In New York, Rachel and Kurt put up the Christmas tree. Kurt said, "Well, I think we've outdone ourselves."
Blaine said, "Don't you think that tree is a little high on one side?"
Rachel said, "Looks fine to me."
There was a knock on the door.
Kurt asked, "Who could that be at this hour?"
Rachel said, "I'll go see." The door opens and she gasped.
Shelby said, "Now this is what I call an apartment."
"Shelby!" She jumped on her and hugged her.
Shelby laughed and spun around.
Kurt said, "Oh! Shelby!"
"Hey, Kurt!" She hugged him. "It feels so good to be social! Blaine." They also hugged.
Kurt said, "Hey, where's Jack?"
Shelby said, "Oh, he's in LA telling his family about the wedding."
Rachel said, "I'm guessing his mom won't be too happy about that."
"Yeah."
Blaine said, "Hey, maybe she'll come around."
"I don't know about that."
Kurt asked, "What about Anne Marie and Ian?"
Rachel said, "I think they're going to Miami. At least that's what Claire told me."
The gang was putting up their own Christmas tree in the community center.
Claire started off singing "As Long As There's Christmas" from Belle's Enchanted Christmas. Anne Marie and Ian joined in. Henry did, too. The new kids also joined in. Kitty said, "Hey, come on, you guys. The lights go on first."
Anne Marie said, "Well, I think we've outdone ourselves."
In the Spotlight Diner, Kurt and Blaine were singing "Spread the Pureblood Cheer" by the Purebloods, but they changed "Pureblood" to "Christmas." Spread the Christmas Cheer!
Outside in the ice skating rink. Rachel said, "I don't really have a wedding present for you yet, but I do have your Christmas/Hanukkah gift."
Shelby looked a bit confused.
Jack skated from behind. "Christmas gram for a Miss Shelby Corcoran."
Shelby turned around, "Honey!" She hugged him. "Oh, when did you get here?"
"Just a few hours ago. I couldn't wait to see you."
"Oh, now we can spend the holidays together."
"Like I was gonna spend the night away from my two favorite girls."
Shelby and Jack skated and Rachel smiled at them. She seemed content. At peace. Like she was finally ready to let Jack go. All three of them were singing "When Christmas Comes to Town" from The Polar Express.
Shelby said, "You remember when I said there was no one there to love Rachel as much as I do? I was wrong." She put her hand on his cheek. "He was right here in front of me the whole time." She leaned forward.
Jack said, "Uh, you know, it's pretty cold out. If we kiss, I'm afraid our lips will get frozen stuck together."
Shelby smiled, "It'll be worth it." She kissed him.
In the center, Jermaine wanted everyone to perform sometime before Christmas. Claire and Anne Marie performed "Christmas Wish" by ALL CAPS.
Marley said, "And now, ladies and gentlemen, please welcome to the stage, Mr. Ian Rivers."
Anne Marie and Ian were singing that classic tune, "I Want a Hippopotamus for Christmas."
Treble Base were singing "This Christmas" by Tonks and the Aurors.
Everyone in the community center clapped. Claire took her bow. She said, "Merry Christmas, everybody." Everyone else said, "Merry Christmas!"