Warning: this is not for teen and younger. If you are under 18... shame on you. You will be scar!
A what-if story is something that is the same but has a different outcome. There was a battle going on between Mami battle the witch Charlotte. The different outcome is Mami was able to get herself free. When she did the witch Charlotte turned her gaze to the girls, Madoka and Sayaka. Charlotte is about to eat them. Mami tries her best to beat it. But it seems her guns have no effect. So she ends up doing this. Did the unthinkable about. She eats Charlotte from the small body first, then slurp up the main body. Charlotte was stunned to see she was the one being prey this time. Not predator. Homura just arrived and was stunned to see Mami eating the witch instead of killing her. See Mami's belly explain. Cause the dress to break. Expose her huge belly.
"Wow... this is unsuspecting." Kyubey walk-in site. "All my years observing. I never witnessed a day that a magical girl ate a witch. Normally, it is the other way around." Kyubey sounds excited. "Oh, what outcome of this will happen."
"...Don't get too excited parasite." Homura growls. She rushes to see Mami. "Hey, are you ok?" Homura asks her. See how Mami's belly is bigger than her own body.
"Y-yes I am..." Mami tries to get up. She uses her gun to help her stand up. Mami expects to feel the witch fight in her belly. But for some reason feels like it snuggles in her belly. Mami finds it strange but ignores it. Homura leaves them alone. Head off to the next witch. For Madoka's shake.
"...Hm... Nah it's not my concern... my top priority is to keep Madoka safe..." Homura disappears into the dark. The girls are outside of the witch's domain. Mami's belly shrinks but is still big. She starts to feel weird. Start to be more hungry but also craving cheese foods.
"You girls can go ahead. I can handle myself." Mami lies to them but can fool them.
"Ok..." The girls let her go. "I never expect you just eat that witch... How does it feel?" Sayaka asks.
"No... I guess I am the first who... *Urps* does it." Mami waddles to her home. When she did. Mami was still feeling hungry for cheese. She picks up the phone and starts to call for pizza. Without thinking she orders 10 pizzas, 5 cheese sticks, and 5 cheesy pasta. "Ugh... I can't believe I did that..." She starts to groan. Cling on her belly. Feeling the witch move around from the excitement of cheesy food. Excited to eat them while being in Mami's belly. Someone Mami can feel Charlotte wants to eat the cheese food in her. "Why you're happy!? You are just going to the foods that I swallow! Like a damn baby bird!" Mami waits for a while. Hours pass. Mami has been trying to satisfy the cheese urge. She eats mac and cheese, cheesy chikuwa, cheese tempura, and just plain cheese straight up. But it wasn't enough to stop the cheese urge. Like Charlotte telling her to eat more cheese for her liking. "Ugh... what you doing to me?" Mami groans. She hears the door's belly. She use her gun to get up again. "Ugh... Coming!" She realizes she is still in her magical girl. "Uhm excuse!" She changes back into her everyday clothes. But she notices something is wrong. Her belly is, showing her underwear. "Gah!" She went to her bedroom and grabbed a blanket to cover her lower part. "...Oh this is bad.." She looks at herself in the mirror. "I look like I am having a baby or two." The door knocks again. "Oh... I hope the person won't see me like this." She walks to the door and opens up. She notices the delivery man is distracted by his phone.
"Ok miss... here's your food whatever." The delivery man gave her the food. "That be 4418.20 yens." Mami handed him 4450 yen. "Thank you."
"K-Keep the change..." Mami tells him. He just says whatever then goes. Mami starts to groan again. Can feel Charlotte wants to eat the food already. "Calm down you damn witch! Ugh..." Mami starts to eat the food. Slowly please Charlotte and the hunger. Took a while but when she finished all. She is twice as big again. "Oof... so tired..." She ends up passing out on the couch. Kyubey was nearby standing there. Watch the whole thing happen.
"Hm... How peculiar... it seems the magical girl and the witch materialize a symbiotic pair... Like a mother and the unborn baby..." Kyubey laughs. "Heh, I wonder... it will develop into a new witch from this symbiotic pair... or something else." Kyubey keeps watching her. As Mami slept, Charlotte slowly became part of her. Become her fat until all left is the Grief Seed. The strange part the seed gives off a a warm glow. So bright that Kyubey can see it. "Oh, what is this now?" Morning come. Mami gets up.
"Hm... did I passout..." Mami gets up. "Oof... I feel a bit lighter now..." Mami doesn't know what is going on. When she walks past the mirror. She stops and sees she become chubby. "Huh? HUH?!" She was in disbelief. She tried to pinch herself to see if she was dreaming. But sadly it is all real. "What is this!?"
"Huh, this is new..." Kyubey keeps watching her. "It seems to eat the witch to increase her power... but at the cast. Your body expands from it." Kyubey starts to think. "I wonder... how far is the limit... This requires more testing with other girls." Kyubey went off. Search for which magical girls he can think of. See he can use them for the eating witches projects. So far within a week, he has tricked a fragile emotional girl, with green hair, green eyes, with big boobs, not big as Mami's. Away has a twin-tail look and pale skin. In her magical girl form, she has a shield as a weapon, the dress is a knight-like dress. An experimental girl wants to see the limits magical girls are. Have red drill hair, and red eyes, she is flat-chested but has thick thighs. In her magical girl form, she wears a black lab coat, black scrubs pants, and a black crop top, the weapon is a pair of claws with needle tips. Only hurt witches. Lastly a unique girl, a blue wavy hair, blue eyes, big butt, she is a thrill seeker who wants to see what she can do for fun. In her magical girl form, she wears a pink headband and goggles over them, a ripped white shirt, a pink bra, white shorts, and pink combat boots.
"...Uhg..." Mami was trying to lose weight. But so far no effort. She has been dieting, working out, and doing yoga. But somehow she can't lose a single pound. "Why I'm having trouble losing weight?" She was in her bathroom on a scale
"Oh because you can't," Kyubey tells her. She just appears in her tub. "It appears from eating that witch somehow caused your mana to grow... but as a side effect your body has to grow to contain it." Kyubey walks to her. "It's amazing... Bet tell... have you got the hunger to eat more witches?
"No! The Last thing I want is to eat more witches!" Mami lies again. Some reasons part of her wants to eat more witches. Don't help but each time she sees sense witch. Her mouth drools, with a strong urge to eat it. But she tries to resist the urge to eat it.
"Hm... it's a shame... I bet if you keep eating them. You will become a very strong and powerful magical girl." Kyubey tries to persuade her to eat more to shake off his influence.
"N-no stop this! G-get out!" Mami put him outside of her window.
"Oh well… she will come around eating more… I wonder… that eat she eats still alive in her. Or she completely absorbed by her." kyubey thinks as for the moment when he was trying to convince her to eat more witches. Sense present of Charlotte in her still. Somehow but it was tiny and weak. The next day Mami headed to a clothing store for plus-size girls. Sadly there are not many. She was lucky to find one and purchase the clothes she needed for her chubby body now.
"Thank you. Come again." The cashier smiles and bows to Mami. Mami nodded and headed it the nearest public bathroom to change. Feeling that the clothes she is currently wearing are ready to break from her belly fat. She can find one quickly and change. When she came out she was wearing a white dress, black kneesock, and a green vest.
"Ok. No one spots me yet." Mami discarded her clothes in a trash bag meant for burnable since those clothes were stretched and almost torn. "Ok, I need to head home... and see that no point in wearing the old clothes..." Mami sigh. The fact all the clothes she brought are so cute and make her look mature too.
"Hey, have you heard of Mami?" Mami froze in fear after hearing her name. She turned and saw it was Sayaka and Madoka. The girls are talking. "I tried to see she was at her apartment. But she wasn't there." Madoka sounds scared.
"No, I haven't... weird part is I have noticed a few odd things... like Kyubey talking to this green-haired timid girl about eating a witch..." Sakaya seems worried. "I didn't know that is a thing now... Maybe Homura was right about the Kyubey character... Madoka... best that we don't trust that freak. I'll be willing to be a magical girl... but if the job is all about eating the witches. Count me out! I think I'd rather do something else."
"I agree with you... eating them seem weird and wrong..." Madoka sigh. "So if we ever see Kyubey?"
"Ignore him! Decline any offering. Include the... wish come true offering.." Sayaka cringed. As she number of wishes to pick she wants them to come true. "We better off doing other stuff than be a magical girl now." Madoka nodded. Both girls walk off on different paths. Sayaka head to home. Madoka still on the search for Mami.
"Wow. Seeing you eat the witch causes a chain reaction." Homura was impressed. She starts to think about what of the way to find it more way for Madoka to start to see the Magical girl more terrible in her eyes.
"Homura leave me alone... I have a terrible day." Mami wasn't pleased to see Homura find this interesting. "Ugh, I possibly have to move now since they know where I live." Mami walks off. She notices an odd green-haired girl in a purple dress, along sense a witch. She was worried at first. Then go off somewhere. Mami fears that she might be the same girl that Sayuka talks about. She went to the store again and purchased bigger clothes. Worry about the possibility that the girl might try to eat the witch. Or worse herself when she gives in to her hunger for eating them. Within a while. Mami was able to keep herself hidden while following the timid girl. Mami found a witch's den. The girl changes into a knight-like armor with a shield as a weapon.
"O-okay... Kyubey says I can get stronger if I devoure the witch..." The timid girl tries to calm herself. "Ok, I can do this." Mami was hidden in the shadows. She changes into her magical girl outfit. She was surprised that her outfit got big with her.
"At least I don't have to worry about finding a way to size it.." Mami sighed while poking her belly. She kept her eyes watching the timid girl. "So far everything looks good." Mami kept watching until the girl knocked out a familiar.
"I-Iwonder..." Without thinking Mami watched the timid girl eat the familiar. When she swallows it whole. When the familiar drops in her stomach. It instantly disappeared. "Oh... I fear I have to eat the witch... I was hoping I could just the familiars to be stronger..." She was upset that she needed to eat the boss. Mami was a stunt to her just eat the servant. She worries that she might over her head. The timid girl starts to go invisible. Mami was astonished. Never expect her to have the power to go invisible.
"Oh come on!" Mami was annoyed with this action. She starts to get to the witch first. If she kills it in time. Then that poor timid girl won't eat it. But she also worries about herself. The closer she gets to the witch. Her eerie craving to eat it has become. Like something in her keeps telling her to eat the witch, over and over. "S-Shut up... I won't eat the witch! I WON'T EAT THE WITCH!" Mami was able to get the voice to stop, and give her time to find the witch. But see she was too late. The timid was battling a witch. Marionette-like being, with strings attached to it, marionette crossbar. Have no face, wearing a princess outfit. With a ton of makeup on the face.
"Alright weaken the witch. Then eat it... if it's the only way for me to be strong... so be it!" Sena went invisible again. Mami tries her best to keep up but has trouble predicting the move she is going to make. At the moment. She can see the strings being cut off. Fall to the ground. The girl was about to eat the witch start from the feat.
"No stop!" Mami stops her in time. "Look this is not the way to be stronger!"
"L-Let me go! I have to do this!" The timid girl shouted. "I have to be stronger! I need to get strong very fast!"
"This isn't the way!" Mami keeps holding her. But something inside her started to cry out. Keep says to eat the witch over and over to the point the urge starts to consume her thoughts. Mami let her go. Her own body moves on its own. She tries to stop herself. With everything she gots. But the timid girl pushes her out of the way.
"NO THIS IS MINE." The girl tries her best to gulp it down as fast as she can. After she gulp it all down. Cause her belly to break her dress from getting huge. "Ugh... I hope this is work it..." For some reason after the girl devours it all. The urge Mami is having is gone.
"Oh, you shouldn't do that..." Mami starts to feel sick suddenly. She tries to explain but try to fight back the sickness.
"Uhm... i-is something wrong?" She asks Mami.
"Ugh, I was trying to stop you from making..." Mami tries to explain as she keeps being strong. "The same mistake I-I made..." Mami looks at her.
"W-What mistake." The girl looks worried. Mami explains what happens to her from the time she eats Chalotte. She explained she was skinny at first with a big belly from swallowing the witch. 2nd was the craving. Lastly, after which absorbed into her body. She gains weight. "...H-huh?!" The girl starts to panic. Mami tells her more. Now she will have the strong urge to eat another witch when you sense one. "Oh god! I-I need to get it out of me!"
"I'm afraid it's too late." Kyubey looks at her. Appear behind the girls. "It seem the witch you have to eat seem nest in your... somehow feel safe in your... This is fascinating like the witch is back in a mother's womb... ignore the fact where the witch is right now." Kyubey sounds exciting. "And you Mami... I notice your urge to eat another witch grows each time you get near to one."
"K-Kyubey I thought you were friend... What are you doing?" Mami looks at her.
"A friend... I just saw you something else... Something... not so important... Goodbye." Kyubey went off. Mami was shocked to hear this. But soon look at the girl.
"Hey, what's your name?" Mami asks her.
"I-I am Futaba Sana... You are?" Sana look at her.
"My name is Tomoe Mami..." Mami hold your hand. "I think it is best that we stick together... abandon your previous life... You have to start a new one now..." Sana nodded.
"I-It might be for the best... my family doesn't care about me, and I don't have any friends." Sana nodded.
"...Well come on... we better go." Mami takes her out. "Can't live in my place... I am trying to avoid people right now. I can't come back to it." Sana nodded. They end up going to a cheap motel. After a while, Sana starts to act weird. She has been stacking things neatly. Store things in neat order. And been stacking things nicely. "Hey, are you?"
"I-I don't know! I have been having urges to do things perfectly! Paper works, put stuff in order, use mostly, and fold clothes neatly!" Sana explain.
"I-I see..." Mami thinks maybe eating a witch causes different side effects. When she devours Chalotte. She has been getting urges to eat cheese. "I'm going out... I need to check something..." She went to a drugstore. Buy 10 pregnancy tests. She goes to the nearest public bathroom to use the test. A short time after all the tests were over, she saw that all the tests had positive on them. She was shocked at first... Then it somehow eats the witch causing her to be pregnant. Maybe that was it was a nest in her. It was getting for the cycle of rebirth. She worries now after it is born. It is human or a witch again. She would be ok or not. Suddenly she hears a voice from within her.
"Mama... don't scare... I-I want to be born as a human... I want to be born blessed of your love..." She could feel it was telling the truth. Mami somehow smiles and says this. While stroking her belly motherly.
"Don't worry... I promise once you are born. I'll protect you... like a real mother." Mami smile.
Preview of the next:
"Huh you mean been using us for twisted experiments?"
"...Don't worry baby... if you are born as a human again. Mommy make sure you never become a magical girl again."
"Oh, I wonder. What happens if an expecting mother eats another witch. Will the baby grow or you get more pregnant?"