The courtroom was packed, a sea of reporters, legal enthusiasts, and fans of both Grey Sloan Memorial and the now-notorious defendants. The case had gripped the nation, broadcasting live internationally with millions glued to their screens. For the first time, personal grievances, professional ambitions, and deep-seated betrayals were laid bare under the cold, harsh light of justice.


Judge Martha Wallace adjusted her glasses and banged her gavel. "Court is now in session. This is the matter of Jo Wilson versus Alex Karev and Izzie Stevens. Counsel, are you ready to proceed?"

Annalise Keating rose from her seat with commanding grace. Her dark suit was impeccably tailored, exuding power and precision. "The plaintiff is ready, Your Honor."

On the other side, Connor Walsh, sharp and slick, gave a tight nod as he stood. "The defense is ready, Your Honor."

Judge Wallace scanned the courtroom. "Very well. Ms. Keating, your opening statement."


Annalise walked to the jury box, her heels echoing on the polished floor. Her presence was magnetic, and her voice resonated with a mix of authority and empathy.

"Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, this is a case about betrayal—personal and professional. Dr. Jo Wilson devoted her life to her career, her patients, and her marriage. And what was her reward? Deception. Abandonment. Her husband, Alex Karev, not only broke his vows but blindsided her, leaving her life in chaos to run back to a past relationship with Dr. Izzie Stevens."

She turned, her eyes piercing the jurors. "This isn't just about heartbreak. It's about consequences. Alex Karev didn't just leave his wife—he left her with shared debts, career sabotage, and emotional devastation. And Dr. Stevens? She's not an innocent party. Her actions enabled this deception."

Annalise leaned slightly toward the jury, lowering her voice. "By the end of this trial, you will see that Jo Wilson deserves justice. And we will prove that justice demands accountability."

She walked back to her seat, her expression resolute.


Connor Walsh stood and smoothed his tie. He approached the jury box, his posture relaxed, almost conversational.

"Ladies and gentlemen, what Ms. Keating wants you to believe is a story—one-sided, dramatic, and full of assumptions. Yes, Alex Karev left his marriage. Yes, he reunited with Dr. Stevens. But life isn't a courtroom drama. People make tough decisions, sometimes messy ones. My clients acted in the best interests of their family."

He glanced toward Alex and Izzie, who sat stoically. "Dr. Karev discovered he had children he didn't know existed. As a father, he made a choice—a choice to be present, to give his kids the family he never had. Is it painful for Dr. Wilson? Absolutely. But is it illegal? No."

Connor stepped closer to the jury, his tone softening. "This case isn't about justice. It's about anger. Dr. Wilson is hurt, and she wants someone to blame. But the law isn't about assigning blame—it's about facts. And the facts will show my clients did nothing wrong."

He returned to his seat, exchanging a brief nod with Alex.


The Witness Testimonies

The first day centered on establishing the emotional and financial fallout. Jo Wilson was called as the first witness.

Annalise guided her gently. "Dr. Wilson, can you describe your life with Alex before he left?"

Jo hesitated, her voice trembling slightly. "We were... happy, or so I thought. We were partners in everything. We worked at the same hospital, supported each other's careers. Then one day, he was just... gone."

"Gone?" Annalise pressed.

Jo nodded, her composure cracking. "He left a letter. That's it. No conversation, no warning. Just a letter saying he was leaving to be with Izzie."

Annalise handed her the letter. "Is this the letter?"

Jo's hand shook as she held it. "Yes."

Annalise turned to the jury. "Let the record show this letter was the only communication Dr. Karev gave before abandoning his marriage."

Connor rose. "Objection, Your Honor. Mischaracterization. Dr. Karev left additional explanations in subsequent communications."

Judge Wallace nodded. "Sustained. Ms. Keating, rephrase."

Annalise nodded smoothly. "What impact did this letter have on you, Dr. Wilson?"

Jo looked at the jury, her pain palpable. "It destroyed me. I had to take time off work. I couldn't pay our mortgage alone. I was blindsided."


Connor's cross-examination was swift and surgical. He approached Jo with an air of calculated charm.

"Dr. Wilson, you claim you were blindsided. But isn't it true that your marriage had been struggling for months before this?"

Jo frowned. "We had our issues, but we were working on them."

Connor raised an eyebrow. "Working on them? Or avoiding them? Didn't you once tell a colleague that Alex was 'pulling away'?"

Jo's eyes narrowed. "I didn't think he would leave me."

Connor held up a document. "You mentioned financial struggles. Isn't it true that Dr. Karev transferred his share of the mortgage to you before leaving?"

Jo hesitated. "Yes, but—"

Connor cut in. "So, while painful, Dr. Karev didn't leave you financially unsupported, correct?"

Jo's jaw tightened. "Technically, yes."

Connor smiled faintly. "Thank you, Dr. Wilson. No further questions."


The Defendants Speak

Alex Karev took the stand next, his demeanor somber. Annalise wasted no time.

"Dr. Karev, why didn't you tell your wife in person that you were leaving?"

Alex looked down. "I didn't know how. I knew it would hurt her, and I didn't want to see her in pain."

Annalise pounced. "So you thought a letter was kinder? Easier for you, maybe?"

Alex flinched. "It wasn't about me. I had to think about my kids."

Annalise raised an eyebrow. "Your kids. Kids you didn't know existed until recently. Did you ever consider discussing this with your wife, your partner?"

Alex's voice rose slightly. "I didn't have time! It was all happening so fast—"

Annalise's voice sharpened. "Or was it because you'd already decided your marriage didn't matter?"

"Objection!" Connor interjected. "Argumentative."

"Sustained," Judge Wallace warned. "Ms. Keating, move on."


The courtroom buzzed as Izzie Stevens took the stand. Annalise's tone was cold.

"Dr. Stevens, were you aware Alex was still married when he came to you?"

Izzie straightened. "Yes, but I didn't encourage him to leave."

Annalise's eyes narrowed. "Really? Because we have phone records showing frequent calls between you two months before he left."

Izzie faltered. "We were catching up as friends."

Annalise stepped closer. "Friends? Friends who just happened to have a romantic history and children together?"

Connor jumped up. "Objection! Badgering."

Judge Wallace sighed. "Sustained. Ms. Keating, watch your tone."


As the day concluded, tensions ran high. Both sides had landed blows, but the jury's expressions remained inscrutable. The trial had only just begun, and it was clear this international showdown would be anything but predictable.