Brewster was in the process of making a coffee when he noticed Tom Nook, Mr. Resetti, and Rover were all being chased by a piece of paper with the words 'Milk', 'Eggs', and 'Cheese' printed on it.
"Run! Don't even take a look at it!" Rover exclaimed at the top of his lungs as he screamed.
Brewster murmured as he took a step out, wondering what the commotion was with the floating piece of paper. He squinted, the three animals running back towards the Roost as they ran past it, with the floating shopping list looking directly at Brewster, and Bewster looking directly back at it.
"Brewster, no!" Rover cried as he began crying, with Tom Nook pulling him back.
"It's too late, Rover! He's been exposed to the floating shopping list!" Tom Nook tried talking sense into the bluish cat.
Mr. Resetti frowned as he shook his head, taking off his yellow helmet. "Oh, the animanity..."
The floating shopping list was too much for Brewster, as the penguin suddenly exploded into a pile of coffee, with the floating shopping list spotting Rover, Tom Nook, and Mr. Resetti. The three animals screamed as they began running with fright again, the floating shopping list resuming its chase.