When Connie falls through the ice at the quarry, she disappears, and ends up somewhere else... The effect of this sudden turn of events will alter the future in a way that no one could have imagined, and show the Evans family that the world is far bigger than they ever thought.

This takes place in 1993, a few months before Henry's Cousin comes to visit. Henry's parents feel bad for not paying much attention to him so they decide to get him a Good Guy Doll. Of course he ends up getting the one that's possesed by Lakeshore Strangler, Charles Lee Ray. Chucky realizes that Henry's not like any ordinary child and they have a lot in common such as murder.

What if Mark Evans had become so desperate to see his mother again, that he decided to do something previously unimaginable? And what if Sam and Dean Winchester were sent back in time by Castiel to December of 1993? There, the brothers must prevent a grief-stricken Mark from committing an atrocity, and discover that theirs isn't the only family with dark secrets...