Chapter 4: Reunion and Revelation (288 AC)

The flames in the hearth of Winterfell's lord's solar cast flickering shadows against the stone walls, their crackling the only sound as Eddard Stark pored over reports. The North was vast, its threats constant. A stack of missives lay scattered across his desk, detailing raiding parties of Ironborn on the western coasts and growing unrest among the smallfolk. His fingers tightened around the parchment as he read of villages burned and families displaced—a grim reminder of the fragile peace his people lived under.

Yet, even as the weight of the North rested heavily on his shoulders, it was not the only burden that plagued him. The tension in his household had grown unrelenting. Catelyn's unease over Jon Snow lingered like a shadow, straining their conversations and stifling their moments of closeness. She didn't say it outright, but her resentment simmered beneath every glance she cast at the boy. Ned could feel the unspoken accusations in her eyes—that Jon was a threat to their children, to Robb in particular. It was a wound between them that he could not mend.

Outside, the faint sound of Robb's laughter echoed from the training yard, punctuated by the sharp clang of wooden swords. His son was too young to grasp the fissures that had formed in his family, finding solace in his games and playfights. Ned envied him for that innocence. He envied all his children for it, even Jon, who carried burdens of his own but still smiled like the boy he was.

A sharp caw broke the quiet, pulling Ned from his thoughts. The ravens in the rookery stirred, their cries echoing through the keep. Moments later, the heavy door to his solar creaked open, and Maester Luwin entered, a sealed letter in his hand.

"Lord Stark," the maester began, his voice gentle but firm. "A raven has arrived from Castle Black. It bears news from your brother, Benjen."

Ned sat upright, his attention fully captured. It had been years since Benjen had left for the Wall, trading the life of a Stark for the black cloak of the Night's Watch. News from him was rare, and always weighty.

Ned reached for the letter, breaking the seal quickly. His eyes scanned the words, his brow furrowing as he read. Benjen was returning to Winterfell. The letter explained that he would arrive alongside Lord Commander Qorgyle and a small retinue of sworn brothers. Their purpose was clear: to discuss the worsening plight of the Night's Watch. The Gift lands, once fertile and brimming with resources, had been left barren and undefended. The Watch's numbers were dwindling, their strength eroding with every passing year.

Ned exhaled slowly, setting the letter down. He looked to Luwin, his tone measured but urgent. "Prepare for their arrival. They'll need food, drink, and quarters. And send word to the kitchen to prepare a modest feast."

The maester nodded. "Of course, my lord."

"And Luwin," Ned added, his voice dropping slightly, "ensure that Jon is present when they arrive. He will want to see his uncle."

One moon later, a light snow fell over Winterfell as the Night's Watch delegation arrived. The courtyard was alive with activity as stable hands tended to horses, and the Stark household gathered to greet their guests. Ned stood at the top of the steps, his grey cloak billowing lightly in the cold wind.

The black-cloaked figures of the Watch rode in with quiet dignity, their faces weathered by years of frost and hardship. At their head was Benjen Stark, riding beside Lord Commander Qorgyle. Ned felt his chest tighten as he took in the sight of his younger brother. Time and the Wall had hardened him—his once-youthful face was lined, his shoulders broader beneath the heavy furs he wore. But the spark in his eyes, that indomitable Stark resilience, remained.

Ned greeted Lord Commander Qorgyle and the sworn brothers of the Watch first. Steward Vayon Poole stepped forward, offering bread and salt in the name of guest right. Only after these formalities did Ned turn to his brother, his expression softening.

Benjen dismounted, his boots crunching against the snow as he strode forward. "Thank you, Lord Stark," he said formally, though a smile tugged at the corners of his mouth. "For receiving us."

Ned stepped forward, breaking the formality with an embrace. "The Night's Watch is always welcome in Winterfell," he replied, his voice warmer now. "And so is my brother."

Benjen chuckled quietly, clapping him on the back. "It's good to be home, Ned." His eyes swept over the courtyard, landing on familiar faces. Catelyn stood to the side, Sansa's tiny hand in hers, while Robb darted forward eagerly. Behind them, more hesitant but no less present, was Jon Snow.

"How fares the North?" Benjen asked, his tone lighter now.

"As cold and restless as ever," Ned replied, his voice carrying a touch of humor. "And you, Benjen? How fares the Wall?"

Benjen's smile faded slightly, but he answered, "We'll talk of it soon."

Benjen turned to Catelyn, a playful smirk tugging at the corner of his mouth. "My lady, I hope my brother is not boring you with his dour face. It's been known to make ravens fall asleep mid-flight."

Catelyn's smile was polite, carefully measured, as befitted a lady of her station. She glanced at Ned briefly before replying, her tone calm but carrying an undertone that only those who paid close attention would catch. "My lord husband has many qualities that command respect," she said with grace. "Though I will admit, lively conversation is not one of them."

The words were said with perfect poise, but the subtle strain in her voice spoke volumes. The flicker of her eyes as she looked at Ned—just for a heartbeat—betrayed more than her composed expression let on. There was no harshness, no open criticism, yet the gulf between them felt palpable.

Benjen, perceptive as ever, caught the shift in the air but chose not to comment. His playful grin softened as he turned his attention back to Catelyn, his usual jest left hanging. Instead, he gave her a small, respectful nod.

Before the conversation could darken, Robb rushed forward, his red hair a messy halo around his eager face. "Uncle Benjen!" he called out, throwing himself at his uncle.

Benjen laughed and scooped Robb up, spinning him once before setting him down. "There's my favorite little lord!" he said warmly, ruffling the boy's messy red hair.

Robb grinned, his chest puffing out proudly. "I'll be as tall as you soon, Uncle Benjen. Maybe taller!"

"We'll see about that," Benjen teased with a chuckle before turning his gaze toward Jon, who lingered at the edge of the gathering, his uncertainty plain.

Benjen's attention then shifted to the petite figure of Sansa Stark, their youngest niece. With impeccable courtesy, she announced, "My lord, I am your only niece."

Amused and curious, Benjen playfully questioned, "Oh, is that so? Let's see," as he attempted to scoop up Sansa. However, Sansa, asserting her newfound sense of decorum, gently protested, "It isn't proper for a lady to be hugged like that."

Undeterred, Benjen responded with a twinkle in his eye, "Well, who might you be, then? And what have you done with her?" Sansa, her indignation giving way to laughter, asserted proudly, "I am your niece!" Benjen, ever the jester, swept Sansa into his arms and began to tickle her while repeating his query, "Who is my niece?" Sansa's laughter rang out in response, "Me!"

Benjen extended a hand, his expression softening. "And here's the other Stark blood, the quiet one. Come here, lad." He pulled Jon into a firm embrace, wrapping him tightly in his black-cloaked arms.

Jon's face lit up, his reserved demeanor breaking under the affection of his uncle. "Uncle Benjen," he said, his voice quieter than Robb's but no less filled with joy.

Benjen stepped back, his hands still resting on Jon's shoulders. "You've grown since I last saw you," he said, his voice low enough that only Jon could hear. "You remind me of Ned at your age. Quiet. Always watching."

Jon blinked at the words, his cheeks reddening slightly. He felt a surge of warmth, rare and treasured, from the man who seemed to see him in ways few others did.

Though Benjen treated Robb and Jon with the same outward kindness, Jon couldn't help but feel there was something different in the way Benjen looked at him. Perhaps it was the shared quietness, the sense of otherness Jon carried within him. In moments like these, Jon always felt Benjen gave him just a little more warmth, as if to make up for something Jon couldn't name. It wasn't enough to be obvious, but it was enough for Jon to notice—and cherish.

The Courtyard, Early Morning

The snow blanketed the courtyard, crisp and untouched except where Jon and Robb piled snow atop the battlement over the gate. They giggled and whispered, glancing over their shoulders as they schemed. Their plan was to push the snow down on some unsuspecting guard below, an act of childish mischief they couldn't resist.

As they worked, a shadow fell across them. A voice spoke, light and amused. "What are you two up to here?"

Both boys froze, their hands still buried in the snow. Slowly, they turned to find a tall man standing behind them. His black cloak swirled in the cold wind, and his weathered face held a roguish grin.

Robb, quick to recover, straightened and spoke with mock authority, mimicking his father. "We're building a snow barrier for… training purposes. You won't tell my father, will you?"

The man chuckled, his dark eyes twinkling with amusement. "Training purposes, is it? And here I thought you were up to mischief." He crouched slightly, bringing himself closer to their level. "Why should I keep your secret, young lord?"

Robb puffed out his chest, his grin wide. "Because I'm Robb Stark of Winterfell, and I'm telling you to."

The man raised an eyebrow, his grin widening. "Robb Stark, eh? And who's your quiet accomplice?"

Before Robb could answer, Jon spoke, his voice quieter but steady. "I'm Jon. Jon Snow."

The ranger tilted his head slightly, his expression shifting to one of curiosity. "Snow, is it?" he asked. "That means…"

Robb's playful demeanor vanished. He stepped forward protectively, his young face set with defiance. "He's my brother," he said firmly. "You don't need to say anything else."

The man's grin softened into something kinder. He raised a hand in mock surrender. "Easy, lad. I didn't mean any harm."

Robb narrowed his eyes but didn't reply. Jon, embarrassed by the sudden tension, spoke up. "It's fine, Robb. He didn't mean anything."

The man straightened, brushing snow from his cloak. "You're right, lad. I didn't." He glanced between the two boys, his expression thoughtful. "I was born north of the Wall myself. The Night's Watch found me as a babe and raised me as one of their own."

"North of the Wall?" Robb asked, his curiosity returning. "What's it like?"

"Cold," the man said with a smirk. "Colder than here. Harsh and dangerous… but beautiful, in its way."

Jon, intrigued now, asked, "You're a ranger?"

"Aye," the man replied. "Name's Mance Rayder."

Jon frowned slightly. "So… no one cared who you were? What name you had?"

Mance knelt again, meeting Jon's gaze. "At the Wall, no one cares if you're a Stark or a Snow. Your worth isn't in the name you're given, lad—it's in how you live, what you do. Remember that."

Jon's gray eyes searched Mance's face, and for the first time, he felt the weight of his name lessen, if only slightly. Robb, unable to help himself, asked, "Do people live north of the Wall?"

Mance nodded. "More than you'd think. But that's a tale for another time."

Jon's gaze shifted to the harp slung over Mance's shoulder. "Can you play?"

Mance grinned. "I can. Want to hear something?"

As the ranger began to play, a haunting melody filled the courtyard. The boys fell silent, the mischief in their hearts replaced by wonder. Jon felt something stir deep within him—a longing, a connection to something he couldn't yet name. It was a moment he would carry with him forever.

The melody lingered in the cold morning air, each haunting note from Mance Rayder's harp weaving a tapestry of unspoken stories. The courtyard seemed to hold its breath, as if the castle itself were listening. Jon stood still, his gray eyes locked on the ranger. Beside him, Robb was less solemn, breaking into applause as the final note faded.

"That was incredible!" Robb exclaimed, his grin stretching wide. "How can a ranger play like that?"

Mance chuckled, slinging the harp back over his shoulder. "Rangers aren't just swords and boots, boy. The wild doesn't care much for titles or traditions. If you want to survive out there, you need more than strength. You need stories. Songs. And a bit of wit to keep the cold at bay."

Robb tilted his head, his youthful curiosity overcoming him. "But what good is a song if you're fighting a pack of direwolves or wildlings?"

Mance smiled, the lines at the corners of his eyes deepening. "A song won't stop a sword or a hungry wolf, that's true. But it can warm the hearts of men. Or remind them what they're fighting for. You'll understand someday."

Jon, who had been silent until now, finally spoke. "Where did you learn to play?" His voice was quieter, more hesitant than Robb's, but there was an intensity in his question.

Mance regarded Jon thoughtfully, as though measuring the weight of his answer. "From an old man at the Shadow Tower," he said finally. "A man who'd seen more winters than most of the Wall's stones. He told me music was like the wind—it could go where men couldn't. Reach hearts that swords couldn't touch."

Jon nodded slowly, his gaze falling to the snow at his feet. He seemed lost in thought, but Robb, ever the one to fill silences, nudged him with his elbow.

"Maybe one day you'll play better than him, Jon!" Robb teased, his laughter bright and infectious.

Mance grinned. "If he's got the patience, maybe he will. What do you say, lad? Want me to teach you the harp?"

Jon's head shot up, his eyes wide with surprise. "You'd teach me?"

"Aye, if you've got the ears for it," Mance replied. "But like I said, it's not just about plucking strings. It's about listening. To the world. To the people around you. Learn to listen, and you might just surprise yourself."

For the first time that morning, Jon smiled—small, tentative, but genuine. "I'd like that."

Mance nodded, satisfied. "Then we'll start tomorrow, after your chores are done."

Robb groaned dramatically. "Chores first? Can't you let him skip just once?"

Mance raised an eyebrow, his smirk playful but firm. "A ranger never skips his duty, young lord. No matter how fine the music."

Robb rolled his eyes but didn't argue further. The two boys scampered off soon after, their laughter echoing through the courtyard as they plotted their next adventure. Mance watched them go, a quiet smile lingering on his face. He turned to leave, his cloak swirling around him like the shadow of a raven's wing.

That afternoon, the great hall of Winterfell bustled with activity as the Night's Watch delegation and the Stark household gathered for a midday meal. Long tables stretched beneath high vaulted ceilings, the stone walls lined with banners of the direwolf sigil. Catelyn sat at Ned's side, her face serene but her posture rigid, as though she were bracing against some unseen storm. She kept one hand on Sansa's shoulder, guiding the little girl through the proper etiquette of mealtime. Across the table, Robb and Jon sat side by side, their cheeks still pink from the cold.

Benjen Stark, seated near his brother, was deep in conversation with Lord Commander Qorgyle. Their voices were low, their expressions grave as they discussed the worsening state of the Wall.

"We're losing ground with every passing year," Qorgyle said, his tone grim. "The Free Folk grow bolder, pushing closer to the Wall. And with so few men, we can't patrol the way we once did."

Benjen added, "And the deserters… there's been an increase. Fewer men are taking the black willingly. Fewer still stay once they do. If it continues this way—"

"It won't," Ned interrupted, his voice steady and resolute. "The North remembers its duty. The Wall will not stand alone."

Benjen raised an eyebrow, leaning back slightly. "And what will you do, Ned? March north yourself? You can't hold the Wall with honor and old words."

Ned's jaw tightened, but before he could reply, Catelyn spoke, her voice measured but pointed. "Perhaps the other kingdoms should shoulder some of this burden," she said. "The Wall is not the North's responsibility alone."

Benjen turned to her, his expression softening slightly. "True enough, my lady. But the farther south you go, the less they remember the dangers beyond the Wall. The Wall isn't just for the North—it's for the whole realm. But try telling a lord in the Reach or Dorne that."

"Comfort breeds forgetfulness," Qorgyle muttered, echoing the words Benjen had spoken earlier.

Later that evening, Benjen found Jon alone in the godswood, sitting beneath the weirwood tree. Snow blanketed the ground, and the red leaves above him rustled softly in the wind. Ghost lay at Jon's side, his white fur blending seamlessly with the snow.

Benjen approached quietly, his boots crunching against the frozen ground. "Mind some company?"

Jon looked up, startled, but quickly shook his head. "No, Uncle. You can sit."

Benjen lowered himself onto the ground beside Jon, his black cloak pooling around him. For a moment, they sat in silence, the stillness of the godswood wrapping around them like a blanket.

"You like it out here, don't you?" Benjen asked finally.

Jon nodded. "It's quiet. No one looks at me like I don't belong."

Benjen sighed, running a hand through his dark hair. "You're a Stark, Jon. You belong more than you know."

"I'm not a Stark," Jon said quietly. "I'm a Snow."

Benjen turned to him, his gaze serious. "You're my brother's son. That makes you a Stark, no matter what name you bear."

Jon didn't reply, his eyes fixed on the snow in front of him. Benjen reached out, placing a hand on the boy's shoulder. "You'll find your place, Jon. The world has a way of testing us, but it also has a way of revealing where we're meant to be."

Jon looked up at him, his gray eyes filled with a longing he didn't yet have the words to express. "Do you think I'll ever… ever be something more than just a bastard?"

Benjen's grip on his shoulder tightened briefly before he spoke. "You already are. You just don't see it yet."

As the wind whispered through the godswood, Jon felt a flicker of warmth in his chest—a small, fragile ember of hope. He didn't know what the future held, but in that moment, with his uncle's hand on his shoulder and the silent strength of the weirwood watching over him, he felt as though he might one day find out.

As the Night wore on, Benjen found himself drawn to the crypts of Winterfell, seeking solace and a moment of reflection. In the dimly lit depths of the crypts, where the statues of their ancestors stood sentinel, he approached the statues of his father, his elder brother, and of Lyanna Stark, his elder sister.

With a sense of reverence, Benjen placed a blue winter rose at the base of Lyanna's statue. The blue winter rose had always been Lyanna's favorite, and it held a special place in their shared memories. Lyanna had been more than just a sister to him; she had been like a mother, a friend, and a playmate during their younger days. Her absence still left a void that could never be filled, and Benjen's heart ached with the memories of their time together.

While Benjen Stark stood in the crypts of Winterfell, paying his respects to his departed family members, especially Lyanna Stark, he sensed the approaching presence of his elder brother, Ned Stark. As he stood before the statue of Lyanna, Benjen couldn't help but wonder about the tension that he had noticed between Ned and Catelyn and how Jon was taking meals at the lower table reserved for stewards and captains of the guard.

Turning to face his brother, Benjen's expression was one of inquiry. He knew that something was amiss, and the crypts, with their hallowed silence, seemed an appropriate place for such a discussion. Benjen cleared his throat, breaking the solemn silence of the crypts. "Ned," he began, "I couldn't help but notice the tension between you and Catelyn. And Jon... there's something different about the way he's treated."

Ned continued to explain, his pride in Jon's resourcefulness evident. "It happened a few weeks ago. Some of the cattle had fallen ill due to an unknown disease. Most of them were able to recover, but a few were deteriorating rapidly. You know how important cattle are to the people in the North, Benjen. Losing even a few can be a heavy burden on the smallfolk."

"Jon proposed a solution," Ned continued. "He mentioned reading about certain herbs in the Winterfell library that could aid in treating the cattle. He separated the diseased ones, administered the herbs, and, miraculously, the cattle began to improve. They recovered, and Jon didn't stop there."

Benjen listened in astonishment. "What else did he do?"

"He started teaching the farmers how to selectively breed their cattle to create stronger stock," Ned replied. "He even suggested changes in their feeding regimen to raise healthier livestock. It's remarkable, Benjen. The yield from our cattle has risen significantly in the last few moons. The farmers have shown their gratitude and loyalty to Jon. It's undeniable that he has a special gift."

Benjen listened in astonishment, his eyes wide with disbelief. "Jon is just five namedays old, and he did all of this?" Benjen shook his head in disbelief. "I've always known Jon to be bright and resourceful, but this surpasses all expectations. It's as if he has an innate understanding of these matters."

Ned nodded, his eyes reflecting his admiration for his young son. "Indeed, it's a gift. But it's also the source of Catelyn's fears. She's concerned that Jon's abilities might make him a rival to Robb and that he will usurp Robb's position as heir of Winterfell."

Benjen furrowed his brow in thought. "I can understand her disapproval of the notion of a bastard, especially since she was raised in the New Gods' faith. However, I cannot fathom why she believes Jon will usurp Robb, especially considering he is just a five-nameday-old boy."

Ned looked up at the face of his beloved sister, Lyanna Stark, whose gaze momentarily appeared both affectionate and judgmental. He spoke, "Catelyn thinks that the unknown mother of Jon still holds my heart, and that one day I will declare Jon as the heir."

Benjen glanced at his brother and then at the face of Lyanna's statue. He said, "I never asked about Jon's mother, and I won't ask now. But I know that the most honorable Ned Stark will stand by his word, a promise made to her. Otherwise, she will haunt him in the afterlife."

Ned Stark's expression transitioned from anger to a bittersweet blend of amusement and melancholy. The mere suggestion that he might renege on his promise to Jon's mother, haunting him even in the afterlife, remained a burdensome weight on his conscience after five long years. The echo of her words, "Promise me, Ned, Promise me, Ned," reverberated in his soul.

"Benjen, I will honor my promise until my last breath. My concern lies in the potential rift it may create between Robb and Jon. Though they are but children now, I cannot envision how Robb will come to terms with it as they grow. I also cannot permit Northern lords to view Jon as an alternative heir. It bodes ill for our family and the North as a whole. I must find a resolution for this," Ned confided, his worry etched across his face.

Benjen responded with reassurance, "You will find a solution, brother."

"Now, let us discuss the Gift lands. They have been abondended by the Night's Watch due to their dwindling numbers,becsause they are ubanble defend these lands from wildlings attacks. How did the Night's Watch manage these lands in days of old? They are among the most fertile lands in the North, and their absence still reverberates throughout our lands," Ned inquired.

Benjen, caught off guard by the abrupt shift in topic, replied with a touch of playfulness, "Who's to say? In the past, the Night's Watch appointed lords to govern these lands. Perhaps you could petition your old friend, King Robert Baratheon, to return them to the North, enabling House Stark to overrule them once more. This way, you could appoint new lords to preside over these territories." With that, he exited the crypts, leaving Ned Stark with his last words resonating in the solemn chamber.

Author's Notes:

Please, it will be appreciated if you guys leave constructive feedback.