A/N: This is a request from DaX0315. Hank and Olivia have been together for over 2 years in this chapter, so Olivia and Tucker never happened, which is fine with me. I don't own any of the characters except my own.

Second Chances

Hank looked at the file on his desk regarding the latest case. The guy had raped and murdered his victims before but managed to get away with it. Hank wanted to make sure he didn't do it again. When Hank saw where he struck prior to starting up in Chicago, he knew just who to call. He got out his cell and dialed her number.

"Hey, there Sexy!"

"Hey, yourself. I need to pick your brain. We got this case. The victims were raped and murdered but it appears he got away with it in New York. Does the name Frank Conway mean anything to you?"

"Yeah, we've been trying to get him for like 5 years. I'll call the squad and see if we can get on the first flight out in the morning."

"Thank you."

"You're welcome and you know the rules."

"Yes, Dear."

"Thank you."

"You're welcome. Love you."

"I love you too."

Hank hung up the phone and decided to call it a day. Olivia made reservations for the 4 of them to fly to Chicago and then she texted the 3 of them and told them to meet her at LaGuardia at 6am instead of going to the Precinct. Olivia asked Lucy if she could stay with Noah, while she was gone and she said she'd be happy too. She called Chief Dodds and told him that they were going to Chicago for a case. He was ok with it.

The members of SVU all got up early and got ready to go. Amanda took Jesse over to Carisi's parents' house, so they could take care of her while she was gone. She and Carisi headed to the airport together. Lucy arrived at Olivia's and Fin had called Olivia and told her he'd pick her up. Once he arrived and Olivia said goodbye to Noah, they headed to the airport. Rollins and Carisi arrive at the same time Fin and Olivia did. They got checked in, went through security and went to the gate after they grabbed coffee and breakfast. Once they boarded their flight, Olivia texted Hank to tell him that they would be there in a few hours and asked if someone could pick them up. He said he would.

"Liv, this is an old case of ours or something?"

"Yeah. It was one we had 5 years ago but he got away with it because we never caught him. Frank Conway is the guy."

"Oh, yeah. I remember him."

"Yeah, I do too."

The flight took off and then a few hours later, they landed in Chicago. They went to Baggage Claim and as promised, Hank was there.

"Thanks for picking us up."

"No problem."

Hank took Olivia's suitcase and kissed her, while Carisi took both his and Amanda's.

They put the bags in the back of Hank's SUV and everyone but Olivia got in.

"You are staying with me, right?"

"Don't I always?"

"Yes but you're here on business."

"It's been way too long, since we've been together."

"Yeah, I know."

Hank shut the back of the SUV and went to open the passenger door for Olivia. She kissed him again before she got in. He shut the door and then he walked around to the other side. He then drove to the District. When they arrived, they all got out and went inside.

"Hey, Olivia."

"Hey, Trudy."

"Detectives Tutuola and Rollins, good to see you."

"You too, Sergeant Platt."

"It's Sergeant Tutuola now."

"Good for you. Who is this handsome fellow?"

"I'm Detective Dominick Carisi Jr., Ma'am."

"It's nice to meet you. I'm Sergeant Platt."

"I've heard about you."

"Oh, yeah? You're adorable."

"Thank you, Ma'am."

Olivia, Hank and Fin tried not to laugh. They all headed upstairs, where everyone else was. Laura Nagel and Assistant State's Attorney Valdez were also up there.

"Boss, Laura said she'd help and Anna is working on the case with us."

"Great. Laura Nagel and Anna Valdez, this is Lieutenant Olivia Benson, Sergeant Odafin Tutuola, Detective Amanda Rollins and Detective Sonny Carisi from Manhattan SVU. This is Special Investigator Laura Nagel and Assistant State's Attorney Anna Valdez."

"Nice to meet you."

"You too."

Hailey came over.

"Hey, Lieutenant."

"Hi Hailey. It's nice to see you again. This my squad, Sergeant Fin Tutuola, Detective Amanda Rollins and Detective Sonny Carisi. This is Detective Hailey Upton."

"Nice to meet you Detective Upton."

"You too. Please, call me Hailey."

All 3 of them winked at Carisi. Everyone set their stuff down and Kim winked at Carisi too. Jay hung up the phone.

"Hey, Sarge."

"Yeah, Halstead."

"We have a sexual assault victim at Med. Her name is Stacy Henderson."

"Is it related to the case?"

"We don't know. Once the DNA comes back, we'll know for sure."

"Rollins and Burgess, head to Med and see what you can find out. Everyone else check witness statements."

Hank and Olivia grabbed some files and went into his office and shut the door. Amanda and Kim went to Med to talk to the victim. They both stopped short as soon as they saw her. She looked very familiar to them. Amanda called Liv and had her and Hank meet them there. They talked to Stacy until they got there. She told them everything she remembered and the description of the perp matched what they knew about Conway. Hank and Olivia arrived at Med. As soon as Kim and Amanda saw them, they walked out of Stacy's room.

"What?"

"Liv, you need to see the vic."

"Why?"

"Just have a look."

Olivia peeked into Stacy's room.

"Yeah and?"

"Liv, she looks like you."

"What are you talking about, Rollins?"

The 4 of them went into the room together.

"Stacy, this is Lieutenant Benson and Sergeant Voight."

"Hi."

"Hello."

"Could you tell them what you told us?"

"Of course."

Stacy told Hank and Olivia what she told Kim and Amanda. The more Olivia heard Stacy speak, the more upset she was becoming.

"Excuse me."

Olivia ran out of the room and went to the waiting room. Hank went after her.

"This is unbelievable."

"Babe, you don't know anything yet."

"Anything is possible, Hank."

Amanda and Kim came out.

"What do you think this means?"

"I have no idea."

"Do you think she's related to you."

"I don't know. Can we run a check on her?"

"I texted Atwater. He's doing one on her right now. Are we done here?"

"I think so."

The 4 of them headed back to the District and went upstairs.

Olivia went straight to Hank's office and Hank followed her. Kevin knocked on Hank's door.

"Yeah."

"Hey, Boss. I got the results of the background check you wanted."

"Thanks, Atwater."

Kevin handed Hank what he had and then he shut the door after he left. Hank looked at it.

"It lists her parents."

"So, tell me."

"Her mother is Ellen Henderson and her father is Joseph Hollister. Both are deceased."

"Oh, shit! That's 2 half siblings now. I can't deal with this, Hank."

"Come here."

Hank put his arms around Olivia and held her as she broke down.

"Maybe you should tell her."

"Oh, yeah, that'll go over real big."

Then there was another knock at the door.

"Yeah."

Kim opened the door.

"Stacy just called. She wants to talk to Lieutenant Benson."

"Ok, thanks."

Hank and Olivia headed to Med once again. When they arrived, they went up to the floor where Stacy was. Hank went to the waiting room and Olivia went to see Stacy.

"Hi."

"Hey."

"I need to say something. I know Joseph Hollister is your father. He's mine too."

"Did your mother hate you because of what he did to her?"

"Yes, she did. I was physically and emotionally abused by her and she was an alcoholic."

"My mother was the same way but she also turned to heroin. She overdosed when I was 5. I spent most of my life in the system. I was in different foster homes but no one wanted me."

"I'm sorry to hear that."

"Thanks. I don't even know why I wanted to see you. I'm glad that bastard is dead. I don't know how I feel about this."

"I don't either. Were you doing ok before this happened?"

"Oh, yeah. I got myself through college and I got a job. It's just that I never had anyone to call family before. Before you ask, I'm fine financially, so I'm not looking for money. Maybe we could be friends and see where it goes from there."

"That might work. I'm in New York but I'm here quite often."

"That handsome guy that was in here earlier, is he single?"

"No. He's mine."

"That's ok. I'm seeing someone anyway."

"That's great."

Then Stacy's boyfriend came in and it turned out to be someone Olivia already knew.

"Olivia, what are you doing here?"

"I'm here working on a case. When did you move to Chicago?"

"A couple years ago. Right after you adopted Noah, actually."

"Seriously. No wonder I haven't seen you in like forever."

"You know Trevor?"

"Yeah, I do. He was one of the Defense Attorneys that was always getting on my nerves. He did help me when I was adopting my son, so he's not such a bad guy after all."

"You're not so bad either, Sergeant."

"Lieutenant, actually."

"Whenever I don't see you for a while, you've been promoted."

"Yeah, I know."

"You still dating that cop from Chicago?"

"Yeah. We've been dating for a couple years now."

"I met Stacy pretty much right away when I moved here. Babe, are you ok?"

"Yeah, I think I'll be fine."

"We found out that we're half-sisters."

"Really?"

"Yep."

Then Hank came in.

"We need to go."

"Ok."

"Olivia, will you come back and see me?"

"Sure. Hank, do you remember me mentioning Trevor Langan?"

"Yeah, sure."

"This is Trevor. Trevor, this is Hank Voight."

"Nice to meet you."

"You too."

Hank and Olivia left and then Trevor sat down with Stacy.

"So, how'd it go?"

"She's been on her own since she was 5 when her mother overdosed on heroin. She was in foster homes but no one wanted her."

"Wow!"

"I don't know what to think about all this."

"You'll get through it. I'll help you. You know I will."

Hank kissed Olivia, took her hand and then they walked to the SUV. Hank drove back to the District. When they got back, they went back upstairs. Everyone was gone.

"Well, at least we're alone."

"I'd rather be at your house."

"We can, you know."

"In the middle of a case?"

"Fin's in charge."

"I need to clear my head."

They started kissing and then they headed to Hank's . When they got there, they went upstairs to Hank's bedroom, got undressed, got on the bed and made love. Afterwards Hank had his arms around Olivia and she had her head on his chest.

"You feel better?"

"A little bit."

Hank reached over to the bedside table and pulled something out.

"Here. This is for you."

"What's this?"

"Open it and see."

Olivia open the box and could not believe what she saw.

"Is this what I think it is?"

"Well, let's see. We've been together for over 2 years and I love you and Noah more than anything in this world. Olivia, will you marry me?"

"Oh, yes, I will marry you!"

Hank put the ring on Olivia's finger and then they kissed. Just as they were about to make love again, Hank's cell rang. It was Olinsky telling him they had Conway in custody. Hank told him they would be there as soon as they could. They got out of bed, got dressed and headed back to the District. When they arrived, they went upstairs and joined everyone, including Anna outside the Interrogation Room. Jay and Antonio were interrogating him. Conway was being smug and wouldn't talk without his lawyer. Both Hank and Olivia were quickly losing patience with him. Hank wanted to go in there but he promised Olivia that he would behave. She meant more to him than anything else, so he really didn't want to piss her off. He just stood there with his arms folded in front of his chest. By the time the lawyer arrived, he was just as smug as Conway and Conway still wouldn't talk.

"Put him in the Cage then. I want this son of a bitch to rot in prison where he belongs."

"I was going to say something else but not with Valdez here."

"Just say it, Hank. We all know what you're thinking."

"Someone needs to put a bullet in Conway."

"This guy is a real ass."

Atwater got a call saying that the DNA found in Stacy matched Conway.

"Boss, the DNA found in Stacy Henderson matched Conway."

Olivia called Trevor and asked if Stacy had been released from the hospital. He said she had. She told him the guy was in custody but not talking.

They all came out of the Interrogation Room.

"You don't have a case against my Client."

"We most certainly do. We have a victim that he only raped and the DNA matched Mr. Conway."

"She probably couldn't say for sure that it was him. Like I said, you don't have a case."

"Stacy is on her way here now."

Antonio and Jay took Conway back into the Interrogation Room and they waited for Stacy and Trevor to get there. When they arrived, Trudy brought them up.

"Hey, Langan."

"Hey, Detective Tutuola."

"Sergeant, actually."

"Sorry."

"That's ok."

"That's him."

"You sure?"

"Positive."

"You still have no case against my Client."

"She just told us he's the one that raped her."

Olivia knocked on the window and then Antonio came out.

"She said he's the one."

"Ok. We'll take him to have him processed."

"Good."

Antonio and Jay brought Conway out and he looked right at Olivia and smirked. They took him downstairs and then out the back entrance.

"I don't like the way he looked at Olivia."

"I don't either."

Everyone called it a day and ended up at Molly's. Once Jay and Antonio were finished, they met everyone there. When everyone arrived, they went in and the group from 51 and Med were already there. Mouch grabbed a table for himself, Trudy, Hank and Olivia. Fin pulled up a stool and sat with them.

"Aw, Babe, our table. Thanks, Mouch."

"No problem."

Trudy kissed Mouch as soon as she saw him. Carisi had sat down at an empty table and all the women went over by him.

"Hey, Handsome."

"Huh?"

"You're a cutie."

"Thanks."

"I'm Sylvie and this is Stella. We're from Fire Station 51. That's Gabby over there."

Gabby waved and then Matt and Kelly tried not to laugh.

"I'm Sonny Carisi from Manhattan SVU."

"It's nice to meet you, Sonny."

Then the women from Med came over to meet Sonny.

"Hi. I'm Sharon Goodwin, the Hospital Administrator from Med."

"I'm Maggie Lockwood, the Head Nurse in the Emergency Department."

"I'm April Sexton, Maggie's second in command."

"I'm Dr. Natalie Manning from the Emergency Department."

"I'm Dr. Sarah Reese, the Psychiatry Resident."

"I'm Sonny Carisi from Manhattan SVU."

"It is so nice to meet you, Sonny."

Olivia and Fin kept looking over at Amanda, who was sitting by herself.

"She looks pissed."

"It's only a matter of time now."

"What are you up to?"

"What the hell is wrong with you, McHolland? I told you that Olivia wanted all of the women to flirt with Carisi to make Rollins jealous."

"I guess I forgot."

"You don't listen."

"I listen."

"Since when?"

Mouch and Trudy both gave each other a look.

Trevor and Stacy came in with Anna and Laura. Anna and Laura joined the rest of the women and Trevor and Stacy came over to where Hank and Olivia were.

"May we join you?"

"Sure."

Trevor got a couple stools and brought them over. Gabby came over and got everyone's order. Olivia had her hand on the table, so Hank grabbed it and held it. Amanda had gotten up and walked over to Sonny.

"I need to tell you something, Dominick Carisi."

"What?"

"I'm in love with you."

"You're what?"

"I love you. I've been in love with you since before I had Jesse."

"I love you too, Amanda Rollins. I have for a while. I just stayed away because I thought there was something goin' on between you and Amaro."

"Nothin' ever really happened between Nick and me. I slept with him once but it mean nothin' to me."

Sonny stood up, put his arms around Amanda and kissed her.

"It's about damn time, you two!"

"I agree with Fin."

Trudy saw Olivia's left hand.

"Hank Voight, did you propose to Olivia?"

"Maybe."

"Either you did or you didn't."

"I did."

"Hank! Olivia, let me see that."

Olivia held out her hand, so Trudy could see her ring better.

"Hank, that ring is beautiful!"

"Thanks."

"Congratulations!"

"Thank you."

"Liv, you're gettin' married?"

"Yeah, Fin, I am. Why the hell does that surprise you?"

"It doesn't. I'm real happy for you, Liv."

"HEY, BURGESS, YOU HAVE TO SEE OLIVIA'S ENGAGEMENT RING."

Hank gave Trudy a look.

"Was that necessary?"

Yes, actually, it was. For someone who said he was never getting married again, I'm glad you're doing this."

Everyone came over and looked at Olivia's ring.

"Congratulations, Liv!"

"What she said."

"Thanks."

"When is the big day? Where is it going to be? Where will you two be living?"

"We don't know anything yet. We just got engaged."

"I say we elope and not include any of them."

"Just Erin, Olive and the boys."

"Sounds like a plan to me."

"Hey! You can't get married without having me there. I want to know if you actually go through with it."

"Don't be such a smart ass, Fin!"

"So, am I going to be included with this wedding of yours?"

"Most definitely. We're sisters, aren't we?"

"We are."

"Wait, what?"

"I found out that Stacy is my half-sister. We do have a half-brother named Simon."

"What's he like?"

"He's been in and out of jail and only seems to contact me when he wants money. Our sperm donor was an actual father to him."

"I just wish I had had parents."

"Although I'm still having a hard time with this, I think I can get used to having a younger half-sister."

"And I could get used to having an older one."

"Babe, we really need to talk about where we're going to be settling down."

"You know one thing, it'll either be New York or Chicago?"

"Fin, you're being a smart ass again."

"Sorry."

"I wouldn't mind coming here but we would need to find someone to watch Noah and find a Preschool for him. I could decide I want to retire too."

"Cindy could help out."

"Thanks for the offer, Herrmann but I know how crazy my schedule gets in the middle of the night and I'm sure Hank's is just as crazy."

"I'd offer Randall but he is recovering from his heart attack. He still hangs out at the Fire Station all day and sometimes he comes to have lunch with me."

"I wouldn't want to put his health in jeopardy again."

"Maybe I could retire and move there. We could get a bigger place. I'd be ok with you keeping Lucy. That way I can be with you and Noah and be closer to Erin."

"Are you feeling ok, Hank?"

"Of course I am. Why wouldn't I be fine?"

"You're offering to retire for me."

"I know what I said. This long distance thing is crazy. We've been doing this for over 2 years. Erin was one of the few people other than you, Noah, Olive, Daniel, Olinsky and Platt that kept me sane after Justin died. Sure Justin is buried here next to his mother but I think I need to move on. It took me a while to realize that I wanted a second chance at happiness after I lost Camille."

"On the other hand, if I come here, then I can get to know Stacy better."

"It's not like we don't go to New York. Trevor's family is still out East."

"Trevor, can you still practice law in New York?"

"Yes. What do you need?"

"I'm guessing someone is going to want to make it official with Noah."

"I can handle that."

"Great. You do want to adopt him, don't you?"

"You know I do."

Herrmann got a new round of drinks for everyone and then they all toasted Hank and Olivia on their engagement. Everyone headed wherever they were going for the night. Hank returned to New York with Olivia, so they could start looking at houses. Once the Conway case went to trial, he was sent to prison for a very long time.

Reviews and suggestions are appreciated.