Elliot and Olivia had been dating for the past 3 months and although Elliot could say he knew A LOT about his partner, he didn't know everything. It started one night when they were lying on her couch watching an episode of Real Housewives, a guilty pleasure NOBODY would ever know and he realized he found out another fun fact about Olivia. She also liked pet names, but she preferred them in the privacy of her home or on a date night. He was ok with that and followed those rules well. Something he didn't know about her though was her friends. He knows Fin, Amanda, and people that they've worked with but he never knew her friends from before this life. Who did she go to school with? Who did she share secrets with?
"Babe, can you grab my phone? Noah was going to text me when they were done at Mastro's"
"I still can't believe a 12 year old is dining at Mastro's"
"That what these kids do nowadays"
"What happened to Shake Shack and McDonalds?"
"No clue, but their dance teacher is paying so at least it's not on my dime" Elliot laughed as he searched her kitchen for her phone. He saw it light up and went to look assuming it was Noah but it said 'Charlie'Elliot doesn't remember any Charlie so he was curious.
He read the message and it seemed innocent but he was feeling a bit insecure.
Charlie 8:17pm
'I think I finally got it under control. No need to come by.'
Elliot just let it be and assumed maybe it was a vic so he handed his phone to Olivia and cuddled up next to her. He watched her show and he would be embarrassed to admit he also got a little bit into it. His attention was pulled when he heard her laugh at her phone and continue texting. He didn't want to be nosy but he was very curious.
Olivia 8:19pm
'Hahahha I wasn't going to come anyways. El is over. I'm not coming over to help you in the shower.'
Charlie 8:19pm
'Rude. It's your fault I was in that situation'
Olivia 8:20pm
'You'll survive. It's not like you were naked this time. Lol'
Charlie 8:22pm
'AGAIN YOU'RE FAULT'
Olivia 8:22pm
'How was that my fault!?'
Charlie 8:22pm
'You left and took the key'
Olivia 8:23pm
'Yeah, because you lost yours...AGAIN :p'
Charlie 8:23pm
'You're annoying'
Olivia 8:23pm
'And you're forgetful'
Charlie 8:23pm
'At least I never forgot whose dick I was sucking'
At that point Elliot had read everything and now he was jealous. Whoever this Charlie guy was was asking Olivia to come over and talking about her sucking his.. He couldn't even finish the thought.
"Liv, who is Charlie?" Elliot was fuming but he didn't yell, "I am trying real hard to keep my cool but are you-"
"Before you even finish that sentence and regret something, let me show you" She said with an eye roll as she scrolled her photos for a picture.
It was a picture of Olivia about 5 years ago at the beach with Noah and she is posed with a blonde woman who he had never seen before. Both were smiling and laughing and Noah even clutched the other woman's hand. Elliot looked at her confused.
"This is Charlotte, also known as Charlie.
"What?"
"Charlie is one of my best friends from grade school"
"But you, well I- I guess I didn't realize you had other friends"
"Aside from the people we work with? That's sad."
"I didn't mean it like that you've just never mentioned them."
"I guess I just never mixed the friend groups. Charlie is in marketing and doesn't see this shit so I try not to bring it to her. Ashley lives in the Hamptons and is a stay at home mom and was always the mom of our group. Vanessa lives in Tennessee so we only get to see her when we get together in the summer, and Brooke is a care-aid so she sometimes has crazy hours. We've grown up together and gone through it all." She said with a smile
"Why have you not told me about them?"
"Honestly I don't know, they know all about you but I-"
"Wait... THEY KNOW ABOUT ME"
"Well yeah, of course" Elliot started to smile bigger than he has in a long time
"YOU TOLD YOUR MOST IMPORTANT FRIENDS ABOUT ME!"
"It's not that big of a deal, honey"
"Oh, baby. It is a HUGE deal" He stood up and reached out for her "It means you looooove me, you want to kisssss me you want to-"
"Ok ok, I do Miss Congeniality" She said with a giggle before snuggling into his arms.
"So what have you told them?"
"Stuff, things"
"Oh come on, I need more than that"
"It's girl talk"
"It's torture when I can't know!" The two laughed and continued to watch TV before they went to pick up Noah.
The next morning.
Olivia had just dropped Noah off and now she and Elliot were on their way to grab coffee when her phone rang through her car speakers.
The name on the screen flashed "Brookie"
"Oh good morning, why are you awake?" She asked her friend
"Because someone had a melt down that mommy couldn't take her to school so I switched my night shift for a day shift and now she is driving to school with her dad" Brooke said making Olivia laugh
"Be nice to my niece"
"Come get your niece because mommy needs a vacay which is why I'm calling"
"Oooh I'm listening" Olivia told her friend almost forgetting that Elliot was there but she wasn't worried something bad would be said
"Where are we going this year?"
"I think I'm good without that Hamptons this year" Olivia told her
"Same, it's getting busier and busier. And I am not going skiing again"
"Why not! We had a gr- Oh hold on, Charlie is calling"
"Add her to the call"
"I am hold on"
"Hey Charlie, Brookes on the line"
"Thank God, I need that bra back, my tits look awful right now."
"I don't have it, I lent it to Bunny"
Elliot mouthed to her "Who's Bunny?"
But before she could answer him she answered her friends
"Yeah I have it, I'll bring it with me tomorrow before lunch"
"Why do you even have it?"
"Brooke lent it to me"
"Yeah but your tits are fine, you literally have the best tits out of the group"
"I do not, Vanessa does!" Olivia defended
"Vanessa got them done so that doesn't count. Yours aren't sagging, they're still film and your nipples, Brooke have you seen her nipples"
"Yeah, it's rude"
"Shut up, anyways we are discussing the trip where are we going?" Olivia asked trying to change the subject
"Not skiing" Charlie said which made Brooke laugh
"I said that too"
"You guys are the worst, our ski trip was fun"
"For you, ski bunny"
Elliot had come to realize why she was called Bunny and smiled as she spoke to her friends.
"Why don't we go to the mountains?"
"And do what?"
"Hike, explore, camp"
"Absolutely not" Olivia said
"Why?"
"I am not camping"
"Okay what about a cabin?"
"Nothing too rustic"
"Yes princess Olivia" Her friends teased and Elliot smiled knowing if him or anyone else called her that they would be skinned alive. This was different. This was Liv and her best friends a side he's never seen.
"I will look at some spots tonight and send them in the group chat but you guys are telling Ashley"
"Ugh fine" The other woman groaned
"Ok, El and I are grabbing coffee I'll text you in a bit"
"Oh Elliots there, did he give you multiple orga-"
"BROOKE!" Olivia shouted making Elliot grin
"Fine, enjoy your coffee date, bye Elliot! Love you long time"
"Love you long time" Olivia and Charlie said before hanging up
"Hmm" Elliot said
"What?"
"So that's what women talk about when they think men aren't around"
"See not that interesting"
"Hey boob sizes were very interesting"
"Perv" She laughed as they pulled into a little cafe near the precinct. Elliot had a permanent goofy grin on his face and Olivia was curious
"What?"
"I always thought I knew you but just watching you have your girl talk and be someone other than captain was really...cute"
"Cute?"
"Yeah, that's honestly the only way I can describe it."
"Well, thanks I think" She giggled "But if you tell anyone what you heard, I will castrate you"
"There's my girl" Elliot laughed "Sooo tell me"
"About?"
"This group chat you ladies have"
"Oh absolutely not. That's top secret"
"Just a peak"
"Trust me, El. It's boring girl talk"
"You talk about boobs, that's not boring"
"If I give you a glance will that be enough"
"It's gotta be something good"
Olivia rolled her eyes but she wasn't mad. She scrolled through her group chat and found something juicy to show Elliot
Eastside Eagles
Olivia 7:52am
You guys...
Charlie 7:52am
SPILL
V 7:52am
TELL US RIGHT NOW, LIV
Ash 7:52am
Details
Brookie 7:52am
YOU DID IT!?
Olivia 7:52am
I'm still vibrating. Like holy shit
Brookie 7:53am
DETAILS! How many rounds? HOW BIG?
Olivia 7:53am
I'm not even exaggerating, a solid 8". 3 rounds. Bedroom. Shower. Bathroom Counter to the bed.
Ash 7:54am
Does he have a brother?
V 7:54am
Ashley, you're married
Ash 7:54am
Not blind. He fucked her 3 times in 1 night so now I'm curious
Charlie 7:55am
Curious or horny?
Ash 7:55am
;) Ok now Liv more details. Who made the first move? Did you come?
Olivia 7:56am
I don't even know who made the first move. Multiple orgasms. I'm talking 1 after the other. I didn't even think that was possible at my age.
Olivia 7:56am
Anyways, Elliots waking up. Talk soon ;) Love you long time
Charlie 7:56am
HE'S STILL THERE
V 7:57am
YOU LET HIM STAY
Brookie 7:57am
She's about to get fucked again
Ash 7:57am
Sounds like he's better in person than in those fantasys she used to have
Olivia pulled her phone away so he couldn't continue reading.
"You fantasized about me!"
"Maybe" She said playing coy"
"Tell me!"
"Nope, you got enough today"
"So you told them how good I was?" He said with his ego shining
"I told you, we tell each other everything"
"I have one more very important question" Elliot asked lowering his voice
"Whats with the group chat name?" He asked making Olivia laugh
"Our cheer squad name in school, it was easy to remember" She laughed
"YOU WERE A CHEERLEADER!"
"I was an athlete"
"You are my walking fantasy"
"I'll look for my old uniform" She winked as they walked out of the coffee shop