So, I've decided to rewrite this due to being unhappy with the original for many reasons.

Fairy Tail belongs to Hiro Mashima and My Hero Academia belongs to Kohei Horikoshi

FAIR WARNING: CONTAINS FAIRY TAIL, 100-YEAR-QUEST, AND MHA SPOILERS. IF YOU DON'T TAKE THE TIME TO READ THIS THEN IT'S YOUR OWN FAULT IF SOMETHING IS SPOILED FOR YOU.

If you haven't read/watched the manga/anime of either Fairy Tail (This includes reading the 100-Year-Quest) or My Hero Academia then I suggest you stop right here and don't continue.

SUMMARY: (Delete this part when posting on AO3)

One year after the 100-Year Quest 20-year-old Lucy is sent to another world. It happens so quickly that Lucy can't question the mysterious person who has broken into her home and sent her away to another world. It's a completely different world than home. She finds herself having to hide who she really is to avoid discovery because should anyone learn who she really is, she'll be in a lot of danger. Two years later, the 22-year-old meets someone who could change her life for the better or the worse.

26-year-old Kai Chisaki (Overhaul) is torn between following the Boss's ideologies and acting on his own doing what he thinks needs to be done to reclaim the power the Yakuza once held over society. One night there's a disturbance outside of the compound. He along with the Boss and his childhood friend, Hari Kurono (Chronostasis) run outside to find out what's happening only to see a beautiful blonde woman take down a guy harming an innocent woman. As he gets to know her, he becomes enthralled and is torn between being the man for her or the man he feels the Yakuza needs.

Will he change paths and not become the man we know in the manga/anime? Or is he still destined to go down the dark one? Hell if I know at the moment. Takes place a year and a half before the Shie Hassaikai Arc.

At the moment Lucy is on an undetermined path with Chisaki aka Overhaul. He will be OOC and it's hard to work around his mysophobia. So, to make things a smidge easier, in this he will only have an aversion to blood and dirt.

Pairing in the beginning is Lucy and Chisaki. In the end, it's unknown. I have written up many possibilities. NatsuxLucy, BickslowxLucy, ChisakixLucy, HawksxLucy, AizawaxLucy.

I will later on have YOU choose. YOUR choice between Path A or B will determine her fate. That's not until way later on, but only IF, KEYWORD IF, I think I'm able to pull it off. Here's to hoping I'll be able to when the time comes.

Chapter word count: 4500+

Hold on to that heartbreak

Hold on to that hell you have to pay

All the tragedies make you who you are

Remember every scar

Missing Member

It's been two years since Lucy's disappearance and all of the searching has still yet to give them a clue as to where she could have gone. All of those who were affected by the spell are still having trouble forgiving themselves despite it not being their fault. Under the spell, they could hear and see everything they said and did to Lucy but had no control over their body.

*Flashback*

Master and Laxus are almost back to Magnolia from a rather long annoying meeting with the magic council. Laxus is not looking forward to being the 9th guild master if these meetings are anything to go by. He's going to have a long talk with the brats about controlling themselves. Just because there's a newer and more understanding council, it doesn't mean they're not going to get in trouble. Once the train has arrived at the station, Laxus gathers his composure before helping his grandfather off of the train. Waiting for them on the platform are his best friends Freed, Evergreen, and Bickslow.

"Hey just get back from the mission?" Laxus asks while pushing Gramps' wheelchair.

"How'd it go?" Master Makarov asks.

"Yeah, it was easy peasy." States Bickslow, his babies repeating him.

"How was the meeting?" Freed inquires, falling into step with Laxus.

"Tch. You better not have created more work for us."

"Have a little faith in us Laxus," Evergreen says.

"I do, but you had the other half of the destructive duo with you."

"Speaking of, where is Lucy?" Makarov asks.

"She ran ahead to the guild. She-"

BOOM!

"What the hell was that?"

"It came from the guild. Bickslow get Gramps."

"Right." Bickslow helps Gramps onto his babies, and they give him a ride to the guild.

Laxus lightning ports to the guild. When he lands Lucy is on the ground, tears in her eyes. He can't see them, but he can smell the salty scent. Looking inside the building, he's met with the sight of an angry dragon slayer, one who would never hurt Lucy.

"What the hell are you doing Natsu?" He makes his way forward only to be stopped in his tracks when Lucy yells at him.

"Don't go in there! There's some type of spell on the guild." Lucy warns Laxus.

Natsu snarls as he steps out of the guild, "Lucy is weak, she doesn't belong in Fairy Tail."

Lucy winces at what her best friend says and whispers, "It's the only explanation."

Mira shouts, "You're not worthy to be part of Fairy Tail!"

Laxus silently agrees with Lucy about a spell being cast on the guild and goes to her side. She is bruised and bloody and is left baffled when other guild members have similar looks as Natsu when they step out of the guild. Erza, Mira, Gray, Juvia, Cana, Elfman, Lisanna. There's no way they're the only ones in the guild. "Where are the other members?"

"Inside, in magic canceling cuffs courtesy of Virgo or covered in pink wool courtesy of Aries. I didn't want to hurt them so I restrained who I could. All of them were going to attack me."

The Thunder Legion and Master finally make it to the guild and are shocked at the sight. A banged-up Lucy is being held up by Laxus and the other guild members sending nasty looks their way.

"What the hell is going on here?" Master shouts.

Erza speaks up, "Lucy is weak Master; therefore she should no longer be a part of the guild." She requips into her Heaven's Wheel Armor and goes to attack Lucy only to be blocked by those in their right state of mind. They all form a barrier around Lucy, Laxus in front.

"See! A proper Fairy Tail mage shouldn't need to be protected like that!" Gray yells.

"What is wrong with you!" Evergreen shouts unable to believe what she is seeing and hearing.

"Lucy thinks there's a spell on the guild," Laxus informs them. "Other members are being restrained inside by either magic-canceling cuffs or wool."

When his children move to attack Makarov's voice booms out loudly, "STAND DOWN!"

They all reluctantly do so, and Master is at a loss for what to do.

Freed steps forward, "I'm going to check to see if there is some type of rune barrier around the guild." The fact he had done so many years ago goes unsaid. He's able to walk past his Nakama without any trouble. He indeed finds runes surrounding the guildhall, "Those who enter the Fairy Tail guild will turn against the light of Fairy Tail, Lucy Heartfilia, and it will stay in effect until the caster deems it time to erase them."

"Can you get rid of them Freed?" Evergreen asks.

"Of course, he can," Laxus says with certainty.

"Where's Levy when you need her?" Bickslow asks. 'Levy!' 'Help' 'Need Levy.'

"Lucy, can you summon Gemini to copy me and help?"

"I would if I could Freed. When I summoned Virgo and Aries, they got attacked as well."

"What are you still doing here?" Cana shouts angrily.

"Leave and never come back Love-Rival!" Juvia shouts at Lucy as well.

Lucy cries, "It hurts. I know it's a spell, but it still hurts to see them acting this way."

Bickslow pulls Lucy into a hug. He grits his teeth wanting to fight on her behalf, but it'll only antagonize them more.

Laxus hears people from a distance, "Gajeel, Levy, Wendy, Pantherlily, and Carla are on their way." He can't help but think whoever casts these runes is an idiot. Why wouldn't they wait until everyone was in the guild? One would think they would want Master Makarov, who is a wizard saint, three powerful dragon slayers, the Thunder Legion, one of them being one of the three smartest guild members, Levy being another one, a badass exceed, and himself under the spell as well.

When they arrive Levy, Wendy and Carla go right to Lucy while Gajeel and Pantherlily get ready for a battle.

"What happened?" Levy questions.

"Don't worry Lucy, I'll heal you." Wendy gets to work, healing the damage done to her.

"Stand down you two."

"Sorry Master, I overheard what was happening and like hell am I going to allow them to attack Bunny Girl even more."

"Hmmm… Well, whatever you do, do not go into the guild. Anyone who enters will turn against Lucy and the spell even remains in effect when you leave."

Their relief of the newly arrived members is short-lived when a big gust of wind blows everyone away from Lucy.

They hear Lucy scream and when their eyes direct their attention to her there's a strange man with black, spiky hair, a black mask, and black clothing making it difficult to get a description. He's holding Lucy's arms behind her back with one hand and the other has a tight grip on her hair. Standing next to him is, "Ivan!" Master shouts. Laxus growls out "Dead beat."

Wendy gasps, "But why?"

"Ah, the looks on your faces." Ivan lets out an evil chuckle, "Why? Well, the Lumen Histoire is no more so I had to find another way to hurt Fairy Tail."

Master Makarov does his best to remain calm, his failing heart has almost killed him a couple of times already, "Why do you want to hurt Fairy Tail so badly?"

Ivan grins evilly, "Remove the runes." The strange man all in black does so.

All of the members of the guild come back to their senses and are horrified by their actions.

"Don't worry about me," Lucy says as Virgo comes through her gate, "Get them."

They all move to attack and Ivan continues to grin, "Say bye little Fairy." And they're gone without a trace. Virgo disappeared as she was about to hit them with her Spica Lock move.

The members stop themselves in time, so they don't attack each other.

"What the hell happened?" Natsu yells.

Those under the spell couldn't fathom as to how Ivan and his crony got close enough to the guildhall to put runes around it without anyone noticing. That is until Mira mentioned that all of the dragon slayers were on missions, so it stood to reason that's when the guild had a spell put on it. Natsu had been the first to arrive and mentioned the weird smell but dropped it, more focused on getting a bite to eat and waiting for Lucy's return.

All of those that hurt Lucy were extremely upset with themselves, especially Natsu. But, they had to put all of that hurt to the side temporarily and focus on finding Lucy. Team Natsu informed everyone that if he could, Loke would already be there to tell them what happened. Either she was too far away, or she was… they didn't even entertain that idea. Someone had asked that if she were close, could Loke still get to Fairy Tail if she was in magic canceling cuffs?

Apparently, not many people knew that some of her spirits had the power to open up their own gates using their own magic. Loke, being one of them, would have used every ounce of magic to get to Fairy Tail to inform them what had happened so they could get to her. Even if she wasn't in magic-cancelling cuffs he could help her. He proved that during the Grand Magic Games. He wasn't the leader of the Zodiacs for nothing.

Since they haven't heard from Loke, Erza contacted Sabertooth to speak with Yukino. She asked if her spirits could contact Lucy's. It was a good idea, but it didn't work. Not even Stache Face could locate them which meant she had to be in another world. They thought maybe Edolas but they had zero information to go on. If only they had a way to contact Rebecca and Shiki that would be super helpful.

They asked them, along with other guilds, to please keep a lookout. Of course, they all accepted. Yukino went as far as contacting Queen Hisui, she would want to know what happened to her good friend. She said she would have ears and eyes out for her and would notify them should she hear of anything. Queen Hisui took the liberty of contacting Emperor Ajeel and asked him to keep an ear and eye out in Alakitasia for any information that may give them a clue.

That gave Laxus the idea to reach out to someone he met on the 100-Year-Quest. The two may have a rivalry but the man likes Fairy Tail. Lucy saving Laxus on the 100-Year-Quest had brought the two closer together and the next thing everyone knew he adopted Lucy as his little sister. The Thunder Legion then adopted her as well, making her an honorary member.

Natsu didn't like Lucy working on a mission with another team without him but whenever she returned she would seek him out immediately to tell him all about it. That day everything happened was no different but instead of finding a happy dragon slayer, she found an angry volatile one who could do nothing but watch from the inside as his body acted on its own accord.

The hurt he saw in her eyes from his words and attacks. The damage he did when he attacked damn near broke him and he fought tooth and nail trying to break free of the spell. He felt relief when he heard her say there was a spell on a guild, that there was no other explanation. She had enough sense to know it wasn't him. To know that he and their nakama would never treat her the way they did.

The rest of them weren't doing much better. The words they spoke to her were the last she heard coming from their mouths. She was anything but weak. Sure, she wasn't as physically strong as far as fighting goes, but neither is Wendy, Levy, Cana, to name a few. Not every woman can be like Mira or Erza.

She could take a beating though. She refused to run when Kain Hikaru beat the crap out of her in front of Natsu while he was trapped underneath rocks. She took the beating Flare gave her during the Grand Magic Games to protect Asuka. She went through hell fighting off three demons to protect and save all of Fairy Tail. Despite the pain, she rewrote the Book of E.N.D. to ensure Natsu wouldn't die when he defeated Zeref.

She was so smart. She was capable of rewriting the book of E.N.D. When they were desperately trying to find a way to defeat Acnologia she was the one to suggest casting Fairy Sphere to trap him on a boat so the dragon slayers could fight his human form.

She was mentally and emotionally strong as well. She powered through the emotional loss of Aquarius, having the strength to carry on. Having faith, they would see each other again. There are so many more examples to prove that she is strong, brave, smart, along with many other things.

It's all a lot of them have been thinking about the past two years. Everything they wish they could say to her, ensure her that the last words they spoke were anything but true.

Two long years of searching and nothing to show for it. Guild members have slowly been coming to terms with the fact that Lucy may very well be either stuck in another world or dead and have been moving on. Some have not given up searching but have also been moving on, living their lives just like Lucy would have wanted them to do. Levy and Gajeel have twins and boy and a girl. Gale and Metalia. They were born before Lucy disappeared. Gray and Juvia. Erza and Jellal also have a baby, a little girl named Irene. Elfman and Evergreen. Cobra and Kinana. Mira, Laxus, and Freed. They're in a polyamorous relationship and also have a baby, a little girl named Rita, after Laxus's great-grandmother.

Natsu on the other hand…

Mira sighs and looks around the guild. She is one of the few who still hasn't given up hope. If her sister can be sent to another world and be brought back two years later, then why can't Lucy? Speaking of Lisanna, she's been there for him when he needed her. He at first lashed out because he thought Lisanna was trying to replace Lucy.

No one could ever replace Lucy. Ever since he met her he couldn't be apart from her. She smelled of home. When he met Anna and regained some memories of her being in his life, it made sense as to why he always wanted Lucy close. Subconsciously he recognized the scent of the other parental figure he had in his past. She was also his teacher and a friend of his father Igneel.

Natsu and Lisanna's friendship is almost like it was before and Mira can see Lisanna falling for him again. Natsu on the other hand doesn't show any interest. A part of his heart was taken away from him leaving a hole that will never be filled. Maybe over time, once they have finality over what happened to Lucy. But even then, it's hard to tell. He spends a lot of his time on missions, searching for any clues about Lucy while out there. He's more proactive about it than he was when he lost Igneel.

Before Lucy's disappearance, Master Makarov wanted to hold the S-Class exams again but had decided to put that on the back burner. That is until the S-Class mages convinced him to not put the exams aside. The more S-Class mages, the better. There were a lot of S-Class requests but few S-Class mages. If all went well, they would be able to promote a few more mages and then they could take the harder jobs that may or may not give them any clues about Lucy's, as well as Ivan's and the strange man's, whereabouts.

They decided to change it up a little. In the last S-Class exam, Lucy was the only one to figure out where Mavis's grave was. She wasn't even up for promotion; she was Cana's partner. If the hell they went through never happened, Cana would be an S-Class mage due to Lucy's help. So, he decided that both people on the team would be promoted.

The way he, Gildarts, Laxus, Mira, and Erza planned it made it so four teams could pass, giving them eight more S-class mages, bringing up their total to 10. Yes, it's excessive, but the more the better. Three teams were the same from the last exam.

Elfman Evergreen

Freed Bickslow

Levy Gajeel

The last four teams were:

Natsu Wendy

Cana Lisanna

Max Warren

Juvia Gray

Instead of choosing Happy as a partner, Natsu asked Wendy if she would be his partner. If Lucy were there, he would have picked her as his partner for the S-Class exams. They've always worked well together and over time have become a kickass team. Wendy was just as good. Not only was she super strong but super smart too. She felt honored that she was chosen as a partner again. She had a lot more confidence compared to last time. They've also fought side by side enough to know how the other operates.

Of course, Juvia jumped at the chance of partnering with Gray.

Cana had chosen Lisanna because they have fought side by side and they too know how the other operates.

Max was chosen for the last spot, and he picked Warren as his partner. They were more of a filler, and to be quite honest they were intimidated at going up against the powerhouses of Fairy Tail.

The four teams that won were Natsu and Wendy, Levy and Gajeel, Cana and Lisanna, and Juvia and Gray.

A lot of members went off in groups. Jet and Droy would obviously go with Levy, Gajeel, and Pantherlily. Cana and Lisanna would sometimes accompany the Thunder Legion since Laxus had been stuck at the guild preparing to take over as Master. The times Laxus could, Wendy went with them instead. The groups were mixed and matched.

Natsu hadn't gone on S-Class missions with anyone other than Happy for the most part. Once or twice, Team Natsu would go on a mission together, but it wasn't the same. One time Lisanna tagged along, but it felt too much like they were replacing Lucy so that didn't ever happen again. Natsu and Happy couldn't go on missions with only Lisanna because that too felt like he was replacing Lucy. The times he did invite someone to go along it was either Wendy and Carla or surprisingly Gray.

Speaking of missions, Natsu is at the standard request board contemplating on what request to pick. As he's about to make a selection he smells an all too familiar scent. Normally he forgets different scents he comes across, the exception being Acnologia and a disguised Ultear. Just like those two, he will never forget this scent. He lets out a growl, stomps over to the guild doors, and grabs the scrawny man by the collar of his shirt letting out a guttural growl, "Who the hell are you?"

The man yelps and tosses the package into the air and thankfully it lands far enough away from the fire dragon slayer and doesn't catch on fire. "I'm... I'm..."

"Natsu!" Mira yells, hurriedly heading in their direction. "He's the mailman!"

Natsu is no longer covered in flames, but he still gets in the man's face, "Why do you smell like that bastard?"

"Wh-What?"

Laxus storms out of his office, he smelt the scent too. He takes in the scene down below and sees that he and Natsu aren't the only dragon slayers whose hackles have risen. He then notices a package lying on the floor away from all of the commotion. He zaps down and picks it up giving it a sniff. "It's coming from this." He turns his head to the mailman still in Natsu's grasp. "Who gave this to you?" He inspects it to make sure there's no dangerous magic before opening it. Though it only reeks of the unknown man, he wouldn't put it past Ivan to put some type of spell on it for whatever reason.

Erza makes her way forward to Natsu, "Calm down and let him go. The man is just doing his job."

Gray stomps over to them, "I would like to know who gave him that package as well Natsu but scaring him won't get answers any faster."

Natsu lets go and takes a step back, crossing his arms.

The mailman tries his best to not cower, he knows Natsu isn't a bad guy, but he's never seen the dragon slayer so on edge, ready to rip someone's throat out. "No-No one saw who brought it in, it was like it just appeared out of nowhere."

Mira walks the mailman out, "I'm sorry about them. You know how well a dragon slayer's sense of smell is."

The man visibly calms down as he's escorted out of the guild. "Yeah, Wendy helped me find my Grandma when she got lost." He jumps when he hears a loud thunderclap.

"Well, the package smells like the man who has something to do with Lucy's disappearance."

The man's eyes widen, "Hopefully it's a clue."

Mira gives the man a smile that doesn't quite reach her eyes. "Hopefully. Can you ask everyone at the post office to be extra vigilant and keep an eye out for any suspicious people and let us know right away should another package magically appear?"

"Yes, I can do that. I'll call so the dragon slayers can check out the office and see if they can discover anything new with their noses."

"Even better. Be prepared, they might just do that soon."

"Okay." The man jumps when there's another thunderclap. It's a nice day so he knows it's Laxus the lightning dragon slayer making all that noise. Despite knowing that, he's still jumpy from the unexpected sound and the fact that the man is in a pissy mood, for good reason.

When Mira walks back into the guild she's met with the sight of Laxus with his LacrimaVision and lacrima movie player in his hands yelling at people to help him set it up. She wonders how he managed to transport it here without frying it. She brushes that thought off, there are more important matters at hand. At the bar, there's an open box. She peers inside only to see that it's empty. "What was in here?"

"The bastard sent us a lacrima disc." Laxus pulls something out of his pocket and tosses it to her.

Mira easily catches it and looks it over, "Do you think..."

"There's only one way to find out," Cana says.

Wendy speaks up, "Should we even watch it? I mean there could be something really horrible on there."

Natsu's hands are fisted at his sides, "I don't care what is on there. If it has to do with Luce then I need to know."

This time Bisca speaks up, "Just in case, Al and I are going to leave with Asuka. If anyone else would like for us to take your kids elsewhere we can do that."

"But we'll miss everything," Asuka pouts.

"It's okay sweetie," Alzack soothes her, "They'll fill us in."

The parents start gathering up their strangely quiet children. They may be young, but they can sense something is wrong and it would be in their best interest to not act up.

Levy is the first to pass her two children to them, "Thank you so much."

Freed takes his, Laxus's, and Mira's bundle of joy to them. "It is very much appreciated."

"Yes, thank you," Jellal says as he passes little Irene to Alzack.

Bisca, Alzack, Reedus, and a few others leave the guild with the children to take them to the park, get some ice cream, and do anything else to keep them occupied.

Everything is all set up and everyone has taken a seat. Lisanna hesitantly sits with Natsu and Happy. When Mira sees that Laxus has a tight hold on the remote, handshaking, she gently pries it away from him before he crushes it to bits and pieces.

Laxus gives her a little smile, "Thanks." He's excited to finally have news but scared as all hell about what could be on that disc.

Mira nods her head and squeezes his hand before she hits play.

It's dark and the lighting is dim. The man in front of the camera is nothing but a silhouette. There's not much to go on by his appearance other than long spiky hair going in every direction. They recognize him as the man who was with Ivan.

"Hello Fairy Tail. I hope all is well. Of course it isn't, you lost your light although I see it hasn't stopped you from starting happy little families. I bet you're wondering who I am and my connection with Ivan Dreyar. Unfortunately for you, you'll never be able to find out. Nor will you be able to find your precious light. I have the power to move between worlds and we found an interesting one to dump Lucky Lucy Heartfilia in.

"Oh, the hell she has gone through to survive, the atrocities she has witnessed. The life she's had to live isn't for the faint of heart. Some of the horrific crimes she's seen were against women and instead of turning them in to the authorities she outright killed them. How does that make you fairies feel? Fairies don't kill right unless it can't be helped in battle. She took their lives into her own hands and ended them."

The mysterious man cackles, "We are both quite surprised she's lasted this long without breaking. Who knows how long that will last though? I'm well aware that the videos I will be sending you will give you hints as to where to find her but by that time you do, if you do, she'll be so broken that it's going to crush you, especially Natsu, the fire dragon slayer. Speaking of crushing you, it seems as if she's getting close to someone else, and who knows where that will lead." The man cackles some more, "Oh what I wouldn't give to see the looks on your faces right now but alas I got to get back to recording Lucy's new life. Don't want to miss anything now, do we? Enjoy! HAHAHA!"

The screen goes black and when a new scene starts, Mira pauses it. A lot of faces in the guild are a mixture of anger and sadness, some a combination of both.

"Does everyone still want to watch this?"

Gray grits out through his teeth, "Yes, I need to know."

"Same here," Levy agrees. "Not only will we get more information on where she's at, but we also need to know everything she's been through so when we finally get her back we'll have a good idea on how to help her."

Cobra hears in Jellal's and Macbeth's souls the same thing he's thinking about, "She's going to need help learning how to live with what she's done from those who have also killed for no good reason."

Midnight nods, "We'll help with that."

Jellal grabs Erza's hands, "That action alone really changes a person. I know Fairies don't kill per se, so she's going to need you guys to not pass judgment on her."

Gajeel speaks up in his gruff tone, "I'd be lying if I said I wouldn't outright kill those kinds of men."

"Same here." Bickslow agrees.

Everyone talks about what they can do to help Lucy if what the guy said is true. Mira looks at Natsu and what she sees breaks her heart. His hands are fisted in his lap, knuckles turning white, bangs covering his eyes, and tears streaming down his face. His whole body is shaking, and you can tell he's trying his hardest to not go on a rampage.

"Natsu, do you still want to watch it?"

Natsu slams a flaming fist on the table he's sitting at and looks up, "I said I would and I'm going to regardless of what I see now press play."

Looking around the guild to double-check that everyone else is ready as well, she walks around the bar to take a seat herself and gets comfortable. She points the remote at the lacrima player, takes in a deep breath, and slowly exhales as she presses play.

Push through

Despite all you've been through

You will carry on

We will carry on

Escape The Fate - Remember Every Scar

If you didn't already know Rebecca and Shiki are from Hiro Mashima's Edens Zero. Hiro did a Rave MasterxFairyTailxEdensZero crossover. Hence how they know them. It's quite enjoyable seeing all of those characters interact with each other.

ww5dotreadfairytaildotcom