Fool me Once

by hotangel241d

Damon is having a tough time dealing with his newfound emotions after shutting them out for so many years. Meeting Elena really threw him for a loop, she made him feel things he hadn't felt since he was human. He's so close to rescuing Katherine from the tomb, but what would happen if she wasn't in there? His whole life revolved around loving her. What purpose would his life have?

4. The Doppelganger

The doppelganger.

Stefans eyes widened as Katherine sauntered towards him, "Katherine. What-I mean how. I-" He stuttered as she ran her hands up his chest and then aggressively pushed him up against the wall.

"Aren't you happy to see me? I know you missed me. You're dating, or you weredating, my literal twin." She snickered as she leaned in towards his lips. Stefan growled and shoved her off him, his eyes darkened as his fangs dropped down. Katherine laughed as she walked further into the house, twirling her hair around one of her fingers. "Oh, don't be like that, Stefan. I'm only being honest."

Stefan scoffed as he vamped forward, stopping inches away from her, "Honesty was never really your strong suit, Katherine."

Katherine shrugged her shoulders as her lips pulled up into a smirk and she rolled her eyes, "Enough. I didn't come here to have pointless conversations."

Stefan titled his head in curiosity as he took a step closer to her, trapping her between him and the wall, caging her between his arms as he leaned against it, "Why are you here then? Hmm? You obviously know that Damon left right before you knocked on the door. Hewas the one who waited for you for 145 years, not me. I'm sure he would be thrilled to see you."

Katherine lightly shook her head as she linked her arms around the back of his neck, pulling him down closer to her lips, "I don't want Damon. It was always you, Stefan. I came here for you." He swallowed heavily and gazed into her eyes. She tantalizingly ran her tongue across her lips and her fingers up into his hair making his eyes flutter shut as he groaned. "I know you missed me, Stefan." She whispered before ghosting her lips against his. He abruptly gripped her hips and pressed her into the wall, his eyes burning with passion he had locked away for years. She gasped and jumped up, wrapping her legs around his waist, and then attacked his lips. He moaned loudly as he vamped them into the living room and smashed into the wall next to the fireplace, denting it from the force. Her fingers tangled into his hair, and she yanked his head back making him hiss. "Tell me. Tell me you missed me." She panted as she started to grind her hips against his hard cock. He growled as his fangs dropped down and he aggressively wrapped his hand around her throat.

"No." He smirked as her eyes darkened before crashing his lips down onto hers. She moaned and ran her hand down his chest, ripped the button off his jeans, and grabbed his throbbing cock. He gasped and started kissing down her neck as her hand began to move slowly up and down his length. "Fuck." He breathed out while vamping them to the couch, stumbling back onto it with her straddling his waist. Katherine tightened her grip around his cock and increased her pace as she stared hungrily into his eyes. His lips parted and his head fell back against the couch, he was so angry, he needed a release. She leaned into the crook of his neck as her hand sped up even more and ran her tongue up to his ear, lightly nibbling on his earlobe.

"Tell me, Stefan. Tell me you didn't miss this; didn't miss the way I can bring you to your knees." She whispered into his ear. Stefan let out a desperate moan as she let go of his cock and growled while he aggressively flipped them over, pressing her down into the couch. He ripped her pants down her legs and pulled his cock out to align it with her drenched core. She loudly cried out as he speared into her, giving her no time to adjust to his intrusion as he began to wildly thrust, "Mmm, that's right. Let me feel all that pent up rage." She seductively breathed out as her legs came up to wrap around his waist, pushing him deeper inside her.

"Fuck, Katherine!" Stefan growled as his fingers dug into her hips while she arched them up against him. His eyes rolled back into his head and tightly pressed shut, he could already feel his release starting to build up. Katherine ran her hand down his chest and then linked it behind his head making him groan. His eyes snapped open when he felt her fangs sink into his shoulder and a loud moan escaped his lips, "Uh, yes!" She smirked against his skin as she bit down deeper and tangled her fingers in his hair, roughly tugging on it. His rhythm was getting sloppy; she knew he was close, so she clenched down around him, loving the way his body shuddered. "I-don't, I can't" He whimpered as she let go of his shoulder and yanked his lips down to hers.

"Cum for me, Stefan." She breathed out before licking a line up his neck. She squeezed her muscles around his cock again, and he lost it. His eyes darkened and he violently bit down into her breast as he came deep inside her, his body trembling from the intensity of the release. "Yes, Stefan! Fuck!" She cried out as her own orgasm hit, scraping her nails down his back as it washed over her. Stefans mouth fell from her breast as he gasped for unrequired air, and he collapsed on top of her. He could feel her pussy still spasming around his cock, covering his body in goosebumps. She dropped her legs from around his waist and tenderly cradled his head against her chest, running her fingers lightly through his hair.

"Katherine?" Damon whispered in disbelief, his voice bursting into their bubble. Stefans eyes shot open, and he instantly jumped up from the couch, staring at his older brother with remorse. Damon was standing in the doorway, holding a bottle of bourbon that he had just picked up from the store on his way home from dropping off Elena; his face broken in ways Stefan had never seen. Katherine didn't even bother to cover herself up as she rolled onto her side, smirking at him with an evil glint in her eyes. Stefan scrambled to tuck himself back into his jeans and took a few steps in Damons direction with guilt written all over his face.

"Damon, I, she just. I was so angry about Elena. And then Katherine showed up, and I-I didn't, I'm sorry."

Damon scoffed at his brothers babbling backwards way of trying to justify what he just walked in and saw and glared down at Katherine, "You. I waited for you, for 145 years. I waited! I did so many horrible things to rescue you from that damn tomb! And, fuck, you weren't even in there. And the first person you seek out when you decide to conveniently return is Stefan?!" Damons chest was heaving as he clenched the bottle of bourbon in his hand. Katherine took an exaggerated deep breath before standing up and vamping over to him. His eyes were red but brimming with unshed tears and his body was vibrating with rage.

Katherine lightly ran her fingers down the side of his face and traced over his lips and he hated himself for letting himself be this emotional, "Don't take it so personally, Damon." She cooed as she leaned in towards his lips and then kissed her way up to his ear, "I never asked you to save me."

Damon growled furiously as his fangs dropped down and he threw her into the wall, wrapping his hand tightly around her throat. "You bitch. I died for you! I, God, I wasted my life loving you! I should kill you right now."

She snickered cruelly as she bent his wrist back, removing his hand from her throat and tackled him down to the floor, straddling his waist, "Please, Damon." She purred as she ran her hands up his chest, pressing herself down against his groin. "You would never kill me, you can't. And we both know that. But go ahead, do it. I dare you." She whispered into his ear before twirling her tongue around the shell of it. She smiled to herself when she felt his cock twitch in his pants and wiggled her hips back and forth. Damon grabbed her waist and tossed her off him, snarling as he vamped over to her and bashed the bottle of bourbon into her head.

"Fuck you." He shakily breathed out as she wiped the amber liquor from her face, "Was this ever, I mean, you, you never loved me. Did you?" He barely got the words out as he fought back tears.

Katherine slowly closed the distance between them and stared up into his eyes, "No. I didn't. It was always, Stefan." She told him, with absolutely no emotion in her voice. Damon felt the walls closing in on him, he wasted his entire life, died, for nothing. He glared back at Stefan as a single tear slid down his cheek, his lips beginning to quiver as his heart shattered into pieces, and then vamped out of the house, slamming the door behind him.

Stefan ran to catch up with him but when he opened the door, he was already gone, his car still sitting in the driveway. "Damon!"

..:..TVD..:..TVD..:..TVD..:..TVD..:..TVD..:..

Elena was brushing her teeth, getting herself ready for bed, when she suddenly saw Damon standing behind her in the mirror, his eyes swollen from crying. She quickly rinsed the toothpaste from her mouth and spun around, "Damon? What happened? What's wrong?" she softly asked as she reached up to wipe the tears from his cheeks. Damon chuckled humorlessly as more tears spilled from his eyes and shook his head. His lips parted as he tried to verbalize what he was feeling, explain what had just happened, but all that came out was a heartbroken sob. "Hey, shhh, it's okay." She soothingly said as she pulled him into a hug, wrapping her arms as tightly as she could around his trembling body. She tenderly ran her fingers up and down his back as she kissed everywhere she was able to reach without letting him go, "Talk to me. I'm right here." She whispered as she grabbed his hand and slowly guided him into her bedroom. Damon couldn't get his mind to cooperate with his mouth, his whole world felt like it was tilted on its axis. He sat down on the edge of her bed and raked his fingers through his hair while letting out a strangled deep breath. Elena sat next to him, her hand still rubbing tiny circles up and down his back, and patiently waited for him to let her in.

He stared up at the ceiling for a moment, hating himself for crying like this in front of her, before looking down into her eyes. He shakily cupped her face, running his thumb across her bottom lip and felt himself start to calm down just from being in her presence, "I- uh." He paused and cleared his throat, trying to stop his voice from breaking, "When I got home, I heard your voice in the living room and I thought, I thought you had somehow beat me back to my house. But then I heard Stefan, and, I, when I walked in, I saw them, together. She, they were, I wish I could just forget her!" He growled as his eyes pressed tightly shut, wishing he could erase his memory, before looking back at her. "She, she never even loved me." He whispered so low that she almost didn't hear him.

Elenas eyebrows scrunched together as she tried to understand what he was talking about, and then it all came together, "Katherine." She breathed out as she moved closer to him. He just nodded his head and let out a sigh, "Oh, Damon, she never deserved you. God. I'm so sorry." Her eyes filled with tears as she imagined how much pain he was in and wrapped her arms around him, cradling him against her body, "I'm sorry." She just kept repeating as she gently ran her fingers through his hair.

He let himself be comforted for a few more minutes before sitting up and gazing into her eyes, he felt like he needed her to understand why he was upset before she jumped to any conclusions on her own. "Elena, I'm not upset because I wanted her back, and I need you to know that." He paused when she tried to look away from him, but he gently grabbed both sides of her face to stop her, "I'm upset because I wasted my life for her. I died trying to save her and then waited for 145 years for her. That's what is hurting me. I could never want her back. Even if I never found you, I still would never take her back. She made me into, this, a monster, promised me eternity, and then threw me away, I could never forgive that."

Elena stared up into his eyes and nodded her head one time as she placed her hands over his, lacing their fingers together, "You are not a monster." She said with so much confidence that he felt his heart swell with emotion. "But listen, if you need time, Damon. I, I understand. I don't want-" he interrupted her as he surged forward and passionately kissed her, pouring everything he felt into it. She gasped as his mouth crashed against hers and he took the opportunity to deepen the kiss, twirling his tongue around hers as he slowly lowered her down onto the bed. Her hands dug into his hair and pulled him impossibly closer, moaning as he ran his hands down the sides of her body. He grabbed her waist and slid them higher up into the bed, never breaking their kiss. "Damon" She breathlessly moaned as he began to trail his lips down her neck, biting her with his human teeth. He loved the way she said his name, he couldn't get enough of it. He stopped when he reached her shirt and gazed up into her eyes, silently asking for her permission. She was already breathing heavily, and the scent of her arousal was dizzying, "Please." She panted as she reached down to pull her own shirt over her head, "Give me everything, Damon. I can take it."

Damon felt his cock harden as those words crossed her lips and a low growl rumbled from deep in his chest, "Elena, I don't-"

"Do it. I trust you." She said sternly as she arched up into his hand that was palming her breast.

He groaned as the veins trickled down under his eyes and bent down to suck one of her nipples into his mouth, scraping his fangs against it, making her shudder. He kissed his way up to her lips and stared down into her eyes, loving the way she was looking at him, like he was her whole world. "God, Elena. You have no idea what you do to me."

She smiled seductively as she ran her hand down his chest, cupping him through his jeans, "Show me." She whispered before leaning up to teasingly bite down on his neck. A loud groan escaped his lips, and he grabbed both her wrists, pinning them above her head; his chest heaving as he tried to get himself under control, but the dangerous way she was gazing up at him was making it extremely difficult. He ripped his shirt off and wrapped her arms around his neck, he needed to feel her bare skin against his. She dug her nails into his back making him hiss, and aggressively pulled him down, stopping inches away from her lips, "Don't hold back." She breathed out before roughly tugging on his hair and kissing him with a fierce passion.

"Fuck." He moaned as she tilted his head to the side and bit his neck, hungrily drinking him in. His body shivered as her teeth broke his skin and he couldn't stop himself from sinking his fangs into her as well, igniting a fire inside him that he thought he would never feel again. His fingers dug into her hips as she ground up into him, rubbing her heated core against his throbbing, confined cock. Her nails tore at the skin of his back making him drink deeper; he could feel her bite down again, reopening the wound as she greedily sucked his blood, and he almost came on the spot. He gasped for air and let go of her neck, cradling the back of her head, holding her in place. He started to thrust against her, his cock throbbing and leaking, he was already so close to cumming. She finally removed her mouth from him, panting heavily as she tried to catch her breath, but he didn't give her much time before he crashed his lips onto hers. Her arms wrapped around him as their bodies continued to grind together, she could feel an orgasm building up and she could tell he was close too. He ran his hands down her body and gripped onto her hips, his body was trembling and the heat from her body was so inviting. He suddenly pulled himself away from her lips and tore her shorts off along with her panties, growling at the smell of her arousal. His cock was basically begging him for release, but he couldn't stop himself from tasting her. He slid down her body, kissing and biting on his way, and ran his tongue up her slit.

"Yes, oh God!" She cried out as she arched off the bed, her pussy was drenched and so close to cumming, "Damon, I, I need you, now!" Damon smirked against her pussy, loving how she was pleading with him to fuck her, but he wanted to taste her cum on his tongue first. He gazed up at her through his thick eyelashes as he twirled his tongue lightly around her clit before sucking it between his lips. Her hands tangled into his hair, and she started to grind against his face, "Oh, please, please!" He let his eyes fall closed as he lost himself in her, relentlessly licking her pussy. He brought her right to the edge and then pulled away, so he could stick his tongue inside her, fucking her with it. She whined and begged but he grabbed her hips and held her firmly to the bed as he alternated between sucking on her clit and tongue fucking her. "Damon, please! I need to cum, please!" She sobbed as her body broke out into a thin layer of sweat, trembling and tight from anticipation. He looked up at her and watched as he sucked her clit into his mouth, and pushed two fingers into her pussy, curling them towards her g-spot. Her eyes shot open, and she stared down at him as her lips parted with a silent, breathless, moan. She kept her eyes trained on his as he finally let her fall over the edge, "Uhh, I, ohmy, fuck, D-Damon!" Her body began to violently shake as her orgasm ripped through her, and he drank her in, moaning loudly at the sweet taste of her cum. He waited until her body stopped shaking before slowly pulling his fingers from her and kissing his way back up to her lips. She was panting heavily, and her pupils were blown wide open, "Damon, please, fuck me." She growled as she jumped up and pushed him onto his back, taking him by surprise.

His cock was pulsing at this point, and he knew as soon as he felt her tight warmth around him, he was done for. She quickly removed his jeans and boxers in one swift motion and straddled his waist, rubbing her drenched pussy up and down his length, "Jesus, Elena. Don't tease me, please." He groaned as his cock throbbed against her. She leaned down and sucked one of his nipples between her lips as she grabbed his cock and slid onto it, making his body tremble. He growled and grabbed her hips, aggressively flipped them around so he was on top again and began to fiercely thrust into her tight pussy. His eyes darkened with lust as he gazed down at her, admiring the way her breasts bounced as he fucked her. He grabbed her legs and threw them up onto his shoulders before bending down to bite one of her nipples, making her cry out at the combination of pain and pleasure. He dug his fingers into her hips as he pounded her into the bed, and his fangs began to drop down as he neared his release. He growled and stared down at her, his eyes dark with desire, and she instantly tilted her head back, offering herself to him fully. He leaned into the crook of her neck and bit down harder than he meant to, but she didn't seem to mind as she let out a loud moan. He hungrily sucked her blood down his throat as he let himself go, drilling into her like she told him to.

"Yes, let go, Damon! Give me everything, I can feel you throbbing inside me, cum for me!" She panted as her legs suddenly kicked out and wrapped tightly around his waist. He growled against her skin and felt his release starting from the bottom of his stomach. A warmth washed over him, and he started to tremble as his toes curled and as he was beginning to cum, she harshly bit down into his shoulder, and he saw stars behind his eyes. His mouth fell from her neck as he let out a strangled moan and his cum shot out deep inside her, making his legs shake and covering his body in goosebumps. Elena licked the bite marks she made and let her head fall back against the pillow, gazing up at him as she tenderly ran her fingers through his hair, pushing it off his face. His lips were parted as he stared down at her and he felt his eyes start to fill with tears so he went to roll off her, but she wouldn't let him, "Don't, don't hide from me. Please." She whispered as she gently pulled his lips down to hers, kissing him with everything she had left in her. He rested his forehead against hers and closed his eyes as she soothingly trailed her fingers up and down his back until his body stopped shaking. He slowly sat up and gazed into her eyes, smiling at how happy she genuinely made him feel. She smiled back as he rolled onto her side and waited for her to snuggle against him, kissing the top of her head as her arm wrapped around his torso. He tenderly rubbed her back and laid his head down on top of hers, finally letting his body and his heart relax. "Hey, Damon?" Elena sounded nervous which instantly made his anxiety spike again.

"Hmm?" He was trying to breathe through his negative thoughts, but his insecurities were winning. She could feel him starting to shake again and propped herself up on her elbow, gently cupping his face while she gazed down into his eyes, smiling reassuringly.

"I, I think, no I mean, I." She paused and took a settling deep breath, watching as his eyes frantically searched hers for what she was trying to say, "Damon, I love you. It's impossible for me not to. And you don't have to say it back. I know you still love her, but I just, I needed you to know, that I really do, that someone cares about you and loves you. I don't know when it happened but, I love you, Damon, and I just want to make you happy."

Damon had tears rolling down his cheeks at her adorable admission and he tucked her hair behind her ear before pulling her down into a tender kiss, "I don't love her, Elena. I don't even know if I ever did. I just didn't know what love felt like until I found you. You have no idea how happy you make me. You calm down everything in my head, you see the good parts of me that I thought I lost centuries ago. Elena, I love you so much."

Elena giggled nervously and kissed him sweetly while lacing her fingers with his, "I'll never let you feel alone. I promise." She breathed out against his lips.

He smiled into their kiss and gently grabbed both sides of her face, "I don't deserve you."

"No, you really don't. Elena, what the hell is going on?"

Elena jumped up and wrapped her sheet around their naked bodies at the sound of her Aunt Jennas voice, "Oh my God. Aunt Jenna, I, it's not, can we talk about this after I get dressed?" She squeaked as Damon smiled to himself at how adorable her blushing cheeks were. Aunt Jenna glared at the two of them and rolled her eyes, leaving her room and closing the door behind her with an exaggerated sigh. "Damon, I'm so sorry." She panicked as she turned to face him but was surprised to see him smiling back at her. "What, why are you smiling?" She couldn't help but laugh a little at how cute he looked when he was genuinely smiling about something.

Damon playfully growled at her and grabbed her around the waist, rolling her underneath him, making her giggle, "Because, I'm happy, Elena. You make me so unbelievably happy." And then he kissed her softly on the lips, taking away all of her anxiety.

Little did they know that Stefan was right under her window. After Damon left their house earlier, he ran after him to make sure he didn't do anything reckless. The last place he thought to look was Elenas, and hearing how happy they both sounded made his stomach churn. Of course he wanted his brother to be happy, but not with Elena. Elena was supposed to be his.

"Why are you here, Stefan? You don't need her anymore. I have such big plans for us. Me, you and Damon." Katherine whispered into his ear as she wrapped her arms around his waist from behind, pulling him against her body.