red filling her eyes, she had found herself incessantly thinking about their friend who was not with them. And this time, she knew why. The rest of the summer holidays had passed by, packed with many more games of Quidditch (there had been no improvement on her end) and long conversations filling the air where she could not keep her words clear. Her face had seemingly adopted a permanent shade of red as she saw him every day, refusing to let her emotions fade until she was forced to admit it to herself. Her heart had simply swelled substantially in an attempt to contain all that she felt about Harry Potter, and she was barely holding on. There was now no more running. Only hiding. For how could she ever think of telling him?

But now he was in front of her. Like she had been doing so frequently as of late, she stared at him and saw that he was deep in thought about Ron's comments regarding Malfoy. He looked so serious, so endearing, so—

"Harry Potter?"

A girl Hermione did not know had opened their compartment door. She was nervously holding on to two rolls of parchment. "I'm supposed to deliver this to you," she said, holding out the scroll to him with a slightly shaking arm. As Harry took it from her, Hermione noticed that the girl's face had turned scarlet and her own eyes widened in shameful realization. Was this how she looked when she was around Harry lately? So embarrassed, so flustered, so…silly?

The girl glanced down at the remaining scroll in her hand. The redness in her face had lessened and she now looked to the rest of the room. "This one is for Neville Longbottom." After handing over the note to Neville, she promptly left their compartment, seemingly dazed.

"What's that?" Hermione said, as Harry and Neville unrolled their letters.

"It's from Slughorn. Invitation," Harry said as he scanned it.

Neville looked thoroughly puzzled. "Why me?"

"I might have an idea…" Harry said, looking around the compartment. "We'll see you later, I guess."

"But we just got here!" Hermione said. From the corner of her eye, she saw Ron raise an eyebrow at the tone of protest in her voice.

Harry shrugged. "Sorry." He turned to Neville. "Let's go."

Hermione watched them leave with disappointment. Now deprived of what she had been planning to look at, she settled for staring out the train window and her thoughts drifted once again to the moment when she had realized she had fallen for her best friend. It had been the third time that summer she had found herself waking up on the kitchen floor with no memory as to what had happened. However, this time one thing was new; there had been a faint, terrifying vision of being swallowed up by sand. The fear had been the first thing to greet her as she had come to her senses. She had desperately sought to escape it and had found Harry's green eyes staring back into hers. Before she knew it, she had reached for him and had found herself tightly clutching him. The realization of being in love had hit her not long after, once the pain in her head had subsided. And the rest of the summer was spent grappling with the idea and what—if anything—she could do about it.

Now however, her thoughts took her back to the memory of how that night, hours after dinner, Ginny had pulled her to the side.


"How are you feeling?" Ginny asked, after she had dragged Hermione away to a secluded part of the house.

"Fine," Hermione said in puzzlement.

"Okay," Ginny said. She crossed her arms and scowled. "Because we're talking. Now."

"Ginny, what is this?"

"Hermione…I saw you disappear!"

"…What?"

"Earlier today, you were in front of our cupboard, just opening and closing it over and over. And all of a sudden…you were gone. It was like you Disapparated!"

Hermione scrunched up her face in thought. Yes… she remembered opening and closing the cupboard. Growing frustrated that nothing was happening. And then sensing that Harry had something to do with the whole affair, she had opened the cupboard one last time. But after that… there was a gap. The next thing she knew, she had been shaken awake, finding herself sprawled out on the kitchen floor.

"Disapparated?" Hermione repeated.

Ginny's eyes were now round and fearful. "Can you PLEASE explain what's going on?"

"Going on?" Hermione repeated.

Ginny seemed to be on the verge of tears. "I watched you disappear in front of my eyes in our kitchen. I had to run outside to tell Harry and Ron something was wrong—I don't even know if they understood me—I must have babbling some type of nonsense. Harry kind of just ran ahead of us, but by the time we all got back, you were lying on the floor with a packed bag next to you! I swear I thought I was going mad! I mean, this is in our house! If there's some strange enchantment we're under or dark magic—"

"I'm sure it's nothing like that," Hermione interrupted. But the truth was that she had no idea what to make of it. Her mind was now racing, attempting to fit this new bit of information into her head. She was gathering pieces of possible explanations. How strange that she did not feel panicked, simply...peculiar. Perhaps it was because it felt so far away, because she did not remember—had not felt—this disappearance that Ginny was talking about.

"You don't sound so sure," Ginny said. "But you were lying to me before, weren't you? There's definitely something going on. Unless you want me to believe that just the two of us are losing it."

Hermione could not see how she could deny it this time. Not if as Ginny had said, she had really "disappeared." She looked at Ginny. "I thought you left the room though."

"I did…but I came back like a second later. Did you really think I would leave you alone after what you said? But now it feels like I've been roped into something. We should really tell Mum. Maybe she'll know what's going on."

"I don't think so," Hermione said, shaking her head. "This seems beyond just some spell or enchantment. Maybe even beyond magic." She looked intensely into Ginny's face and the ghostly, unintelligible voice filled her head with whispers. "But I can feel it. This has something to do with…Harry."

"Harry?"

Hermione felt her heart beating faster. And for just an instant, her mind became the tiniest bit clearer. Hearing the words come out of her mouth made her certain.

"Yes," she breathed. "It has something to do with him."

She moved her arms around a clearly confused Ginny and squeezed tight. "Thanks for your concern, Ginny. I'm still not completely sure what's going on. But I promise I'll find out. And when I do, you'll be the first to know."


Back in the compartment of the Hogwarts Express, Hermione waited for Harry to walk back in. But the sun had begun to set and he had still not returned. Finally, the compartment door slid open and she eagerly turned her head towards the corridor. She stifled her disappointment when she saw Neville by himself.

"Neville? Where's Harry?" she asked.

Neville frowned. "He said he wanted to check something."

Hermione frowned back. "What could there possibly be to check?" She turned to Ron. "What do you think he's up to?"

Ron shrugged.

"Brilliant," she snapped. She pushed her irritation to the side to think. What on earth was he up to? Honestly, he could be so exhausting sometimes.

They all soon changed into their robes and eventually, the train stopped. But Harry had still not returned.

"Why hasn't he come back?" Hermione asked the others in the compartment.

"He probably went ahead without us," Ron said.

"But why?" she stressed, struggling to see the logic.

"Maybe he got called to do something. Professor told him something or—"

"It's probably nothing," Neville said.

"Or he could be stuck," Luna remarked casually.

Hermione, Ron and Neville turned their heads towards Luna.

"Why would you say that?" Hermione said.

"I suppose a Kocky Snorgle got him?" Ron remarked sarcastically.

"The Crumple-Horned Sn—" Luna began.

"Not the time, Luna," Hermione snapped. "You think someone attacked him?"

"Attacked?" Luna said with surprise. "I said stuck. There are quite a lot of people on the train, you know. Maybe he got caught—"

"By someone after him?" Neville said.

"—between them," Luna finished. "He probably can't move since they're all so close together. It can get very crowded, you know."

"Oh!" Neville suddenly remarked. "He was putting on a cloak after we came out of Slughorn's."

At these words, Hermione and Ron glanced at each other with knowing looks. Now, it certainly seemed possible that Harry had gotten himself into a troublesome situation.

Hermione felt a slight tremor in her head and Luna's words repeated themselves in her mind until the ghostly voice that had been in her all summer repeated one word over and over again. Stuck. Stuck. Stuck. Stuck. Stuck. Stuck.

She abruptly stood up. "I'm going looking for him," she said to the others.

"I'll go too," Ron said.

"I need you to cover for me in case it takes longer than I thought."

"We could search more ground if both of us went," Ron pointed out. "And if he's really in trouble—"

"You'll need to take our luggage out to the platform. And…I need someone to watch Crookshanks."

"If you think I'm really going to let you go off by yourself—"

"I can take care of myself, Ron!"

"I wasn't saying you couldn't! But—"

"It's probably nothing anyway. I'll find him quickly and we'll be right out. And if it takes just a little longer…save us seats," she said, making her way out the door and waving to a bemused Neville and Luna.

Ron glared.

As the rest of the students began to exit the train, Hermione briskly walked down the corridors, squeezing past the stragglers and keeping her eyes open for the untidy hair she knew so well. When he still seemed to be evading her vision, she proceeded to check every compartment she came across from then on, keeping in mind that he could be invisible. "Harry?" she called into a seemingly empty compartment.

There was no response.

"Harry?" she called into a seemingly empty compartment.

There was no response.

"Harry?" she called into a seemingly empty compartment.

There was no response.

"Harry?" she called into a seemingly empty compartment.

There was no response.

"Harry?" she called into a seemingly empty compartment.

There was no response.

"Harry?" she called into a seemingly empty compartment.

There was no response.

The train was empty now. Hermione briefly wondered whether if Harry had simply left early and she was wasting her time, worried out of her mind for nothing. But the voice in her head spoke up. Still here, still here, still here.

She came upon a compartment with the blinds drawn. And she was met with a pain in her head. Dreading what she would possibly find inside, she took a deep breath, thought of Harry, seized the door and slid it open.

It was empty.

The pain in her head grew and she felt a heaviness in her chest.

"Harry!" she called.

There was no response.

She frowned and stepped in, slowly inching forward. Her foot hit something. She instantly sensed what to do and bent down, grasping the seemingly empty space in front of her. Her fingers found fabric. Heart beating faster, and Harry's face clear in her head, she pulled her arm back and found a body lying curled up on the floor.

There he was. Stuck.

She shrieked. It was his face. But it was red all over. She slowly came to the terrifying realization that it was blood.

"Harry! What happened?" She dropped to her knees and attempted to wipe away the blood with her hands in panic. But she only succeeded in smearing it over the small, unmarked corners of his face so that now, every part of his face was red. Her breathing soon stabilized and she assessed the sight in front of her. Harry's eyes were darting around helplessly but he did not speak. His nose was bent out of shape, still slowly dripping blood into his open mouth. As the shock wore off, she realized that he could not make a sound from the Full Body-Bind Curse he was under. She took out her wand and pointed it at him, preparing to release him from the curse.

"Drop it!" a new voice said.

Hermione froze. Despite the warning, she gripped her wand harder and slowly began to turn around, keeping her knees to the ground.

"Hermione?" the voice said.

It took Hermione a few seconds to place the voice. "Tonks?" She completed her turn and found herself looking up at the young Auror's surprised face.

"What are you doing here?" they both said at the same time.

Tonks took a moment to take in the sight, seeing Hermione crouched over Harry, still frozen.

"Am I…interrupting something?" Tonks asked with confusion.

"No," Hermione said. What could she possibly have been interrupting in this current position? "He didn't show up and I went looking. I just found him like this."

Tonks glanced over Harry and seemed to finally notice all the blood. She pointed her wand, there was a flash of red light and Harry, now able to move once again, scrambled to his feet, avoiding the eyes of both Hermione and Tonks. "Thanks," he muttered.

Now also rising to her feet, Hermione pointed her own wand at Harry's face. "Hold still. Tergeo." The blood was cleansed off Harry's face.

"How did you know I was here?" Harry asked her.

Still slightly shook and feeling that it would be a bad idea to answer honestly and say, "The voice in my head," Hermione shrugged. "Got lucky, I suppose. Why were you here though?"

"We can talk later," Tonks interrupted. The train had begun to move again. Harry quickly picked his Cloak off the ground and the three of them all ran out the compartment and into the corridor. Tonks soon pulled open the exit door. "Jump," she told them and leapt out on to the platform. Harry quickly followed and landed with a wobble. He turned back around expectantly. The train had now started to speed up. Hermione prepared to jump off but as she did, the train gave a small lurch which resulted in her losing her footing. Her mouth formed an o-shape and her eyes widened as she felt herself falling forward. She heard Harry and Tonks yell out her name.

Her face was then smothered as a pair of arms wrapped around her. She continued to fall forward for a second longer before a hand steadied her. She lifted her head from the chest it had been pressed up against and found herself staring into the green eyes she knew so well. She was safe.

"Okay?" Harry murmured.

"Yes," she managed to say, catching her breath. "Thanks." He loosened his grip and stood apart from her.

Tonks patted them both on the back before addressing Harry. "Stand still. I'll fix your nose."

Harry did so. Tonks pointed her wand once more at him and said, "Episkey." He raised his arm and felt around his face. "Thanks!" he said. He then seemed to remember his embarrassment from earlier and shifted his eyes away, apparently wanting to look anywhere else rather than at the two of them.

"We'll have to walk back up to the school," Tonks said to them. She waved her wand and summoned a silver four-legged beast. Hermione and Harry watched as it glided off towards the castle.

"Was that a Patronus?" Hermione asked interestedly.

Tonks nodded. "I'm sending word that I've found Harry." She motioned to the path ahead of them. "Let's go. I would say to get under the Cloak but since there's two of you, it might make the walk a bit more difficult. But be ready to scramble under it just in case something happens."

Hermione briefly considered pointing out that if it was just her and Harry, they could very well fit under the Cloak without trouble, especially if they pressed themselves closer together. But she held back. "How does sending messages with Patronuses work?" she instead asked a couple minutes into their walk. Tonks began to explain the theory and technique behind it as Hermione listened with fascination. After a few minutes however, Hermione remembered what she had been intending to ask at first. "What were you doing there, Tonks? Did you run into Ron and he told you about us?"

"Ron? No, I must have missed him," Tonks said. "I'm stationed outside Hogsmeade now. Security. And I noticed Harry hadn't left the train yet. Figured I should look around."

"Lucky you did. And lucky Hermione found me," Harry spoke up.

Hermione met his eyes and saw him look away. But she responded to him in her head. Always. Always. Always. The ghostly voice that was not hers but had taken up residence in her mind joined in the chant, as if reaffirming her resolve. Always. Always. Always. No matter where, even if he was cursed so he could not move, even if he was struck dumb so he could not answer back, she would search until she found him. Always. Always. Always.

"Who did it to you, Harry?" Tonks asked.

"Draco Malfoy," Harry and Hermione said at the same time. His green eyes were back on her. They had widened at the same time as her own brown ones at her response.

"How did you know?" Harry asked Hermione in shock.

"Lucky guess," she mumbled. "But when? When could he have found the time?"

Even through the darkness and the small amount of light that illuminated their path, Hermione noticed a faint shade of red appearing on Harry's face.

"I snuck into his compartment under the Cloak and got caught."

"But why?" Though as Hermione asked, she felt as if she knew the answer to this as well.

"I thought he might let something slip about what he's up to while talking with his mates."

"Harry!" she cried with exasperation.

They were silent for a while after as they continued the trek back to the castle. Noticing the uncomfortable silence, Hermione chanced a glance at Tonks. She looked miserable, a far cry from the way she had been the year before, and Hermione had a very good idea why.

"Are you…okay, Tonks?"

Tonks blinked slowly and turned to her. "I'm fine."

"It…it wasn't your fault, you know." Hermione sensed Harry, who had mostly maintained his silence up to this point, freeze up beside her. But as Hermione continued to gaze at Tonks, she noticed the Auror's expression change to one of befuddlement.

"…What?" Tonks said.

For the first time, doubt entered Hermione's mind regarding this matter. But sensing Harry's uneasiness, she did not dare to utter Sirius's name out loud.

"Well…" Hermione began, starting to feel nervous and wondering how much she should say. "It's been kind of noticeable how you've been feeling and you know…I'm really sorry it happened but you can't blame yourself. Things are out of your control sometimes." A look of realization seemed to dawn on Tonks's face.

"I…think you're mistaken about something, Hermione."

"…What?"

"I'm sorry you kids noticed. I should have been more guarded," Tonks said, looking away. "But how I feel now is not a relatively important issue in the grand scheme of things."

"Can you elaborate?"

Tonks shook her head. "I shouldn't burden you with knowledge of my problems. And you're too young. You wouldn't understand."

"I'm almost of age!" Hermione protested. "And besides, it's not like you're some old grandmother either. You're still young yourself!"

There was a moment of silence. "…So I've been told," Tonks said. There was an unmistakable trace of bitterness in her answer.

"People are not taking you seriously at work because of your age or something?" Hermione guessed.

"Something like that," Tonks muttered. There were another few seconds of awkward silence. "…But it's more like when you're dealing with someone who has so much self-doubt, they won't believe you even when you reassure them over and over that some things don't matter."

Hermione's state had now moved from doubt to pure confusion. "…Who are we talking about?"

Tonks shook her head. She looked from Hermione to Harry, who was now clearly uncomfortable, and back to Hermione. "I don't think you'll have this issue at any rate. Things being unrequited, I mean."

It was Hermione's turn to now look at Harry and she could tell he was just as confused, if not more, than she was at Tonks's cryptic words.

They had now finally arrived in front of the castle gates which were chained shut.

Harry took out his wand. "Alohomora!" he said, pointing to the locks.

Nothing happened.

Hermione turned to him with exasperation. "We wouldn't be safe here at Hogwarts if it was that simple." She regretted saying such a thing upon noticing the expression of annoyance on his face.

"Someone's coming to get you," Tonks said.

Hermione and Harry turned their heads towards the approaching source of light. And seconds later, the foreboding form and sneering face of Severus Snape greeted them from the other side. He took out his wand and tapped the chains, causing them to withdraw upwards and allowing the gates to open with a low groan.

"What a surprise, Potter," Snape said, in a tone that indicated he was not surprised in the least. "Nice of you to finally decide to grace the school with your presence." He glanced over Harry's Muggle clothes. "But of course, you seem to have deemed yourself above such things as appropriate attire."

"I couldn't change," Harry started. "I—"

"You may leave, Nymphadora," Snape said, interrupting Harry and completely ignoring Hermione. "I can take him from here."

Tonks frowned. "I meant Hagrid to get the message."

"Hagrid was unavailable at the time. So the ever-so-pleasant task of retrieving latecomers fell to me," Snape said in a bored voice. "I noticed your new Patronus by the way."

Hermione and Harry tilted their heads. New Patronus?

"You were better off with the old one," Snape continued. "This one looks…weak," he spat.

Tonks did not answer. Hermione and Harry stepped forward and heard the gates shut behind them.

"Bye, Tonks," Hermione said softly.

"Thanks for everything," Harry said.

"Bye, you two," Tonks said in a hollow voice. She turned around and disappeared into the darkness.

As soon as Tonks was out of sight, Snape turned on Harry and Hermione. "Now, what reason could there have been for the two of you to decide that showing up for the feast like everybody else was such a low priority?"

"Please, Professor," Hermione spoke up. "We were—"

"I wasn't finished, Miss Granger. Don't interrupt," Snape said softly, causing Hermione to shut up at once even though it had seemed like Snape had been quite finished. He turned his eyes to her. "Incidentally, I must say I'm a bit surprised. I had thought you always seemed too much of a spineless stickler for the rules to get yourself caught up in such affairs." He sneered at the pinned prefect badge on the front of her robes, shining under the lantern's light. "I would have assumed the position of prefect meant more to you."

"You asked a question, didn't you?" Harry said with gritted teeth. "She was just answering you."

"Manners, Potter," Snape said with a sudden, dangerous glint in his eyes. "I am as you say, asking the question, now. Why were you late? Why did you not get off the train at the same time as everybody else?"

"It wasn't his fault, Professor," Hermione started again. "It was—"

Harry grabbed her hand and squeezed. She fell silent and glanced at his face. He gave a very small, almost imperceptible shake of his head. He obviously did not want to let Snape know why he had been late.

Snape's eyes fell on their entwined fingers and his well-practiced sneer came across his face. "Touching."

The implication made Hermione turn red but she made no effort to let go of Harry's hand. She was however, now bemoaning the fact that the heat she was feeling all over seemed to be causing her to perspire.

"Famous Harry Potter thinks his own romantic escapades more important than the rules. But of course…" Snape turned to Hermione with a smirk. "He was with the one causing his…secret heartache…"

At Snape's reference of the dreadful article from their fourth year, Hermione chanced a glance at Harry's face. She could see from the glow of the lantern that he seemed to have now caught on to what was being suggested. His face turned a little red and he quickly let go of her hand.

"Or…perhaps that story is preferable to me finding out what was really going on," Snape mused. His gaze seemed to pierce through to Hermione's head and she remembered what Harry had said before. How he had sometimes felt as if Snape could read his mind.

Her head began to throb. A look of inexplicable malice had now come over Snape's face as he looked from Harry to Hermione. There was a pounding in her head and the ghostly voice had returned. It's him! It's him!

Hermione quivered, resisting every urge to raise her arms to her head. She did not know what was causing this pain. She could not shake the feeling that Snape could see into her mind and she desperately tried to lock away the voice that was screaming about him. Stop him! Stop him! the voice wailed.

She let out a fearful whimper, causing Harry's head to turn towards her as Snape raised an eyebrow.

"What's wrong?" Harry asked.

She shook her head. Definitely not in front of Snape. The pain finally receded.

Snape's lips curled to form his most revolting sneer yet. "You know what I think? I think you two are a pair of nasty little liars who have let your reputations get to your egos. You imagine yourselves to be far more special than you actually are. Potter here has perhaps realized that Weasley was not up to the task of being such an important sidekick and decided to recruit Ms. Know-It-All to his cause of drawing as much attention as possible to serve his overinflated head."

Hermione was growing shocked. Where was all this coming from? Why did Snape seem so particularly incensed right now? "Professor, as I was saying—"

"I thought I told you not to interrupt me, Miss Granger," Snape hissed.

Hermione could feel Harry's anger radiating from his body. She cast a worried glance over him. Please hold your tongue, Harry! she thought.

"I had assumed," Snape continued. "that perhaps the loss of a hundred House points and having Gryffindor start off the term in negative figures so early might be enough of a deterrent for the future. But I think to ensure that something like this never happens again, we need to go a step further. Losing points does not seem to be much of a concern for you two."

"Wh-what do you mean?" Hermione asked, suddenly fearful.

"Detention, Miss Granger," Snape said. "This Saturday, my office. The both of you."

Hermione only vaguely registered her mouth dropping. Detention?! Her?! She was holding on to the last of her senses, keeping herself from spiraling completely from this injustice. Surely this was an unprecedented level of unfairness!

"For what?" Harry suddenly spoke up angrily. "The term hasn't even started yet, you—"

"Harry, no!" Hermione moaned, grabbing his arm to silence him.

"As predictable as always, Potter," Snape sneered. "Well, you definitely deserve one now. Any objections, Miss Granger?"

Hermione shamefully shook her head, still holding on to Harry who was apparently struggling not to shake in anger. She had not been imagining it; Snape seemed nastier than ever. What was going on? What was triggering him?

"I would advise you to…keep your nose clean, Potter. It would be a sight to behold to see you being humble and keeping your head down for once." He shot the pair of them another malicious glare. "But of course…like father, like son."

Soon, they all stood outside the doors of the Great Hall. Hermione and Harry could hear the chatter of the other students enjoying the feast.

"Well? What are you two waiting for? It's time for your…grand entrance," Snape said with a nasty smile.

They stepped forward. Hermione could still sense Harry raging next to her. She noticed his hand drifting under his robes.

"No Cloak," Snape's voice said from behind them. "Surely, you wouldn't want to deprive the other lowly students the opportunity of laying their eyes on you, Potter."

Without looking at Hermione, Harry marched through the doors walking as fast as he could. Hermione hesitated, then sped up after him.

Her face turned scarlet as she felt the eyes of everyone in the Hall turn to them. There were some low mutterings and several snickers—people undoubtedly drawing wild conclusions why the pair of them were arriving late. The fact that Harry had still not managed to change into his robes did not seem to help. Harry quickly found a seat next to Ron. Hermione squeezed in on Ron's other side, aware that she might cause a further disturbance if she sat next to Harry right now, no matter how much she wanted to.

"What the—where have you two been?" Ron demanded.

"Later," Harry muttered, his eyes darting around the Gryffindor table. Hermione also became aware of the multitude of people who seemed very keen on eavesdropping. She caught Ginny's bemused expression among others. Ron was still suspiciously turning his eyes between the pair of them. Hermione began to panic. Maybe she should have sat next to Harry after all. Ron had seemingly caught on that she was keen on avoiding Harry at the moment and she did not want to think about the conclusions he could draw.

"Look mate," she heard Ron say to Harry. "I got to tell you something."

Hermione's ears perked up.

"I'm really sorry, but when I was transporting your trunk, something happened."

"What?" Harry said in puzzlement.

"Well," Ron began apologetically. "Maybe I was trying to do too much at once but it was also really weird. There were loads of people and I…kind of lost balance or something. Maybe there was something off about the platform or maybe you didn't lock your trunk properly or—"

"Just shut up and tell me what happened," said Harry impatiently.

"…Your trunk kind of burst open and some stuff was broken. There was such a crowd already and people just kind of…ended up trampling some stuff," Ron said quietly. "Believe me, you weren't the only ones getting stares today, okay?"

"What's the damage?" Harry said with a sigh.

"Some bottles of ink, a crack in a cauldron and well—one of your books got a little damaged. Okay, more like completely destroyed…"

"Great first day," Harry grumbled.

"Really sorry, mate."

Harry's expression cleared. "No, I wasn't mad at you or anything—"

"Which book?" Hermione suddenly said, feeling her head spin at what she had just heard. But she sensed as if she already knew the answer.

"The new Potions one," Ron said.

"Ah well," Harry said. "I'm still kind of holding out hope that I won't need it."

Hermione felt as if she was going to be sick. What was going on? She knew that what she had just heard was significant but the exact reason why seemed to be lost on her. The pain in her head had returned and unbelievably, something was telling her this was not a coincidence.

She silently reached for some food to distract her but all the main courses disappeared and were replaced by desserts. She grumpily reached for a plate of pudding and was silent for the rest of the feast.

It was not long then before Dumbledore stood up, causing all the talk to stop.

"Greetings," Dumbledore beamed. He held out his arms and Hermione saw at once, his blackened right hand.

"What's wrong with his hand?" she gasped. Several others in the Hall began to whisper.

But Dumbledore did not seem to sense it was a pressing concern. "Nothing to worry about," he said with a smile still on his face. He proceeded to give his end-of-the-feast speech, the usual topics passing by—restrictions, logistical Quidditch concerns and the like. And then Hermione sensed it coming.

"We have a new staff member this year. Professor Slughorn here," Dumbledore motioned to Slughorn who stood up and nodded his head. "…is a former colleague of mine who has graciously agreed to come out of retirement and resume his old post of Potions master."

"Potions?" The word was repeated by several people in confusion. Hermione was not surprised. And as she looked at Harry, noticed he also, while clearly unhappy about the announcement, did not seem surprised in the slightest.

Dumbledore eventually finished his speech and Hermione snapped back to her senses as she ran ahead to guide the new first-years, leaving Ron with Harry. She could talk with them later. Her ears picked up several snickers and mentions of "…Potter and Granger" as she tried her best to ignore the voices. There would be plenty of time for talk later with Harry, she thought as her face reddened.


Harry had just finished telling Hermione what he had overheard Malfoy saying back on the train.

"But he was just talking big. Showing off for Parkinson," Ron said.

Hermione frowned. "Well… he's certainly prone to that, but…I think, maybe—Ow!"

Harry and Ron looked at her. "What's wrong?" they said simultaneously.

"My head," she muttered. There was now a ringing in her mind at the thought of Malfoy.

She spotted a younger student in front of her holding something green and snarling in his hand. "Hold it!" she managed to say. "Fanged Frisbees are banned, hand it over."

The boy shot her a scowl but placed it into her hand. He ran off and it was not long before Ron grabbed the confiscated frisbee for himself.

"Excellent, I've always wanted one of these," he said happily.

"Ron, honestly—" Hermione started to say. But she was interrupted by a loud giggle. She turned her head just in time to see the source of the noise and watched as Lavender Brown shot Ron a wide smile that made Hermione inexplicably feel like narrowing her eyes. Her head began to hurt at the sight of her fellow sixth-year. She gritted her teeth. This was all starting to get very annoying. Was she going to have to deal with these stupid headaches all term long? They would undoubtedly…disturb her studies.


"Do you remember me telling you we are practicing nonverbal spells, Potter?" Snape leered, rubbing his wrist. Hermione glanced worriedly at Harry. It seemed a subject change did not mean Snape's tendency to pick on Harry would subside.

"Yes," Harry said, barely moving his lips.

"Yes, sir," Snape said icily.

"There's no need to call me 'sir,' Professor."

Hermione gasped. She was not the only one. What was he thinking?

"Detention, Next Saturday night. My office. Perhaps you would like to try for the whole term, Potter. Reminder that you already have one this Saturday along with Miss Granger."

For what seemed to be the umpteenth time, Hermione once again felt her face turn red as several heads swiveled around to look at her. Why did he have to mention her?

"You got detention?" Ron asked Hermione incredulously once the lesson was over. "What for?" Apparently, neither she nor Harry had remembered to mention this to Ron.

"It's ridiculous!" Harry said. "She didn't do anything! Snape's just a f—"

"Harry, it's fine," Hermione said hurriedly, preventing the swear from leaving Harry's mouth.

Harry suddenly seemed troubled, remembering that night. He looked at her guiltily. "Sorry I got you detention."

Hermione shrugged. "I was starting to think I had missed out for too long on this essential experience of schooling life. It's already been what, five years? In a way, I'm glad it happened. Intellectual curiosity, you know?" She smirked. "But yes, it was all your fault, wasn't it?"

Harry held up his hands in mock surrender. "Completely my fault. Really sorry."

"At least we'll be together during it," she said. The words were out of her mouth before she could stop herself.

Ron raised an eyebrow as he looked between them.

Harry stared at her curiously.

Hermione blushed.