I tied down all four of them. Elena and Caroline were tied to chairs on one side. Damon and Stefan were tied to chairs on the other. They were split apart. Caroline was more on the side, while Elena was in the middle, facing both Stefan and Damon. I had tied down their ropes magically, so they couldn't break it, no matter how hard they tried.
They all eventually start to wake up at the same time, and my face turns excited. I start to grab my bag and pull out the water gun.
"Good! You're all awake." I say cheerfully.
"What the hell are you doing?" Damon asked me, and I looked at him.
"Having fun! I mean with all the death going on lately, I figured we could use some fun." I said in a happy voice.
"Why can't I break out of this?" Caroline asks.
"Because it's magically bonded by one of the most powerful witches to exist. But be my guest, try to break out and exert your energy." I state and she looks at me frustrated.
"Kalle, I understand that you're angry—" Stefan begins.
"Angry is an understatement." I state crossing my arms.
"But you already sent Katherine after the cure, and she killed Jeremy. You two are even." Stefan points this out, and I look at him like he's lost his mind.
"Even? Oh no. We are very far from even." I say irritated.
"Whatever you want to do with me, leave my friends out of it." Elena states, and I look at her with a smile.
"Oh, I will gladly leave Caroline out of it. I mean if I touched a hair on head, Nik would probably loose his mind over it, since you are precious to him for some reason." I state, before facing Damon and Stefan. "But these two? No, no neither one of these two are your friends."
"What are you talking about?" Damon says annoyed.
"So glad you asked. I thought we should play a game! You see, when my brother was killed, I felt my heart actually shatter. He was my other half and you killed him." I explained and made my way to Elena. I leaned on the armrest so we were facing each other eye to eye. "I lost the closest person to me for a millennium. You do not get to compare that pain to losing a brother you've known for what? Sixteen years? You think you understand pain, Elena, but you don't know real pain."
I can see her eyes getting more and more furious with me, and I move back towards the middle of the room again. "So! The game is called, which Salvatore do you love more! It is basically a game where I torture both of them, and you have to choose which one gets to live!"
"What?" Caroline asks.
"I'm not doing that." Elena states.
"Well then I guess you are both going to die today." I state, facing the two of them.
"Stop! This has nothing to do with them!" Elena screams and I turn around to face her.
"It has everything to do with them. Your love for Stefan was something I have never seen before. A love that could last a lifetime. And yet, you somehow broke up with him for Damon. Meaning that you somehow loved him more than your epic love, which is absolutely fascinating." I say placing my hand on my heart. "In all honesty, I think I'm doing them a favor. Who ever you don't pick does not have to live for the rest of eternity in heartbreak."
"Don't listen to her, Elena. She doesn't kill." Damon remarks, and I look back.
"Excuse me?"
"I've seen how you are. I have never seen you really kill just because you wanted to. You kill because you have to, and you're not going to kill one of us just because your mad that they killed your brother." Damon explains and I make my way up to him.
"You really are undermining my love for my brother. But hey, the saying goes 'don't believe it until you see it.' And if that is what it takes.." I state, backing up with my water gun. "Than so be it."
I then start spraying Damon and Stefan with my vervain-filled water guns, and they both scream in anguish. I can tell they're holding back how much it hurts, but I know it hurts way more than they're letting on.
"Is this believable enough for you?" I question, as I continue to spray. I can see Elena trying to not look, but I know she cannot bare to see either one of them like this.
"STOP STOP STOP!" Elena screams and I stop spraying. "Please. Please I will do anything, but stop."
"All you have to do is choose Elena. Stefan or Damon." I state and she looks between both of them.
I can see her mouth moving, but no words come out. Then I see her look at Damon with sadness. And she seems really sad for some reason, way more than she does for Stefan. But now I look at Stefan's face, seeing him annoyed.
"What's going on?" I questioned and none of them answered. "I get that you love Damon now, but why are you more concerned about him than Stefan? I would have figured your relationship left some kind of mark."
Silence fills the room, and nobody speaks. I decide to look at the most chatty person in the room, Caroline.
"Caroline, care to share what's going on?" I question. She shakes her head no and I nod. "Alright."
I then start spraying Caroline and she screams even louder than Damon and Stefan combined. I hear Elena screaming stop again but I still have not gotten my answer.
"She's sired!" Stefan finally yells, and I stop spraying. I look over to Stefan in confusion. "Elena's sired to Damon."
"What?" I say with a laugh. "Oh my god, it all makes sense now. Elena ran to Damon because she's sired to him. Damn, that's got to hurt Damon."
"Go to hell." Damon stated angrily.
"Trust me, I will but not today. Maybe you will though." I state, going to my bag to put away my water gun and pulling out a stake. "This has been moving too slowly and I think it's time we speed up the process."
"I am not choosing." Elena states.
"Yeah, you've made that clear. And this sire bond thing makes things complicated, so here is what we are going to do now." I state, walking towards Damom, and placing the stake digging at his heart.
"NO!" Elena screams at me.
"You either choose who you want to save Elena...or you choose to let them both live...but you turn off your humanity." I state and they all look at me.
"What? She can't turn off her humanity." Caroline stated.
"Elena, don't do it. It's not worth it." Stefan pleaded, but Elena continued to look at him puzzled.
"Come on Elena. We both know deep down you want to turn it off. I mean aren't you tired of feeling the pain of people dying? Feeling the guilt of hurting others? You can turn it all off right now." I state.
"No Elena! She wants you to do this just so you will feel these regrets later—" Damon states but I push the stake in deeper in his heart.
"Tic tok Elena." I state.
I watch as Damon's body starts to slowly desiccate as the stake pierces his heart. I hear Stefan and Caroline screaming in the background, telling Elena 'to not do it'. 'That it's not worth it.' She will regret it and all of that. But I just keep my focus on Elena and Damon.
Damon seems like he wants to talk, but the pain of the desiccation is making it hard to. Then I look at Elena. Her eyes are filled with sadness. If Damon could speak, whatever he would ask, should would do. But he can't. So instead, Elena gives in.
"ENOUGH!" Elena screams, causing everyone to shut up. Her eyes shift to face me in anger. "I'll do it."
Once Elena says that, I stop pushing the stake into Damon's heart, but still leave it there.
"Glad we came to an agreement." I say with a smile, even though she is looking at me like I am the devil. At this point, she may not be way off.
"Elena do—" Damon starts but I cover his mouth.
"Ah ah ah. Anything that comes from your mouth, she listens to. Can't have that." I say, as Damon screams in my hand.
"Elena don't do it!" Stefan pleads and Elena looks up at him. "You will loose yourself, your love is what drives you. And you know Damon would say the same thing."
Elena looks over to Damon, who shakes his head in agreement, with my hand still over his mouth. She then looks at me with anger and frustration.
"Okay, Elena. Keep your humanity on, but then you're going to have to face the reality that all of your family members are dead." I state with a straight face, and her face goes from anger to sadness.
I know that was a low blow, but she has been involved in killing two of my brothers, tried to have the rest of my siblings killed many times, and had no remorse for any of it. This is just what Karma is.
"Shut up!" Caroline screams but I ignore her.
Elena then turns around to see her brother's corpse on the couch. That was the last straw. She closes her eyes as Stefan, Caroline, and even Damon mumbles in my hand, scream for Elena to stop.
But it is too late.
Once Elena turns around, she opens her eyes and they look emotionless. I smile at the sight.
"Looks like my work here is done." I state, as I lift my hand from Damon's mouth. They all look at Elena with defeat, as I grab my things. I think I have done enough damage for today.
"It's always a pleasure working with you, but I think I've overstayed my welcome." I state as I get my bag and walk towards the door. "The spell should be lifted in about an hour or so."
"You're a coward!" Damon yells at me.
"Call me all the names you want. But nobody messes with my family, and gets away scot-free. Remember that next time." I state as my final statement, before leaving the house.