Chapter 8: Mashing The Love Button

A brown colt shot me a grin from across the store. I dropped my gaze, blushing to myself. Scootaloo grabbed me by the shoulders, pulling me in with a large grin on her face. "Go talk to him, Sweetie Belle!" she said.

Covering my mouth with my hoof so the colt couldn't read my lips, I said, "I can't do that! I'd be too nervous."

Apple Bloom patted me on the back. "He's been eyein' you since we got here!" the red-maned filly encouraged. "Go on, Sweetie Belle!"

The crusaders then pulled me off of my seat, and suddenly, I was making direct eye contact with the colt from across the room. I tried turning back, but the girls both motioned for me to go talk with him, and it didn't look like they were about to let me chicken out of this one. Taking a big gulp, I put one hoof in front of the other until I found myself right in front of him.

This whole thing was almost demoralizing. I was sweating awkward bullets, trying to bat off social anxiety. Why was meeting somepony new suddenly so hard for me? Without thinking anymore, I stuttered, "H-hi. I'm Sweetie Belle."

"Hey, Sweetie Belle! I'm Button! Wanna see this new game I got?"

And just like that, all the nerves disappeared. I smiled and took a seat next to him as he showed me his videogame, and I couldn't help but mumble to myself, "I think I'm gonna like this guy."

We talked for what felt like it must have been an hour at least. It turned out that he was really sweet and funny and really good at videogames. I tried playing his game for a whole 2 minutes before giving up just as Apple Bloom and Scootaloo walked over.

"Hey, Sweetie Belle," Apple Bloom said, "we gotta git goin'. Y'all gonna stay here?"

I looked at Button with a conflicted expression. I didn't need to say a word, though, as he read me perfectly. "Go ahead, Sweetie Belle," he said. "I'll meet you here same time tomorrow?"

"That sounds great!" I exclaimed, giving him a quick hug. "I'll see you tomorrow, Button!"

The girls and I left the ice cream shop, and the minute we knew that Button was out of both seeing and hearing distance, Apple Bloom was right there in my face, smiling. "Somepony must have hit it off really well!"

"YEAH! You two were talking together forever!" Scootaloo chimed in, taking Apple Bloom's place in front of my face. "Is he nice? What's he like? Was he funny? Is he your boyfriend?"

Backing up a little, I said, "Hold on, girls! I mean I just barely met him. He seems really nice, but I'm not ready to call him my boyfriend yet."

"But y'all do have another date with him tomorrow, don't ya?"

"A... date?"

Scootaloo giggled. "Your first date, Sweetie Belle! Be sure to tell us all about how it goes!"

"Wait! Aren't you two coming?"

"Nahhh. We don't wanna ruin the romance. Well, we'll see you tomorrow, Sweetie Belle!"

Taking a gulp and watching the other crusaders part ways, I mumbled, "S-see you."

I got to the milkshake parlor the next day and waited for Button. As I waited, there were already a million thoughts racing through my head.

Did he forget?

Did his mom say he couldn't come?

Do I look OK?

What videogames does he play again?

"HELLOOOO SWEETIE BELLE! HIIII!"

I turned around in a flash, almost suffering from a heart attack on the spot. That was nothing, though, compared to how quickly my heart was beating once I saw Button's eyes looking straight at me.

"Button!" I said, trying to catch my breath all of a sudden. "You scared me!"

"I brought my JoyBoy today. I thought you might like it better than what I had yesterday."

Taking his hoofheld toy awkwardly, I asked, "Are you sure? I'm not very good at videogames."

"You were doing fine yesterday. Besides, you're Sweetie Belle! You seem to me like you're good at everything!" I blushed profusely, pulling my mane in front of my cheeks. "Waiteeeer! Hey! Hey waiteeeerr! WAITE- Oh, there you are. Two please! So, Sweetie Belle, have you done anything to earn your cutie mark yet?"

"Not yet," I said as we sat side by side at the nearest table. "The girls and I tried being cutie mark crusader firefighters, buuuuut..." I lifted up my tail, which was slightly burnt at the end.

"Bummer! Have I told you yet that you have a really pretty mane, by the way?"

Now I had to hide how much I was blushing with my hoof. "Listen, Button. About us... Do you think we like each other enough to be called-"

"Oooorder up!"

Suddenly, two milkshakes slammed onto our table. Button then got right in my face with a large, boyish grin and shouted, "Milkshake race! One! Two! Three! GO!"

He then drank his milkshake as fast as he could until he fell onto the floor, grabbing his head and screaming. Getting bored of him writhing on the floor, I grabbed his toy and started playing, suddenly wondering why I was in love with this guy.

Wait, I'm in love with him,?

Button, once he finished screaming, got back to his seat and shouted, "I WIIIIN! Hm? Sweetie Belle, why are you looking at me like-"

I closed my eyes and kissed him gently on the lips. Once I pulled away, he just sat there with a blank look on his face, unsure of what to say. Quickly shrinking in my chair, I said, "Sorry. I just... realized that I really like you."

"See! I told you that you're good at everything!"

I blinked in confusion. "W-huh? What do you mean?"

"You're a really good kisser!"

More confusion! "Have you kissed many girls before?"

"Only my mom. Hey! Once you're finished with your milkshake, I know the perfect place we can go!"

"Really? Where is it?"

"Finish your milkshake! I want it to be a surprise."

I quickly finished my milkshake (handling the brain freeze much more easily than Button did) and followed him up to a hill near the top of Ponyville where the sun was just barely beginning to set. As I looked around, I couldn't see anything except grass and a tree.

"Why did you wanna take me here?"

"Just to watch the sunset."

"Wait, Really?"

"Yep. Just look at it. Now whenever I see a sunset this beautiful, I'll remember the filly I watched it with: the only thing that can outshine the sun."

I wanted to cry. This was the most romantic thing anypony had ever done for me. I kissed him again, holding my lips against his for as long as I possibly could. Once our lips broke apart, I snuggled with him as close as I could, talking the day away as the dusk turned to night. I felt like I was about to fall asleep in hooves when- "No! NO! Don't jump in the water! Awwww mannn." Giggling to myself, I kissed him on the cheek and fell into a slumber.

The next day, we met up at the same time and place. For some reason, though, I was being a girl and checking to make sure my mane looked really nice today. Button arrived only a few minutes after me.

"Hey, Sweetie Belle! Listen, I thought we could try hanging out somewhere else today. Is that OK?"

"Sure! Where did you have in mind?"

"Come on! I'll show you!"

He grabbed me by the hoof and led me to some place that I'd never seen before. We were in some secluded alley behind a few buildings. "B-Button? Where are we?"

"Sweetie Belle, do you like me?"

The question caught me off guard. "What do you mean? Of course I like you!"

"Then lay on the floor."

And suddenly, I was scared.

"What?" Looking down, I noticed his penis beginning to grow outside his sheath. "Uh, oh..."

I wanted to say something, but his look had changed from silly to serious. Without wasting another moment, I got on my back.

"Spread your legs."

"Button, this isn't-"

"I said spread 'em!" I timidly complied, beginning to shake as I watched Button lick his lips. "Ohhhh this is gonna be good."

He brought his hoof to my vulva and pulled my labia apart, staring at the pink insides that surrounded my hole. Acting more out of fear than courage, I began, "Button... I don't think-"

"Oh, you wanna open your mouth, huh?"

"I..." Before I could wrap my mind around what was going on, Button had stuck his dick into my mouth.

"Now suck it, Sweetie Whore."

I didn't know what else to do. I bobbed my head back and forth, sucking as much of his penis as I could take in.

"Yeah, do you like that?"

I was too busy sucking to answer, which I hoped he wasn't expecting.

"DO YA?!"

I nodded my head in fear and went back to sucking.

"Oh, you DO, huh? Then lemme give you some more."

He put his full length in my mouth, forcing me to deep throat him. I began to cry and gag as he took full advantage of my body and emotions.

"Ohhh yeah. Just like that. Don't forget to lick my ballsack. I'd hate to see what happens if you missed that."

I tried bringing my tongue out, but just ended up gagging on his shaft. He was using me with no regard to my feelings or body. He had these sick desires, and he was only using me to fulfill those desires. The worst part of it all, though, to make things even worse, I loved every second of it.

He grabbed me by the mane and pulled me in deeper. Mmm how I wished he'd pull harder. His dick was already pretty big for a colt, but I knew I could make it bigger. I licked up his shaft, spending time massaging the ring of his penis.

"Mmmm," he cooed. "You like that, don't you, Slutty Bell?"

I moaned quietly on his shaft, which I could feel begin to grow in my mouth. He pushed his hoof through my mane, and even through his roughness and violence, he still managed to treat me like a lady. I was beginning to feel damp between my legs. I squeezed them together, feeling the most pleasure I had felt in days. I returned my mind to closing my eyes tenderly, sucking up and down his dick as he told me what he wanted. I put away any ideas of being ladylike so I could be his perfect little slut that he could do whatever he wanted with.

He pulled out of my mouth, a strand of saliva dripping down his dillhole. I was breathing heavily, thinking of all the things he could do with me next.

Rubbing up and down his shaft, he said, "Lay back down, slut." I complied as he quickly spread my knees apart, opened my labia wider and licked up my draining lube. "Mmmm. You taste just as good as you look. Wanna have some fun?"

"Please, Button! I need it so bad!"

He angled his penis towards my soaking pussy. "Wet already, are you?"

I pulled my lady lips wider. "Mmm yes, Button. Put it in me."

He put it in all at once. Even through all my times with Daddy, nopony had ever been this rough, which made me go crazy in pleasure already. My inner walls attempted to latch onto his throbbing penis, but he was so rough that my vagina hardly had any time to keep up. It felt like he was going straight through me, having time to touch every sensitive area of my body with every stroke. The edge of his penis rubbed along my orifice, telling me to spread wider just so he could fit through. He was hitting the very edge of my insides, but I couldn't help but buck my hips forward, bringing him in deeper. By this point, my brain had shut down, leaving no thoughts in my mind but how good he felt.

He picked up my legs and put them on his shoulders. His pace was kicking up, making my fillyhood practically go numb. The sound of his penis going through me and the splashing of my girl parts echoed along the walls of the alley. A gentle moan escaped my lips.

"Louder, slut."

"Ahhhhh," I moaned, trying to be a little louder in my distracted state.

"Ohhhh so good. Do it again."

"Ahhhhhh!" I was squeezing my eyes closed, trying to make my throat sore as I screamed for the dick that I wanted so bad.

He flipped me over into a doggy-style position and penetrated me again. His hooves latched onto my flanks, helping him slide in and out as his manhood became covered with more feminine lust than ever. I pumped my plot into his pelvis, his long, hard penis just making everything so much more painful and making me crazy horny. As his length came out, it sent shivers down my legs. As he went back in, I would tense up, filled with that familiar sensation that brought me closer to an orgasm.

He pulled out, and my vagina was throbbing intensely, dripping lube onto the floor. My labia was so stretched out that they didn't even touch anymore. Instead, there was an exposed hole full of my vaginal juices and tightened walls. I was panting, taking in long, deep breaths just to keep myself alive. My heart was practically pumping out of my chest.

Button moved his hoof up my hole, collecting some of my wetness. He licked it up with a soft "Ahhh" at the end. "You want me Sweetie Belle?"

"Yes, Button."

"How bad do you want me?"

"So bad. I wanna feel you again."

"Then beg."

"PLEASE, Button! I wanna feel you sooo baaaddd!"

"You reeeeally want my cock?"

"YES! PUT IT IN ME! PLEEEEEASE!"

Button lifted up my tail, and suddenly I felt him penetrating me again. His erect penis was now coursing through my anal cavity. I bit onto my hoof, keeping myself from screaming in pain. He went in all at once, pushing as deep as he could go while laughing at my attempts to silence myself.

"Yeah," he chuckled. "Take it you whore."

"Mmmmmm go deeper, baby."

"You like it don't you?"

"Ohhhh it's so good."

He spanked me as he pumped into my anus, his voice cracking as he moaned. It was twice as hard for him to push inside my butthole as it was for my vagina (SO HOT!). He spanked me again, but this time I didn't even try to silence my screams. I wanted the whole world to know that I was Button's horny slut. He pulled my tail to help navigate his shaft through my narrow hole. His balls hit my clitoris as he made it in as deep as he could physically go. I was now screaming at the top of my lungs.

He then pulled out, stroking his shaft.

"Get on your knees and open up, whore."

I complied, getting just below and in front of his erect penis when I saw his balls begin to pulse. Thick strands of cum shot out of his penis and into my mouth. Most of it made it onto my tongue, but some of it missed and got on the rest of my face

He stopped stroking. "Let me see." I opened my lips, showing him all the cum that he put in my mouth. "Now swallow it." I gulped it down, feeling the savory, sticky liquid pour down my throat. I then looked down and saw that I was cumming on the ground beneath me.

My gaze shot back up to Buttons. My eyes were practically begging to kiss him, but I knew he wouldn't want his own sperm on his face. In a completely different demeanor, he said, "You might wanna get some of that off your face before you get back home." Giggling, I wiped the rest of the cum off my face and drank it all down. "Wow, Sweetie Belle. Where'd you learn to get so good at this?"

"Would you believe me if I said my Daddy?"

"Cooool! I learned from my mom. She's a real whore."

"Bet you I could do better."

"Are you kidding? You're way tighter than my mom ever was! I keep telling you, you're good at everything!"

Giggling to myself, I exclaimed, "I am not!"

"Oh yeah? Prove it!"

The two of us then walked off together, shoulder to shoulder, sharing laughs and smiles as we talked about anything and everything, Me and the boy I fell in love with.

Now this is the story all about how my life got flipped, turned upside down, and I'd like to take a minute. Just sit right there. I'll tell you all about how I went from being a filly to a mare.