It's Jonathan's birthday, and Jarvis enlist the help of Barbara Gordon and her super-powered friends to help him make it the best birthday Jonathan's ever had

Jarvis sits at his desk writing down plans, feverish determination gleaming his eyes, as he finishes the last of the notes he leans back and wipes his brow from sweat. Jarvis looks down at his plans and smiles and satisfaction, the plans for operation scarecrow Palooza are perfect

...

At Sweet Justice, Barbara Gordon and her friends are eating ice cream after a successful fight with the forces of evil, but before Barbara is done with her Bowl, the sound of a chair being scraped against the floor of the restaurant in the direction of their table is heard, to which she looks over and sees Jarvis tetch, is hair disheveled and his eyes crazier than ever. But before any of the girls can say anything Jarvis plops a large stack of papers on to the table and begins to speak rapidly," hey girls, can you help me with something it's Jonathan's birthday I want to make it special", the group of girls takes a second to absorb everything that was just that before getting simultaneous tentative nods," good, all the instructions are in that stack of paper we need to legislate I'm stupid to work among yourselves, as for me I'll be the one distracting Jonathan"

and before the girls know it Jarvis is gone, Karen picks up the stack of papers gingerly and start leafing through them

...

Barbara flips through the guest list, calling the numbers and when the guest picks up singing a little song that goes as such " dear friend, do not be late, for today is a very important date, Scurry upon your paws or claws, for the day of a scarecrow's Birth has donned", and like clockwork the person being called responds in a monotone " I accept this invitation" and quickly hangs up

...

Karen stands nervously in a line holding a medium sized chocolate cake, when she finally gets to the checkout counter she pays quickly and rushes out the front doors

...

zee is stuffing a shopping cart's worth of snacks and drinks into the backseat of Jessica's car

...

Jessica stands at the front desk of the Party Store arms weighed down by the weight of the hodgepodge of Halloween and party decorations that she's holding

...

Kara drags an unconscious bald man through the Skies of Gotham

...

The group of girls a busy decorating the house for the birthday when there's a knock at the front door, when Barbara answer that in front of her is a group of all blank eyed people all holding presence of different sizes and colors, one of them a boy in the green shirt that's covered in question marks who's also wearing a pair of Party City Mouse ears, begin speaking in a monotone " we're here for the party"

a couple minutes later after the group of blank eyed People Help the girls set up the party, Jarvis and Jonathan walk into their house, Jonathan wearing a blindfold being led by Jarvis." all right sweetie I'm going to take off the blindfold" Jarvis said as he gingerly slips the blindfold from his boyfriend's eyes who after a couple seconds registered the site in front of him, " Jarvis" Jonathan turns to his boyfriend before embracing him in a hug " this is wonderful!" Jonathan exclaimed as he twirled his boyfriend in a hug

after some wonderful minutes of partying, Jonathan lies on living room couch exhausted, in one of his hands is a Dixie cup food respite which is half drunk, he's attempted to take another sip is interrupted by the voice of his boyfriend calling from their room " Johnny sweetie come up I have another present for you" Jonathan perks up at the seductive tone Jarvis said that sentence in, putting down the cop on the coffee table he power walks upstairs to their shared bedroom

when he opened the door the side he sees causes his penis to stir, in front of him and his boyfriend wearing Lacy blue lingerie with a leather caller wrapped tightly around his throat, in one hand he holds a black bag to which Jonathan feel slight confusion until he takes in the scene upon the bed. Upon that bed lies Hugo Strange, naked except for boxes a look of Terror in his eyes any pleas for help he may make on Silence by the duct tape upon his mouth, Jonathan struts into the room, and Jarvis hands him the bag. When he takes a peek inside he sees an assortment of torture tools, Jonathan looks up to his boyfriend a Sinister smile splitting both of their lips