The courtroom was a storm brewing with tension on Day 8 of Wilson v. Karev and Stevens. The trial had long since stopped being about just the legal dispute between Jo Wilson and Alex Karev—it had morphed into a battle of character assassination and deeply personal vendettas. Millions around the world were glued to their screens, anticipating yet another dramatic day.
Jo Wilson arrived with Annalise Keating, both wearing steely expressions, while Alex Karev and Izzie Stevens sat at the defense table with Connor Walsh, visibly bracing themselves for another tumultuous round. The previous day's allegations had left the court shaken, but no one expected how ugly the proceedings would get today.
Judge Martha Wallace entered, slamming her gavel with more force than usual. "Court is now in session. Let me remind both parties that this is a legal proceeding, not a soap opera. I expect civility and focus on the matters at hand. Mr. Walsh, you may call your next witness."
Connor Walsh rose smoothly, his trademark smirk firmly in place. "Thank you, Your Honor. The defense calls Dr. Alex Karev to the stand."
Alex stood, adjusting his jacket nervously as he made his way to the witness stand. After being sworn in, he sat down, his expression a mix of defiance and unease.
Connor Walsh's Examination of Alex Karev
Connor began, his tone conversational but pointed. "Dr. Karev, over the past week, the plaintiff has made numerous allegations against you, some of which paint you as a man with questionable character. How do you respond to these claims?"
Alex exhaled sharply. "I think they're exaggerated, twisted, and in some cases, outright lies."
Connor nodded sympathetically. "Can you give an example of something you believe has been misrepresented?"
Alex leaned forward slightly. "Jo's trying to make me look like a villain, but she's not innocent either. She's made mistakes—big ones. And her behavior put other people at risk."
Connor raised an eyebrow, his tone sharpening. "Can you elaborate on that, Dr. Karev?"
Alex hesitated for a moment, as if deciding whether to proceed. Then, he spoke with carefully measured outrage. "During the height of the pandemic, Jo was careless. She exposed Dr. Atticus Lincoln—Link—to COVID-19 because she refused to follow basic protocols."
The courtroom erupted in gasps and murmurs. Jo's mouth dropped open in shock as Annalise immediately stood.
Annalise Keating's Objection
"Objection, Your Honor!" Annalise's voice was ice-cold, yet furious. "This is a baseless and inflammatory claim with no relevance to the case at hand."
Connor turned to the judge, his expression calm. "Your Honor, it speaks to the plaintiff's character and her alleged recklessness, which is directly relevant to the defense's position."
Judge Wallace frowned, her patience clearly frayed. "Mr. Walsh, unless you have concrete evidence to support this claim, I will not allow it."
Connor smiled faintly. "Your Honor, we have evidence in the form of medical records and text messages."
Judge Wallace's expression hardened. "Proceed carefully."
The Accusation Unfolds
Connor approached Alex. "Dr. Karev, what evidence do you have to support this accusation?"
Alex nodded, his tone growing more confident. "During the pandemic, Jo was constantly around Link and his son, Scout. She ignored quarantine guidelines after she had contact with a symptomatic patient. A few days later, Link tested positive for COVID-19. She put him—and his family—at risk."
Jo stood abruptly, her voice shaking with fury. "That's not true! I didn't know I was exposed, Alex, and you know that!"
Judge Wallace banged her gavel furiously. "Dr. Wilson, sit down! Address your counsel if you wish to respond."
Jo sat reluctantly, her face flushed with anger. Annalise placed a calming hand on her arm before standing.
Annalise's Cross-Examination
Annalise strode to the witness stand, her movements deliberate and precise. "Dr. Karev, you've just accused my client of reckless behavior during a global pandemic. Tell me, were you present during the alleged exposure?"
Alex shifted uncomfortably. "No, but I saw the fallout."
Annalise raised an eyebrow. "So, your accusation is based entirely on secondhand information?"
Connor stood. "Objection, argumentative."
Judge Wallace nodded. "Sustained. Ms. Keating, rephrase."
Annalise nodded, her tone icy. "Dr. Karev, are you aware that Dr. Wilson followed all hospital protocols during the pandemic, as verified by her department head?"
Alex hesitated. "I'm aware of what she claims, but the facts—"
Annalise cut him off. "The facts, Dr. Karev, are that you have no firsthand knowledge of the events you're describing. Isn't that correct?"
Alex's jaw tightened. "I know what I know."
Annalise smirked slightly. "What you know, or what you've assumed to further your smear campaign against my client?"
Jo's Emotional Testimony
Annalise returned to her table and whispered briefly with Jo before addressing the judge. "Your Honor, the plaintiff would like to rebut this accusation immediately."
Judge Wallace nodded. "Proceed, Ms. Keating."
Jo stood and took the stand once more, her hands trembling slightly as she was sworn in. Once seated, she faced the jury, her voice steady despite the tension in the room.
"I want to set the record straight," Jo began, her voice firm. "During the pandemic, I followed every protocol that Grey Sloan Memorial put in place. I cared for COVID-19 patients, yes, but I took every precaution to ensure I didn't expose anyone."
Annalise stepped forward. "Dr. Wilson, did you knowingly expose Dr. Atticus Lincoln to COVID-19?"
Jo shook her head vehemently. "No. When I found out I'd been exposed, I quarantined immediately. Link didn't catch COVID from me—he caught it from a patient he treated in the ER."
Annalise turned to the jury. "Dr. Wilson, how has this false accusation affected you?"
Jo's voice wavered slightly. "It's humiliating. Alex knows how hard I worked during the pandemic. He knows how much I sacrificed. And now he's using it against me because he can't take responsibility for his own actions."
Alex's Outburst
Alex couldn't contain himself any longer. "You're lying, Jo! You were reckless, and you know it!"
Judge Wallace slammed her gavel down repeatedly. "Dr. Karev, one more outburst, and you will be removed from this courtroom!"
Jo turned to Alex, her eyes blazing with anger. "You're pathetic, Alex! You can't stand the fact that people are finally seeing who you really are!"
Alex stood, his face red with fury. "And you're just bitter because you can't blame me for everything anymore!"
Judge Wallace motioned to the bailiff. "That's it. Dr. Karev, you're out of here. Bailiff, remove him."
As Alex was escorted out, the courtroom buzzed with shocked whispers. Jo sat back in her chair, visibly shaken but resolute.
The Fallout
When the court adjourned for the day, reporters outside the courthouse swarmed the attorneys and witnesses. Headlines quickly lit up social media: "Karev Smear Campaign Backfires," "Wilson Refutes COVID Allegations with Evidence," and "Courtroom Chaos as Karev Escorted Out."
Inside, Annalise and Jo regrouped, their determination stronger than ever. Meanwhile, Alex and Izzie left through a side entrance, avoiding the media frenzy.
Day 8 had proven to be one of the most volatile yet, and with every passing day, the trial moved further away from a resolution and deeper into the realm of personal destruction. The world waited to see who would emerge victorious—and at what cost.
