I've been headcanoning this for far too long.
Classic Sonamy - musical Newsies.
Song Prompt
"Well, hello again." Sonic walked by the balcony, on the run from Eggman's seeking robots below.
He was traveling through Eggman's run-down machinery land, a place he operated to lure animals to him and then robotize them, making them apart of the attractions…
While moving through the high-seats of the show-girls, he noticed a familiar Pink hedgehog he once saved a while back.
"Please go away!"
He could tell as she turned to him that her eyes were already hypnotized. Just like Tails, who he also needed to save before the attractions kept them their permanently. If you stayed too long under the hypnotizing music and show, then the robots find you and lead you off to be robotized.
Seeing as she wasn't in her right mind, he relaxed more, and began to smoothly let a smirk cross his muzzle.
"I'm working." She was pulling on some strings to let backdrops fall down by rope-works. Looks like the hypnotism got her as a servant to the show… which meant Eggman already knew she was here…
Probably hoping to use her later, but not expecting Sonic to find her so quickly.
Funny how they keep running into each other like this…
He leaned like a cool-kid up on a pillar with one of his hands, "Oh, a smart girl, huh?" he looked away a moment, "Beautiful. Smart." He nodded his head and then turned back to her again, his eyelids lowering, knowing he could say anything and she'd be unaware of everything.
"Independent." He mocked her a little on that, watching her move away and get to the next set of ropes to tightened them. He checked her from foot to head, then smiled spun a little over to her, deciding to have some fun with this.
He then leaned over the railing and placed his arms on it, lowering his head down to smile up at her as she robotically worked without blinking her eyes. Her eyes, by the way, were very much stoic. But he'd break her out of it later…
"I've got no use… for moonlight~"
He tilted his head in fascination of her.
"Or sappy poetry." He 'heh'd and rolled his eyes, leaning back up and pulling on the railing a bit, not looking at her anymore.
"Love at first sight… for suckers! At least…" he slowly rotated his head back to her, elongating his neck and seeming to fall right back into adoring her. "It used to be~"
He then shook his hand out, moving behind and passed her. "Look, girls are nice." He then stopped and flopped his hand out, "Once," and then folded them. "Or twice." He looked up as if shrugging.
"Till I find someone new…~" he gently moved his eyes back to her, lifting his head slightly up and to the side as his eyebrow raised to her again.
He tapped his foot, "But I never planned on someone…" He shook his head down and unfolded his arms, placing them on his hips. "Like you~"
He smiled back to her.
The robots started to swarm below, and he looked down between the cracks to see them.
The robot showgirls suddenly were revealed by Amy unhooking and untying some ropes and stings, rushing over to grab a light and pull to position it on them.
They sat down and kicked up their legs as Sonic took sacks of flour, used for weighting the ropes and backdrops, to fall on their heads and cause explosions.
"Don't come a-knocking on my door!"
"I've got no use… for moonlight~" he kept up his sneaky gorilla warfare as the robots below fought to find the culprit who was exploding them.
"Or sappy poetry… Love at first sight… For suckers… at least it used~ to be~" He jumped up and laid on the railing when his work was done. A hand on his chin, one leg bent up and the other balancing on the rail, straight out. He remembered the first time he saw her… what a shock, what a surprise. For such a weird girl to keep his curiosity.
He then jumped down and stepped back, happy with his work below, and pulled one Classic Amy's quills towards him in a gentle catch and swoop, letting his muzzle rest on its soft surface and smell her sweet scent.
"What are you doing?"
He immediately sped back, "Quiet down! There's a show going on!" he gestured to the robotic showgirl's tune, leaning over the railing again and flopping his arms out to it.
"You are the most impossible boy-!" she turned to him, and he 'shh'd her charmingly by placing a cheeky finger on her mouth, smirking uncontrollably.
Now that he didn't have to fib or play-it-cool with her, he was enjoying the banter.
"Ever..!" she took her stool, moving it away from him and sitting down to watch the show, still hypnotized.
"Don't come a-knocking on my door!" The robots were all destroyed, as Sonic readied a few ropes to hoist himself down now.
"No, I never planned on someone… like you~!" he swung down and took out the showgirl robots, causing Amy's hypnotism to cease.
She shook her eyes free of her long stare and rubbed her eyes, growing weary from nausea, as she tumbled over the railing.
He caught her, remembering the first time he held her, and smiled doting down to her.
He rolled his eyes, shaking his head as she gasped at seeing him, bundled her fist up by her face, and blushed; clearly swooning that he was there.
He then winked to the camera and dashed off to save the rest of his friends!