Haruhi's Choice
This is the sequel to "Happy Birthday Haruhi." It's the first day of school after Haruhi's birthday weekend with Renge. Haruhi was seen walking into school holding Renge's hand. Before she left, Haruhi kissed Renge in front of everyone! Are they a couple now? What do the Hosts think? Is anyone else jealous? Rated M for strong sexual content. HaruhixRenge girlxgirl
Disclaimer: I don't own Ouran High School Host Club.
The dim light in the third music room filtered through the back window into the changing area, landing on the sight of two girls, kissing and groping each other like there was no tomorrow.
"Are you sure *kiss* no one *kiss* followed you in here?" Haruhi asked Renge, her hands roaming the other girls' body.
"Yes *kiss* I'm *kiss* sure," Renge answered, allowing Haruhi to lift her onto a nearby counter.
The noise of the two girls was not muted by the curtain of the changing area, nor by the lack of light in the room—so, it was no secret what was going on when a few members of the host club came in through the main entrance.
Kyoya was first, followed shortly by Huni and Mori.
"You hear something, Takashi?"
"Yeah. It's coming from over there."
"Sounds like…smacking?"
Kyoya set his items down and stopped the third year's from going any further.
"Gentlemen, I believe I will go and take a look at what the disturbance might be. Would you be so kind as to stop any of the other club members from investigating until I return?"
Both Mori and Huni nodded to this and kept watch on the entrance for the other club members while Kyoya made his way to the back changing area.
The noises got steadily louder as he approached and there was no mistaking the sound of pleasurable moans and gasps as that of two people kissing heavily it sounded like.
*Who would have the audacity to do that kind of thing here?* The thought made him angry that anyone would use their club area as a make out spot!
Right before he was about to open the curtain leading to the main source of the noise, he stopped at the sound of a familiar giggling voice.
"Haruhi! Stop! You know I'm ticklish there!"
"But your face looks so cute when it gets all flushed like that."
He froze, hand still poised to pull back the curtain.
*Haruhi? Renge?*
He lowered his hand slowly and listened for a few more minutes while he decided the next course of action.
"Stop it…your making me…lose control…"
"That's the idea, Renge…"
"But…the club…"
"I didn't hear anyone come in yet. We have a little more time…"
"Mhm! Yes! Right there, right there..."
The noises they were making were muted, but still filled with pleasure—enough to paint a good mental picture to anyone listening in.
Kyoya's pulse increased a little and he loosened his tie enough to cool down his now increased body temperature. A noise from the front of the third music room brought him back to the matter at hand and he cleared his throat, loudly.
The sounds in the changing room continued as Renge's noises became more urgent.
*Oh great! They are too worked up to even notice any other noises but each other! I'm going to have to go in there.*
Taking a deep breath, he put on his most stern face and pulled back the curtain. He quickly got in and shut the drape behind him once he saw that Haruhi's hand was very visibly under Renge's dress and both girls were too busy kissing each other to notice another presence in the room.
Renge was almost worked up to a climax and let Haruhi know by her increased panting and grunting. Haruhi sped up her thrusting, her own contact high getting the best of her.
"Haru-Haruhi! Ah!"
"Renge!"
As both girls were about ready to scream, Kyoya rushed forward and placed both his hands on each of their mouths, muting their sounds as their climaxes subsided.
The girls' eyes were wide as they looked at Kyoya, who was visibly angry and breathing hard. He spoke in hushed tones so that only the girls could hear him.
"I suggest, from now on, that you two find somewhere else to…pleasure yourselves."
The girls nodded and Kyoya removed his hands.
He took a moment to fix his tie as Haruhi removed herself from Renge and they helped each other straighten their clothing to look presentable. The noises coming from the front of the room indicated that each of the host club members had arrived and they were waiting for Kyoya and Haruhi.
"Haruhi, I will go out first. Wait a little bit before following. Renge, I suggest you use whatever means necessary to leave as quietly as you came. I won't breathe a word of this to the other hosts, but I advise that you both keep your…relationship...a secret for now."
Kyoya turned and started to make his way to leave.
"Kyoya-sempai…I-I'm sorry," Haruhi uttered, a little unsure of what to say and bowed.
"We didn't mean to be so loud," Renge added, bowing.
Kyoya looked back at the girls and gave his trademark smirk.
"Think nothing of it for now, Haruhi," Kyoya said, waving a dismissive hand at the girls. "Renge, I'll ask you again to make a quick and silent exit now. It looks like the other hosts are arriving." With that, Kyoya was off.
Once he was out of site, Haruhi took Renge in her arms for a silent and quick kiss.
"I'm so sorry Haruhi!"
"It's ok, Renge. We will just have to keep this a secret for now, that's all," Haruhi said, returning her kiss with one of her own. "I have to go, but..."
Haruhi looked away and Renge could tell that she was blushing.
"Could-could I c-come by your place tonight? I-I'd re-really like to see you. If that's ok?"
Renge was blushing a little also. She didn't think things would progress this far with her and Haruhi this fast, but she nodded and replied, "I'll send the car around to pick you up after host club."
Haruhi would have normally protested at being given a ride, but she only nodded and gave Renge one last kiss before heading off to greet the other hosts.
"But, Haru-chan! Usa-chan and me want to know how your date with Ren-chan went!"
Huni-sempai was following Haruhi around the club room while she cleaned up the tea sets. The twins gave up asking the obvious question that was on everyone's mind but was told before club began to leave this one alone from Kyoya, of all people. He also restrained Tamaki and warned the rest of the club members to avoid asking Haruhi about her date or there would be a heavy price to pay. What that price was…was anyone's guess, but the threat of the unknown from the host club's 'dark prince' was enough to keep them at bay. Everyone, except Huni-sempai.
"Haru-chan! Haru-chan! How was it? Was it nice? Where did you go? Were you a perfect gentleman?"
Huni peppered her with questions all while Haruhi completed her duties of cleaning and straightening up Music Room 3 while the other hosts attempted to look like they were busy doing something and not listening to the answer to Huni-sempai's questions.
At Huni-sempai's last question, Haruhi stopped what she was doing and looked over at Kyoya.
*Was I a perfect gentleman?*
A light bulb went off over her head.
"Kyoya-sempai? Can I speak to you please? In private?"
The host club seemed to still at Haruhi's words.
*Did I hear that right? Haruhi? Is asking to talk to Kyoya? IN PRIVATE?* Tamaki's mind theatre was going in overdrive as he started to imagine the worst possible scenarios.
The twins looked at each other, nodded once and began to quietly follow Haruhi and Kyoya into the changing area. Before they could make their move to listen in at the closed door, Mori and Huni were there blocking their way.
"Hey! What gives?" they asked, in perfect unison.
"Hika-chan! Kao-chan! You shouldn't listen! It's supposed to be private!" Huni said.
"Yeah, but were bored," they answered.
"Not our problem," Mori said
"Yeah! Now go away!" Huni said, sticking his tongue out at the nosey twins.
Defeated for now, the twins turned to go back to their favorite pastime, tormenting Tamaki.
Once they were both inside the changing room, Haruhi turned to face Kyoya.
"Kyoya-sempai, I have a great idea! Why don't I actually start dating Renge?"
Kyoya took his glasses off and started to clean them with a cloth he took out of his pocket.
"I thought that you were already dating Renge, Haruhi. That was what I saw you two doing this afternoon, was it not?"
Haruhi looked away for a moment as her face turned red.
"Ye-yeah, I guess…but that was in private! Why not let Renge and I date out in the open?"
Kyoya stopped his actions and looked up at Haruhi.
"No, wait, hear me out before you say anything," Haruhi took a breath and let it out.
"I'm supposed to be posing as a guy, right? While I'm in the host club?"
Kyoya nodded.
"Ok, so what better way to show that I'm a guy then dating a cute girl like Renge? Well, not like Renge, but my Renge. Anyway, what do you think? Pretty clever, right?" Haruhi said, her face in a pleased smile.
Kyoya put his glasses back on and looked Haruhi in the eyes.
"Haruhi, what do you think the reaction will be when everyone finds out that you are dating Renge? For that matter, have you even asked her if she wants to go public with your relationship?"
That stopped her. Haruhi didn't think about that. She just thought it was a great idea, something that they didn't have to hide from everyone.
"No, you're right. I should have asked her first," Haruhi said, letting her smile fall from her face. She felt like a bad girlfriend.
Kyoya sighed and put his hand on his forehead, a sure sign he was going to regret his next words.
"I guess it would be interesting to see how our guests would react to one of our own dating," he said, slowly.
Haruhi's eyes lit up at hearing this.
"You mean it? So, if I can convince her to start dating me for real, like out in public, and me still being in the host club, you'd be ok with it?"
Kyoya just nodded once before hearing a very girlish squeal coming from Haruhi.
"Thank you! Thank you so much Kyoya-sempai! You don't know how much this means to me!"
Haruhi turned and rushed out of the room, almost knocking over Huni and Mori in her mad dash to go meet Renge at her house.
"What was that all about?" the twins asked, turning to look at Kyoya who had just come out of the changing room.
"Gentlemen, please gather around. I have an announcement to make."