Time for the first lemon of the book. Mistystar never truly had her first time as it was just pretty minuscule stuff compared to when Silverstream, Honeypaw, and Windstream had their turn. So. Let's get this started. I am still trying to figure out how to post on AO3, so I will try to keep it rated M, but I have never been good at watering stuff down. I couldn't even find the messages from the critic who told me how to water down lemons and such in the first book. Oh boy. Fuck it. Let's roll right into this lemon. The lemon happens near the end of the chapter.

Chapter 5: FireheartxMistystar

Mistystar sat down in her den. Fireheart walked in, and the scent of heat was nearly overwhelming. He took a deep breath to calm his male instinct, barely succeeding. Mistystar said, "Let's wait until night falls. You did say we could take care of my heat problem if I wanted to. And I want it. At this point, I would almost say I need it." Fireheart nodded in understanding.

Fireheart walked over to Mistystar and sat next to her. They coiled their tails in love. Fireheart said, "Are you sure you want to do this? You're only a virgin once." Mistystar nodded and Fireheart asked, "What if I told you something that I've told every she-cat I've mated with, which are Honeypaw, Silverstream, and Windstream. I also told Heathertail on the return journey from the Sun-Drown place before I changed history." Mistystar eyed him curiously and said, "What could it be that you had to tell them before you mated them? Must be your darkest secret." Fireheart replied, "It is my darkest secret." Mistystar said, "I can handle it. I promise."

Fireheart took a deep breath to calm his nerves and said, "Alright. Here goes." Fireheart looked at Mistystar and continued, "I used to be a twoleg." Mistystar laughed and said, "Impossible. You really had me going. Good one." Fireheart looked at her and replied seriously, "I used to be a twoleg. When I was a twoleg, I was murdered in cold blood. That is why I always have that same dream almost every night. I know you've been in it with me. At least in the past before I changed history. That dream is about how I died as a twoleg. That is how I was able to speak English, which is the Twoleg's language, in the dream. Every time I have that dream, I fight the Twoleg who killed my Twoleg self in the dream. You asked how I knew how to speak twoleg. That is how. Because I was murdered in cold-blood, the first Leaders of Lionclan and Tigerclan decided to bring me back as the cat with powers before you, so I could prevent it from happening to anyone else in this life. That is how I knew how to make the anti-venom back when I was bitten by an adder on the journey to the Sun-Drown place. Starclan never told me. I was shocked it worked with a marigold poultice. Lionstar and Stripestar brought me back because they knew Tigerstar was plotting something. In this scenario, Tigerstar is just like the person who killed me as a Twoleg. Someone who kills in cold blood, because Tigerstar really has no reason, except for Revenge." Mistystar looked at Fireheart and realized he was being honest.

Mistystar took everything in and said, "That is a pretty deep and dark secret. I understand why you told Honeypaw, Silverstream, and Windstream before you mated them. You'd want them to know." Fireheart replied, "Exactly. I will tell every she-cat who is in the harem or every she-cat that joins, before I mate them for the first time. Because they should know their mate used to be a Twoleg. And if they decide to stop being my mate because of it, I completely understand. I wouldn't dream of forcing them to stay. All of the she-cats in my harem or who join, deserve to be happy; and if I can't do it, I understand."

Mistystar said, "Well. The fact you used to a twoleg doesn't mean anything to me. It is a shock to be sure, and it is one hell of a thing to drop on me when I just remembered you; but that is not who you are now. You are Fireheart, the Leader of Lionclan, the restorer of Hope to the Forest, The savior of all eight clans, and the Tom I love. I will always love you and be your mate. No matter what." Fireheart purred lightly and said, "Alright, Mistystar."

In Thunderclan:

Foxleap was waiting outside the Leader's Den. Bramblestar mewed, "Come in, Foxleap." Foxleap walked in and said, "Fireheart still hasn't returned. What is taking him so long?" Bramblestar replied, "You couldn't smell it?" Foxleap asked, "Smell what? I was too focused on Fireheart's speech." Bramblestar purred in amusement and said, "Mistystar is in heat." Foxleap's eyes went wide and he said, "But why would that make Fireheart take so long to get back?" Bramblestar chuckled and said, "Just. Think about it for a second." Foxleap thought for a second and he said, "No fucking way." Bramblestar laughed and mewed, "Yes fucking way." Foxleap muttered, "I never thought anyone would win Mistystar's heart. And I certainly wouldn't have thought a Thunderclan cat could do it." Bramblestar laughed and said, "He is a Lionclan cat. Not Thunderclan. We are all members of Lionclan, that is why it is okay and not against the Warrior Code. However, Fireheart did tell me he will be the only complete member of Lionclan until he reunites all the clans." Foxleap's eyes went wide and he asked, "Why would he say that?"

Bramblestar answered, "Because. There is an army approaching Riverclan. And since Fireheart is the only complete member of Lionclan, he will take on the army by himself." Foxleap said, "That's suicide! Not even Lionblaze could face an entire army by himself and come out unscathed! Why don't we join him in the fight?!" Bramblestar said, "Let's just say, Fireheart inherited his father's powers somehow, and they combined with his own. Making him damn near invincible. This is something he must do alone. Trust me, I don't like it either, but I can not think of anything that could potentially even come close to killing Fireheart. Except maybe himself. He will be fine." Foxleap's eyes went wide again and he said, "That is why he has never lost a battle, even against impossible odds." Bramblestar replied, "Exactly." Foxleap left the Leader's Den.

Bramblestar walked out of the Leader's Den and walked into the Warrior's Den. Dovewing looked at him and asked, "Why are you in the Warrior's Den, Bramblestar? Not trying to be rude, but I am stressed out because I can't remember what I've forgotten. And that dream I have every night is confusing as hell." Bramblestar replied, "I understand. You will remember eventually. I have come to tell you to keep your senses in Thunderclan camp for the night, or at least not near Fireheart." Dovewing eyes lit up with curiosity and she asked, "Why?" Bramblestar mewed, "Just trust me. You don't have to listen to me if you don't want to because I am not ordering you, but you might be surprised at what you find and hear. I figured I'd give you a warning. Sleep well, Dovewing." Bramblestar left the Warrior's Den. Dovewing muttered, "Fireheart. Fireheart. That name doesn't feel right when I say it, like it's not his actual name. And the dream about fire I have every night. The fire isn't dangerous and instead I feel safe around it. A voice calls to me asking if I remember it." Dovewing got a thought and said, "Let me try saying this. Firestar." Dovewing realized saying that name felt much more natural and normal. She muttered, "Strange. Strange indeed. Hmm. Should I listen to Bramblestar? He did say I didn't have to if I didn't want to. Screw it." Dovewing let her senses extend to Fireheart's location.

Back in Riverclan:

Night had fallen. Mistystar said to Fireheart, "It's time. Let's go have a night of fun. And do be gentle, as this will be my first time, Firestar. Shit. Fireheart. My bad." Fireheart laughed quietly and said, "It's fine. My name is actually Firestar after all, even if the star is gone from my head; Starclan still recognizes me as the Leader of Lionclan. I will ask you to try and refrain from saying my actual name when we are around other cats for the time being." Mistystar nodded in understanding and smirked as she said, "Come get it if you want it, Firestar." She ran out of the Leader's Den quietly and Fireheart laughed and said, "Oh. It's so on, Mistystar. I will even give you a head start." Fireheart ignited his pelt on fire. White flames flowed around his body freely.

Fireheart waited another minute and smirked. He booked it out of the Leader's Den quietly, becoming nothing but a fiery silent blur.

Mistystar looked around and didn't see Fireheart chasing her. She giggled and said, "Guess I lost him. Wait. Last time I said that, he leapt at me." Mistystar immediately jumped out of the way, a fiery blur leapt past her. Mistystar giggled and Fireheart said, "My my. You've learned." Mistystar teased, "You must not want it bad enough if I was able to dodge that." Fireheart chuckled and said, "You were ready that time. What if I up my speed even more?" Mistystar said with mock fear, "Oh no. What will I do? Wait. I got it!" She leapt at Fireheart, catching him off guard and they rolled on the ground. Fireheart ended up on top, pinned Mistystar gently after extinguishing the flames from his pelt, and said, "Impressive. That's the second time I've ever been caught off guard. I guess I am getting rusty." Mistystar giggled and craned her neck and stuck out her chest to let Fireheart see all of her.

Fireheart traced her body with his eyes and asked, "Are you sure about this?" Mistystar replied, "Yes, Firestar. I am finally ready now. Be gentle." Fireheart nodded in understanding and asked, "Basic mating stance? Or are you feeling adventurous?" Mistystar replied, "Let's start with the basics. I do expect us both to mate more than once. We can do more advanced positions as we mate more and more. Maybe we could even get into some of the Twoleg Mating Stances that you experienced as a Twoleg, because it would be interesting." Fireheart chuckled and said, "I do not remember if I ever did anything like this as a Twoleg. But like you said before, I am no longer a Twoleg. I am Firestar, the Leader of Lionclan, the restorer of Hope to the Forest, The savior of all eight clans, and the Tom you love. I am a Warrior now. And I couldn't be happier. Fuck my Twoleg life. This is the life for me. Being truly free, being able to help others, etc." Mistystar nodded in understanding.

Fireheart unpinned Mistystar. Mistystar got up and got into the basic Mating Stance. Fireheart looked at her glistening core and took a breath. He walked over and mounted Mistystar. Mistystar said, "Please. Be gentle, Firestar." Fireheart nodded, the head of his shaft coming out slowly. Once it was mostly out, he slowly entered Mistystar. She moaned lightly. Fireheart's shaft was stopped a couple inches inside her. Mistystar said, "I am ready when you are." Fireheart asked, "What about the pain you're gonna feel? Should I get you a stick or something to bite?" Mistystar said, "I can handle it without a stick. I promise. However, I do appreciate the concern." Fireheart nodded in understanding and counted down from three. At one, he thrusted hard, absolutely destroying Mistystar's hymen. Mistystar hissed loudly in pain and Fireheart stopped. He waited until Mistystar said, "I am fine now, Firestar. You can continue when you're ready."

Fireheart nodded in understanding and began to slowly thrust. Mistystar moaned lightly with each thrust. She moaned, "More. Faster." Fireheart obiligied and began to thrust faster. Mistystar moaned loudly, "This feels so much better than when I use my tail. Please, make me yours, Firestar." Fireheart blushed and began to thrust harder and slightly faster. Mistystar moaned louder. Fireheart continued to thrust, getting faster as time went on. Mistystar's moans drowned out the sounds of him thrusting in Mistystar, the wet sounds being drowned out.

Mistystar was slightly drooling as Fireheart thrusted inside her. Mistystar said through her moans, "Fuck….. this….. Feels so…. Much better… than I could ever have imagined!" Fireheart began to thrust harder. Mistystar yowled in pleasure as Fireheart began to thrust harder. Fireheart was nearing his climax, so he slowed down to last longer.

Mistystar asked through her moans, "Why did… you slow down?" Fireheart replied, "To last longer. We have been going for around thirty minutes now. You want to feel this as long as possible right?" Mistystar replied, "Yeah. If I don't pass out from pleasure. You got my legs shaking. We should finish before I finally collapse." Fireheart chuckled and said, "Glad I could make your legs shake." Fireheart began to thrust harder and faster. Mistystar moaned loudly as she said through her moans, "This… is more…. Like it…. Make me shake…. Make me yours forever!" Fireheart said, "Happily." He began to thrust even harder and faster, getting close to his climax.

Fireheart was about to climax, when Mistystar's core tightened around his dick. He found it hard to thrust, but be pulled through as Mistystar came, providing natural lubricant. Fireheart's shaft slid in and out easily now. Mistystar yowled loudly in pleasure. Mistystar said, "F-Finish inside me Firestar! Truly make me yours! Fill me up!" Fireheart growled in pleasure as he sped up. Fireheart had now been going for forty-five minutes. Fireheart began to thrust as hard and fast as he could. Mistystar's core tightened around his dick once more, but Fireheart powered through. He roared in pleasure as he came inside Mistystar, easily filling her up. He kept thrusting, causing a bit to fly out as he came more. Mistystar purred as Fireheart filled her up. Fireheart pulled out, sending what was left of his seed on the forest floor. Mistystar purred happily as the white liquid slowly flowed out of her core. She looked at Fireheart mischievously and leapt at him. They rolled on the ground and Mistystar ended up on top. She looked at Fireheart's shaft, which had not even begun to retreat back into its protective sheath, and gently poked it teasingly. She giggled and said, "Someone's not done yet. I bet I can milk it for more." Fireheart blushed and Mistystar got off of him and licked the tip of his shaft. Fireheart moaned lightly as it twitched, white hitting Mistystar's face. She closed one eye before the cum got into it and she purred as she said, "I wonder if this is good for my fur. Only one way to find out." She smirked mischievously and began to play with Fireheart's shaft with her tongue and paws, causing more white to get dispersed. Fireheart moaned lightly as he came more. Mistystar purred and let the white cover her fur as best as she could. Fireheart looked at her in disbelief. Mistystar giggled and said, "Don't want to waste even the slightest drop. However, the seed on the forest floor is a lost cause. Because I am not rolling around in it." Fireheart laughed lightly and said, "That's fair." Mistystar purred and licked the tip again. Cum flew into her mouth and she swallowed it. She purred happily and said, "Tastes just as good as I remember. Thanks for a second taste." Fireheart blushed and his shaft had finally begun to retreat back into its protective sheath. Fireheart said, "You're welcome, Mistystar. How does it feel to mate for the first time and to have my seed inside?" Mistystar replied, "It feels amazing. And now we are truly mates. It makes me happy. Sorry it took so long to remember you, Firestar." Fireheart chuckled and said, "It's fine. You kept your promise." Mistystar purred and stood up, but fell back down, her legs shaking intensely. Fireheart walked over and curled up beside her.

In Thunderclan:

Dovewing's eyes went wide in disbelief as she listened to Fireheart's and Mistystar's conversation. She had made her senses come back to Thunderclan before they started to mate. She muttered, "His name is Firestar. And he is the Leader of Lionclan. And he used to be a Twoleg?! And he was on fire when he chased after Mistystar! I thought his pelt igniting in flames when he gave the speech to Thunderclan was a trick of the eyes!" Dovewing took a breath and said, "This must be why Bramblestar warned me to keep my senses in the Thunderclan camp! It has to be!"

Back with Fireheart and Mistystar:

Fireheart felt strength and power flow through him. He looked around and Mistystar asked, "What is it, Firestar?" Fireheart replied, "Some cat just remembered a little about me. Who could it be? Shit! Dovewing! I forgot about her senses! She could've been listening to our conversation! Fuck! And she could have listened to us mate!" Mistystar asked, "What's wrong with that?" Fireheart replied, "Nothing, but if she was listening, I never wanted her to find out about how I used to be a Twoleg until she was ready to mate! However, I guess it is best if she did find out now, so she can decide to be with Bumblestripe instead of me. Hmmm." Mistystar's legs were still shaking and she mewed tiredly, "Sleep next to me on the Forest floor?" Fireheart purred and replied, "Happily Mist." Mistystar purred and fell asleep, her head on Fireheart's chest, Fireheart's tail wrapped around her in a protective manner. Fireheart made sure his own cum wasn't touching him and purred lightly, as he stayed up all night to make sure nothing would sneak up on them, even though he was tired.

There we go! The first Lemon of Book two! How was it?! Better than the lemons of my first book for this series! Be honest. May Starclan watch over you all!