Unfaithful

Chapter Three: Double Trouble

Elena Gilbert

"I can't do this." I mouthed to John who smirked in response.

Suddenly all I could focus on was this moment and what was about to happen if I didn't speak up and say I didn't want this. Yet just like last night I said nothing at all and in response everything began to get out of hand.

"I'm not so sure about this, John. If the wife found out-"

"Nate, come on, how will she find out?"

"Right."

"I'm just saying, if she found out-"

"What makes you think she'll ever find out?"

"True"

"Just enjoy yourself."

"I'm not sure-"

"You're not backing out, are you Nate?"

"No. No, of course not. I'm in."

John looked at me and nodded.

"What is happening?" I mouthed.

John just shook his head and then smiled at me before a pair of hands reached for my hips turning me upright until I was on my knees with my hands gripping John's thigh. This wasn't happening, I wasn't about to be bent over by a married man who got his rocks off to the idea of an Uncle and a Niece having an affair. Nate didn't say anything to me and neither did John as Nate began to caress my ass cheeks though my funeral dress.

"Fuck me, she's got like the perfect ass." Nate commented and I felt John's fingers in my hair, he stroked it softly as Nate groped my ass.

"You want her on her back or hands and knees?"

"Figured she'd have her mouth busy on you."

"If she can handle all that meat."

Nate paused "Why doesn't she talk?"

"She likes to pretend she's still a good girl. But good girls don't suck vampire dick last I checked."

Nate groaned and reached for the zipper of my dress causing me to grip John's thigh in response of the uncertainty.

"Don't be scared, Elena. Just relax, have fun"

I nodded not knowing what else to do.

"Make it quick Nate. Her boyfriend might come looking for her."

Nate's hand moved around to my stomach and then down towards the lace material of my panties.

"You like that don't you?" John said.

I nodded again.

"She's fucking hot, John. How'd you even score her? I mean you've been here less than a week."

"I guess I'm just lucky."

"You and me both" Nate muttered.

When Nate's fingers pushed into the fabric and his finger pressed against my clit I moaned and leaned into his touch unable to stop myself in a moment of weakness. What was wrong with me? He was a father and someone's husband. I couldn't possibly be doing this. But I was and the worst part of all was I didn't even seem to care.

"Slide them off." Nate said then.

At first I couldn't move, I had the strength to remain still but it quickly faded as it often did when I needed it most of all. I moved up onto my knees and slipped the panties down and then sat back on the floor as John stroked my hair.

"Open." Nate commanded.

I didn't even hesitate, I just opened my legs and let him see me, all of me, he reached forward and spread the lips and I moaned softly.

"Fuck she's pink down there."

John grinned "That's right, and so wet."

"I can tell."

Nate's index finger slid between the folds and he groaned as I clenched and my pussy pulsed.

"You're a natural at this." He whispered as his fingers pushed inside and I clenched tightly around them.

"Fuck me, John, she's tight. So fucking tight. Is she a virgin?"

"Was."

Nate groaned "And how long have you two been fucking?"

"I bent her over last night. Didn't take much convincing."

"No?"

"No."

"Hope you like getting ate out Elena." Nate commented before he was suddenly leaning forward and his face was buried between my thighs, his tongue was swirling around and his fingers were stretching me wide. I gripped John's thigh unable to produce words the only sound I could make as Nate began licking me was

"nnNNNNHHHHHNNNNNNAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAABBBBAAAAAAA"

My body shuddered and John's eyes widened as Nate's tongue was swirling all over my pussy.

He didn't stop instead he spread my ass cheeks open and began to take long licks from my slit to my asshole, and then back down to my pussy, his tongue was flicking all over me, his fingers were spreading me wide, and John was watching with a mixture of amusement and desire.

"Fuck that's hot."

"Pick up your leg." Nate instructed to me.

I did and suddenly he was thrusting his tongue inside, I cried out, gripping John's thigh tightly.

"Fuck"

"I can't wait to fuck this." Nate moaned against my lips before he was diving back in, his tongue pushing deep.

"God yes." John groaned as he watched Nate's tongue plunge into me.

I was so lost in the moment, so lost in the pleasure and the feel of his tongue on my clit. John's hands were moving in and out of my hair and the sensations of a tongue on my pussy and a hand in my hair was making this an experience I'd never forget.

Nate's tongue was plunging inside of me and John's dick was hardening as he watched us. I could hear the groans coming from his throat as he watched Nate's head move between my thighs.

"You're such a naughty girl Elena, taking a married man's tongue."

I cried out at his words, and he smirked. My tears pricked tears as I fought an approaching orgasm that felt beyond my control. It was taking everything within me not to moan and cry out the words that I kept within. This was a side of me I didn't know I had within me, the side that had no morals when desires took hold, that would risk everything if it would allow me to live within the sweet necture of this warm gushing feeling. I thought the sounds of Nate sloshing his tongue in and out of my pussy was the type of sound you heard on porn but not tonight. This was real it was me as a willing partisiphant. I'd never been so disgusted with myself in my entire life and yet I didn't stop me, it didn't even come close to slowing me down. But I knew I'd sooner die than have John know just how much the moment was consuming me within. I didn't want him to know that I was experiencing the truest pleasure of my life by seeing him rub his member to the image of a married man giving me oral sex. As long as I acted like the sounds I was making were purely out of instinct and surprise then I could keep enjoying the sweet bliss of this affair.

"nnnnnnnnnnuuuuuuuuuuuuugggggggggguuuuuuuu" I moaned and began panting like some sort of wild animal as Nate's tongue did something brand new and completely unfamiliar.

It was the sound of his tongue licking up my slit and then the slurping sounds of his tongue diving back inside of me. The sounds of his tongue sucking up my juices and swallowing them and then the sound of his lips smacking together. He was eating me out like he hadn't eaten a thing in weeks and I was his first meal.

"Fuck. Elena you taste so good."

Was that true? Did I actually taste sweet to him? Was I better than his wife? I did not just think that, that was beyond shameful, but then again so was what her husband was doing to me right now.

"Jesus you're really getting in there." John commented really seeming to get into this.

"She's got a deliciously tight little pussy and a sweet as candy flavor."

"Mmmm" John responded as his cock began throbbing.

"Oh, God." I cried out, unable to stop myself.

"You like that, don't you? You like a married man going down on you?"

I groaned and began to tremble and pant.

"That's right, keep moaning. Show me how much you like it."

I looked away from John and he didn't see me bit my lower lip in response to Nate kissing my inner thighs.

Behind me I heard Nate shift and suddenly his arms hooked around my thighs and he sank my centre downward catching me off guard. I flipped my back looking down between my legs finding him there, his lips pressed to my inner thighs, his tongue licking the length of me.

"Fuck."

"That's good Elena."

"You want more, don't you?"

"Nnngggghhh." I panted.

"Say you want more."

"nnNNNHHHUUUUUUUUUGHHH."

I couldn't believe I was begging for more, but I was.

I'd never had a man do this before, I'd never sat on Stefan's face before and had never considered such a thing. But now the idea of grinding on his face was something I desperately wanted.

"You're soaking, Elena."

"Please" I managed to gasp knowing I didn't want him to stop, that I wanted Nate to continue with everything inside of me.

"You're so wet" Nate said before he sucked my lips into his mouth and I gasped loudly.

"Oh, my God."

I looked over to John who was still pleasuring himself as he watched, I watched John's eyes looked down to my dress and he raised his brows and pointed his chin upward making me roll my eyes before reaching for my dress and pulling it upward and over my breasts, revealing my nipples which were hard and erect.

"Damn, Elena. Look at you" John said, and then groaned "Fuck"

My dress was pooled at my hips and I could see the hunger in Nate's eyes, the desire.

"That's right." Nate moaned.

"God, that's hot."

"Fuck Elena. Your pussy is so pink and tight. Mmm."

"Oh, my god" I panted as I continued to grind against his face, my ass bouncing up and down on his face.

Nate stopped catching me off guard with such force that I collasped over John's lap before I felt myself being yanked backwards by my hips.

"Don't come inside her." John warned.

Wait, no what? I didnt think that was even an opition. I waited Nate's response.

"Really?"

"No, it's not safe."

"But-"

"No, I can't have any little bastards running around."

"But it would be so fucking hot to cum inside her."

"Trust me. It's not a good idea."

"Well...how about...we take turns fucking her?"

"No. You'll be too rough."

"We'll go slow"

"She's still too tight. It'd tear her."

"What if we do it together?"

"That would kill her."

"So what then?"

"We can tag team her."

"Wait-" I gasped.

"Why not?"

"Cause it's fucked up."

"She's done worse, so has her boyfriend to this town. And his brother."

"Well, okay, yeah, fine, let's do it."

"Good."

"So how do you wanna do it?"

"Don't put it in her ass. She's not ready for that." John said as he began to position himself underneath me.

"John wait-" I gasped.

John seeing the look in my eyes then sighed "And don't come inside of her either."

"Why not?"

"I have reasons."

"Fine. Whatever, man."

"Okay. You ready to tag team her?"

"Fuck yeah"

"Let's do this."

"Wait. Wait. Wait. Hold on a second. John, are you sure we should-"

"I'm sure I wanna make you come, and come and come." John said to me and I believed him.

I couldn't do this, I couldn't let two men just suddenly-

Nate's hands gripped my hips and John's fingers slid inside of me, stretching me and preparing me.

"God you're gonna feel so fucking good around my cock" Nate growled.

"Yeah she is" John agreed.

"Fuck yeah she is."

"God."

"Mmm"

"She's ready" John said.

I couldn't see Nate only John beneath me but I heard him unzip and the length of his zipper should have been my first clue.

"Ready Elena?"

"I don't think we should be doing this" I said softly, almost shyly, and I was sure they both heard it, that I wasn't exactly thrilled at the thought of being a sandwich between two cocks.

"Just relax. It's gonna be okay." John assured me.

"Are you sure this is a good idea? I mean, she's really-"

"Nate, stop stalling. We've already gotten this far. Let's do this. We've gone through too much trouble to not do this. She wants it. Look at her, Nate, she wants it. You want it don't you Elena? You want it. Don't you?"

I hesitated before answering.

"Elena?"

"Yeah" I responded quietly.

Stefan, I love you please forgive me. It's only my body and not my heart, ever ever my heart.

"What was that?"

"Yes."

"Yes, what?"

"Yes, I want it."

"Then let's do this. Let's get our rocks off. Come on, Nate. Don't keep the lady waiting."

"Fuck. Okay. Yeah. I'm ready."

I was on my knees when Nate began pushing the head of his dick between the lips.

"Fuck." He moaned as his shaft began to slowly slip inside.

"Oh, God" I gasped as I felt him push all the way inside.

I couldn't believe what was happening, I couldn't believe how easy it was. How quickly my body had allowed his thick shaft to slip inside.

"Jesus, she's tight." Nate grunted when he finally got balls deep.

"You good?"

"Yeah. Fuck, this is tight."

"She's tight."

"Fuck yeah, she is. Damn, you're not lying, man."

"I told you."

"Mmm. That's right, Elena. You like being a slut, don't you?"

I didn't answer him, I hated how the word slut caused me to tighten between my legs.

"John I don't think you'll fit inside too bud." Nate said.

"We'll make it work."

"How are you even-"

"Don't worry about it, just focus on Elena."

"Oh, I'm focused. I'm very focused."

"Okay. Ready?"

I sank my head down to John's shoulder and screamed in agony as he pushed his way inside my pussy alongside Nate's member.

"Jesus" Nate groaned as John began to slip in and out slowly.

I never adjusted to them, I wasn't built to have two cocks inside of my pussy let alone two extremely thick and large cocks.

"FUCK." I cried out and dug my nails into John's shoulder and my teeth sank into his shoulder.

"Fuck"

"God yes"

"She's squeezing"

"Keep going"

"I'm not stopping. FUCK."

"Fuuuuuckkk"

John continued to carress my thighs as Nate's grip remained fixed upon my hips. They were both working in perfect unison, thrusting inside of me and working my pussy.

"Oh, my God."

"You feel so good Elena. So good."

"Jesus Christ" Nate moaned "Fuck, man she's perfect"

Nate bent over and carressed my ass cheeks as he laid small kisses on each of them before he began thrusting again.

"But this is nasty shit John even for you. Fucking your own niece."

John groaned and ran his hand through my hair as he bucked up into me.

"Would you fuck her if she was your niece?" John challenged.

"Fuck. Yes, I would." Nate said before he leaned forward and his hand came up to my breast before he began to spank me here and there between thrust.

Neither of them could see my face as the agony of two of them inside of me began to ease and I sadly began to adjust to their size and girth. My face remained buried in John's shoulder as my eyes rolled into the back of my head. I'd sooner die then let them know my body could withstand two extremely large cocks inside my pussy. I had never entertained the mere notion of it and yet here I was, and the fact that I was enjoying it was a truth I didn't want to admit to.

"Damn she feels so fucking good" Nate growled before his hand came down across my ass cheek and I bit down harder on John's shoulder, moaning and groaning at the sensations taking hold.

"She's not even trying to act into this." John groaned.

"Fake moans, know them too well." Nate admitted

They thought I was faking it, maybe I was. It didn't matter I was just a warm body between the two of them.

"She's good" Nate groaned and his hand came down on my other ass cheek, causing my hips to jolt forward and my breasts to bounce up and down.

"God damn it" Nate said.

"That's hot" John said before his fingers came up and pinched my nipples and rolled them between his thumb and forefinger.

I was being taken and fucked in ways I'd never expected, by men I'd never imagined would want me.

Nate whispered something to John then and John reached between my legs and parted my inner thighs apart more so the two of them could go deeper catching me off guard.

"Fuck" I gasped as they both thrust inside of me in one fluid motion.

"That's it." Nate groaned before his hand came down across my ass and I cried out and arched my back.

"That's my bitch" John commented as his dick pulsated and throbbed inside of me.

Nate's tongue began licking a trail up my spine and I shivered, arching my back further, allowing his mouth and tongue to taste me as they thrusted inside of me.

I wanted this, needed it, I loved the feel of their dicks sliding in and out but the second Nate let go of his hold on me I dropped like a stone over the top of John to make myself look exhausted which I wasn't if anything I was far from it.

"Damn" Nate laughed and shook his head "Guess we wore her out."

"Not yet, but we will." John assured him as they both continued with me.

John pulled my hair back from the side of my face nearest him and began licking me like an animal as the two men fucked me.

"Fuck" Nate moaned

"Shit" John said.

Nate groaned "How much to keep your mouth shut about this one John?"

"How about you pay for a boob job for her?"

What? John was serious about that? He'd said something last night but I hadn't taken him serious, I'd never make that mistake again.

"They are fuckin small" Nate admitted

They were talking about my beasts as they fucked me, and the only thing keeping me from getting pissed was the fact that they were doing a good job fucking me.

"And I'd be willing to pay a lot."

"I've always had a thing for small tits." John admitted.

"Me too"

"But-"

"She's still small."

Nate slapped my ass making me wince "Yeah she could improve them."

"A pair that says put me in your mouth I taste good." John noted

"But not watermelons, don't draw attention to her." Nate said "Plus when they're installed I want to test them."

Nate wanted me to get a boob job, my neighbourhood wanted me to get a boob job and worst he wanted to test them. What the hell?

"Mmmm, something tasteful but hard as rocks." John groaned before he kissed my cheek.

"Oh, she'll be a hot slut after we're through with her. A hot little slut."

"I'd risk it all for that ass" John commented before striking my ass cheek.

"She'd be worth the risk."

"Mm"

"Fuck"

"Damn"

"Oh, God"

"Yes, baby. Take our dicks. You can take 'em."

"Yeah, she can. She can. She's a natural born slut."

Stefan would kill them for speaking about me like this but he'd probably be more furious with them than me as I was willing and wanting to be here. If he opened the car door right now he'd see Nate with his trousers behind his ankles his ass clutching as he gave it me from behind while the funeral dress I was wearing bounced around my bare hips with my breasts exposed for both of them to enjoy and John remained buried under me spanking my now red ass cheeks. The idea of Stefan witnessing two large and thick cocks entering in and out of my pussy caused my pussy to spasm and clench and both men groaned.

"Oh, fuck!"

"Damn, she's a squirter."

"She is. She is."

"That's right. Squirt for me, Elena. Do it. Give it to me."

I was coming all over John's lap, my legs trembling and my arms shaking and yet they continued as I smirked against John's shoulder.

"Should have worn a condom." Nate groaned as he continued to thrust and spank.

"Yeah me too. But her problem not ours." John said before kissing my cheek.

"I've seen her naked plenty of times before this, she's beautiful."

"How'd you manage that?" John asked curiously.

"Stupid bitch walks by her bedroom window after she's done showering, never saw the pussy or ass just the tits."

"I'm jealous."

"You should be, nice tits and a fuckable ass."

"Mmm" John hummed in agreement

"Fuck, her pussy is gripping."

"It's a great pussy."

"Damn, I'm getting close."

"Go ahead, man."

"Fuck that I ain't giving up this bitch that easy." Nate groaned and lifted my knee up from behind, angling his cock into my g-spot.

"That's right" Nate growled putting more of a dip to his thrusts.

"You like that?" John asked.

"Oh, she likes that."

"You like it? Tell us, Elena. You like it?"

I never replied, but within a few minutes I found myself approaching another orgasm which neither of them noticed.

"Turn her over so she's lying on your chest, I wanna see those tits bounce as we share her."

John did just that and within seconds he had turned me over on his chest.

"Fuck her and play with those titties"

John was the first to slide back inside of me and Nate stood above me his dick bobbing before me and I couldn't help myself as I gripped his shoulders as he also slid inside next to John's powerful member.

"She stretches good now. But still needs-" Nate then made his mouth into an 'O' and allowed his spit to fall over my nipples "-that"

"Fucking nasty." John commented.

Nate smiled and grabbed ahold of my hips as he thrusted.

"God, her pussy is the best. Better than any of the women in town."

"You're telling me." John moaned

"Fuuuck"

"God"

"She's a keeper."

"Fuck"

Nate then leaned over me and took my breast into his mouth as John brought my lips against his from beneath me angling my head, not knowing that my eyes remained fixed on Nate as he licked and sucked.

"She's close"

"So am I" Nate moaned as he continued to suck on my breasts and the pleasure was driving me closer and closer to the edge, and then his finger dipped down and began rubbing and pinching my clit.

"Oh, God."

"She's coming"

"I feel it"

"Yes, baby. That's it. Let go. Come all over our cocks."

"Oh, fuck. I can't hold out."

"You gonna pull out?" Nate asked and John didn't reply.

I kept my eyes shut knowing the answer for both of them.

John didn't say anything as the three of us came together.

"Shit. Oh, God."

"Fuck, she's tight."

"I'm coming. Shit. Fuck."

"Elena. Fuck, yes, baby. Fuck. Elena, oh, God."

"Fuck. Oh, God. Oh, yes. Mmmm."

Nate pulled out first followed by John. Nate made me gasp as he inserted his fingers and began to scrap.

"The damage is done Nate." John told him.

Nate sighed "Fuck it's a lot." he said as the cum rolled out of me.

"Yeah and it's high up in there too." John said as he pulled me off the top of him and sat me beside him.

Nate got out of the car and walked around to John's side as I listened to both of them zip up.

I kept my head down the entire time, feeling their cum sliding out of me.

"What about her?" Nate asked

"Let her stay there, she'll be fine." John said and closed his door, leaving me in the backseat.

Nate knocked on the window and I looked at him.

"Hey. You good?"

I nodded.

"You're really gifted. You did good." Nate told me.

Did he mean that? Why did I need to know? What was wrong with me? Nate licked the corner of his lip before he opened the car door reaching over to bring me closer to him.

"Thanks for tonight." He said before he reached into his wallet, I felt sick as he handed me all the money inside.

I took it and smiled weakly.

"I'll be seeing you soon."

"Nate." I whispered but he closed the door and walked away.

I sat there for several minutes just staring at the money in my hands before I slipped my panties on, the wetness and stickiness causing the fabric to cling to my body.

"Fuck"

I was a whore, a dirty slut, a piece of trash.

My legs felt like jelly as I slowly exited the car. I don't know how I managed to get back inside the house and upstairs to the bathroom without anyone seeing me but I did. I took Nate's money and hid it away in one of my make up bags under the kitchen sink out of sight.

Did he just pay me for sex or was it a tip?

I was disgusting, I'd had sex with not one but two men who were not my boyfriend and they'd cum inside of me.

I was a filthy, filthy, woman.

"Hey." Stefan knocked on the door outside.

I stared at my sweaty forehead and slightly torn hem on my dress "Yeah?" I replied.

"Are you okay?"

I traced my swollen lower lip "I don't know." I replied softly before I then began to run my hands through my hair "It's been a long, long day." I said ashmed of myself for the double meaning.

"Do you need me to get you anything?"

I looked down and the evidence of what had happened was dripping from my inner thighs "No." I answered.

"I could get you anything you need."

I had flashbacks then of being flipped onto my back and Nate spitting on my chest as John kissed me.

"I've got everything I need." I assured him before staring back at my reflection.

"We can think of something to do tomorrow to get your mind off everything."

I unzipped my dress then and let it fall to the bathroom floor as I stared at what Nate and John had done to me. I was covered in sweat, my hair was a mess and my make-up was ruined.

"I just want to go to bed, I'm tired." I admitted.

"You have been through a lot."

I stared at my bare stomach and breasts, and the way the two of them had worked in unison to bring me the pleasure I'd wanted, needed. I reached up and took both my breasts in my hands, they were rather small. But I doubted the two of them were serious about wanting to pay for surgery for me.

"You're going to get through this Elena."

I licked my lips "I just don't know what else is in store and it scares me."

He had no idea what I was really talking about but I did.

"Don't be afraid Elena, I'm here for you."

"Good night, Stefan."

"Good night Elena."

I waited until his footsteps disappeared down the hallway before I stepped into the shower and let the cold water hit my body. I scrubbed every inch of my body, the feel of their touch, their words, the way they'd handled me. I scrubbed harder and harder until the skin of my chest and breasts began to sting and turn red, my hair was a sopping wet mess as I stood there shivering and crying. I was a whore and no amount of scrubbing could change that.

But was I truly a whore? Or was I at the start of a new phase of my life? Where I wasn't being a slut but instead finally exploring my sexual side.

"I don't know"

But I would find out soon enough.