Scene changes to outside of Scylla's lair

Tell me you did not know that would happen
Say you didn't know how that would end

"He is mad-mad." said Frank.

"But he has every right to be. His captain attempted to sacrifice him to Scylla." said Piper.
Look me in the eyes and tell me, Captain
That you did not just sacrifice six men?

"To be fair, he was going to sacrifice his men on Circe's island and leave them as dinner." said Jason.

"And Odysseus only did six lives." said Clarisse.

"Don't side with that!" shouted Annabeth. "What he did was wrong! He just went up and ruined six lives!"

"There was no other option."

"He always finds a way, he could have found a loophole like he did before."

"And where did that end him? He would have just lost more lives and more years if he did not do what he did."

"Yeah, six lives might have been gone but that's the least amount of lives in a row that died." said Jason. "There could have been more deaths."
Use your wits to try and say I'm crazy and mad
That this is all some trick the gods have sent
Tell me you did not miss home so painfully bad
That you gave up the lives of six of our friends?

"He wanted to do the same at Circe's island." said Jason. "Like I said before."

"Yeah." said Leo.

"But he is a captain, he needs to be the role model." said Reyna.

"Exactly! And the men didn't die anyway but those six were." said Thalia.

"But-" started Frank.

"Look, we could argue about whether Odysseus or Eurylochus is right for a long time and never get a full answer. Let's just finish the song and we can discuss this perhaps when the saga ends." said Percy.

"Okay." said everyone.

When we fought the cyclops, you were quick to hatch a plan

Everyone recalled back to the Cyclops Saga and reimagined it.
And when we fought with Circe, it was you who left behind no man

They all also went back to the Circe Saga and also did the same.

"Now that he has said it, he did say it." said Leo.

"Yeah." said Nico. "I'm on Eurylochus's side now. A man who doesn't keep his word is no good man at all."
But when we fought this monster, we didn't take a stand
We just ran

"That is the truth," said Reyna. "It was all Odysseus's fault."

"But Odysseus was facing a lot though," said Will. "He couldn't have done everything by himself."

"Who said he had to? The crew is a team, they could have worked it out together."

"But you've forgotten that they can't be trusted! They opened Aeolus's bag."

"That was only Eurylochus and that to, he regretted it!"

"But the bag was going to be opened either way, if not by Eurylochus, someone else and if not them, then another. The loop will continue going but the fate of the bag is sealed, it will be opened."
Say something

I can't!

Then you have forced my hand

Eurylochus holds his sword

Eurylochus

Lower your weapon

No can do
You miss your wife so bad, you trade the lives of your own crew

Don't make me fight you, brother, you know you'd have done the same

If you want all the power, you must carry all the blame

Eurylochus, Eurylochus, Eurylochus
Odysseus, Odysseus, Odysseus

"It seems that the crew is having the same issue we are having." said Percy.

"They are all picking sides on who is right." said Annabeth.

"And just like us, most people are siding with Eurylochus."
There is no price he won't pay

"From sacrificing six men to fighting his friend, what wouldn't he do to get back home?" asked Hazel.

I am not letting you get in the way

Perimedes stabs Odysseus
My brothers, why?

How are we supposed to trust you now?
Now your time has come, your luck's run out
Now, the time has come to shut you down
You relied on wit and then we died on it

"See?" asked Clarisse. "Every time Odysseus relies on his wits, more people die than just him facing his problems."

"I guess you do have a point Clarisse, well done." said Annabeth.

"Ohh... thanks..." said Clarisse, surprised. "But I guess sometimes you do need to think about the problem before full getting into battle."

"Thank you, Clarisse."
Whoa-oh-oh

Odysseus goes unconscious

They tie Odysseus to a pole

Scene changes to Helios's island

Odysseus wakes up

Agh, my head
Where are we?

Some island, the first one we found
It's bursting with cows just roaming around
Begging us to eat, so much meat

"They haven't had food in how long?" asked Annabeth.

"Since Circe's island I believe." replied Jason.

"Oh that's a long time." said Will.

"They could have eaten the sirens and have ate sushi." said Leo.

"Sirens are half human so that would be cannibalism." said Nico. "Also that's just disgusting."
And hunger is so heavy
This statue
The God of the Sun

"Will!" said Leo. "It's your Dad's place!"

"No, different Sun God." said Annabeth.

"This belongs to Helios, not Apollo." said Frank.

"Okay, Helios is the one with the cattle." said Leo.

"No, Apollo has cattle as well." said Annabeth.

"Okay, Helios is the one with the island."

"No, Apollo has an island as well."

"Just remember that Helios is a Titan, not a God." added Jason.

"Yeah, I have no idea why they said that." said Frank.

Don't know where it's from
But here's where we found all these cows to hunt
Right in front
And hunger is so heavy (hunger is so heavy)

Please don't tell me you're about to do what I think you'll do

Ody, we're never gonna get to make it home

"'Ody'?" laughed Piper.

"We can give friends nicknames as well." said Leo.

"I know, but Ody? Really?"
You know it's true

You don't know that's true
This is the home of the Sun God

"This is the home of the Sun Titan." sung Frank.

They all laughed.

"Leave the music to me." laughed Will.

"But 'Sun God' sounds better than 'Sun Titan'." said Annabeth.

"But 'The Titan of the Sun' sounds better than 'The God of the Sun'." said Percy.

I'm starving my friend

But if you kill his cattle, who knows what he'll send?
This is the home of the Sun God

"Go on Frank." said Leo.

"No." replied Frank.

I'm tired, my friend

But we're so close to home, this can't be where it ends

"How does he even know whether he is close or not?" asked Nico.

"Maybe it's just a method in order to persuade Eurylochus to not kill the cattle." said Reyna.

"Oh, cows. I still hate them." said Annabeth.

How much longer must I suffer now?
Please don't do this
How much longer must I push through doubt?
I need to get home

"He NEEDS to get home." said Hazel.

"He does though." said Will.

"It has been a long journey, I would miss everyone a lot if it had been that long." said Percy.
How much longer must I go about
Eurylochus
My life like this, when people die like this?
Whoa

How much longer must we suffer now?
Reconsider
How much longer must we push through doubt?
We can get home
How much longer must we go about
Eurylochus
Our lives like this when people die like this?

"This is a lot like 'Luck Runs Out'." said Jason.

"It does." said Thalia.

"It probably just means that their roles have swapped now and that things have changed." said Annabeth.
I'm just a man (whoa)

Eurylochus, no!

Eurylochus kills the cattle

You've doomed us
You've doomed us all, Eurylochus!

Odysseus breaks free

Captain?

We need to get away from this island now!

"Odysseus is just ignoring him." said Piper.

"Eurylochus had made him lose his way home twice now." said Jason.

Grab an oar with all the strength your arms allow

The crew stars rowing
These cows were immortal, they were the Sun God's friends
And now that we've pissed them off, who do you think he'll send?

Wind blows

Full speed ahead
Full speed ahead
Faster!
Full speed ahead
Faster!
Full speed ahead

We're too late

"Oh no... what did he send?" said Leo.

"We're about to find out." said Frank.

Author's Note:

anaklusosdude16 - True!

Zivonia - It's here now!