Author's Note:
This is my take on what would have happened if James Potter hadn't been solely obsessed with Lily throughout his time at Hogwarts. Instead, he uses his skills, power, and position in the Wizarding World to create something greater than just personal ambition. This story explores themes of growth, betrayal, and redemption, set against the backdrop of a world on the brink of war.
Disclaimer: J.K. Rowling owns the Wizarding World, I'm just borrowing her characters for a fun ride.
Lily Evans, Sixth Year, Gryffindor
Platform 9 was a whirlwind of chatter, owls hooting indignantly in their cages, and the screech of trolleys against brick. Steam billowed from the scarlet engine of the Hogwarts Express, curling into the air like a creature returning to life after a long sleep.
Lily Evans adjusted the strap of her school bag and scanned the crowd. She spotted Alice Fortescue near the edge of the platform, waving animatedly beside Marlene McKinnon, who stood in her usual confident pose, twirling a lollipop in her mouth like it was a cigarette in an old Muggle noir film.
"Finally!" Alice called, jogging over and pulling Lily into a tight hug. "You're late."
"I'm exactly on time," Lily replied with a smirk. "You're just early because Frank's obsessed with punctuality."
"Punctuality is hot," Alice said with a wink.
Marlene raised an eyebrow. "He also spent ten minutes wiping his shoes before stepping onto the platform. At this point, I think Frank's more committed to hygiene than he is to you."
Alice shrugged, unbothered. "That's what keeps the mystery alive."
They all burst into laughter and boarded the train together, ducking into an empty compartment. Once settled in, Marlene kicked off her shoes and sprawled across the seat like she owned the place.
"So," she began, eyes glinting. "Who do we think got caught snogging behind the Herbology greenhouses last term and still denies it?"
Alice rolled her eyes. "If you say 'me and Frank' one more time, I swear—"
"Oh, please," Marlene interrupted. "You two are practically married. I'm talking about Isabella Travers and Matthew Pucey. I saw tongue. Witnessed. With my own eyes."
Lily let out a dramatic gasp. "Wasn't Isabella dating that sixth-year Ravenclaw?"
"Not anymore, clearly," Marlene said smugly. "And let's not pretend Ravenclaws are all about ethics and essays. I've seen them play Seven Minutes in Heaven like it's a N.E.W.T. prep course."
Alice smirked. "Speaking of inappropriate pairings... how's Sirius, Marlene?"
Lily grinned as Marlene narrowed her eyes. "What about him?"
"Oh nothing," Lily said innocently. "Just wondering if you two are still stuck at second base, or if summer break finally moved things along?"
Marlene scoffed, cheeks slightly flushed. "Wouldn't you like to know."
Alice leaned in, whispering dramatically, "Third base?"
"I'm not giving you the satisfaction," Marlene said coolly, flipping her hair. "But if he's lucky this year..."
Lily raised her eyebrows. "So is he the lucky one now?"
Just then, the door slid open and Remus Lupin stepped inside, looking mildly exasperated but amused.
"Every year I hope to find some quiet in the prefects' compartment," he said, setting down his bag, "and every year I remember that being a Gryffindor means being chronically allergic to silence."
"Remus!" Alice said, grinning. "Come join us. We're discussing Sirius's love life."
Remus sighed but sat beside her anyway. "So the same thing you were talking about last year, then?"
Marlene shot him a playful glare. "Don't act like you don't care."
The door slid open again, and Sirius Black, Peter Pettigrew, and a pair of Chocolate Frogs tumbled in. Sirius looked perfectly pleased with himself.
"I hear we're discussing my love life?" he said, brushing nonexistent lint from his robes. "I'm all ears."
There was a beat of laughter and eye rolls before the conversation flowed effortlessly into a new round of teasing. Alice and Remus started a game of wizard chess. Peter nearly spilled pumpkin juice all over himself trying to make a joke about Peeves.
They ordered snacks from the trolley. Sirius leaned in to propose throwing a welcome-back party in the Gryffindor common room.
"With actual Firewhisky this time," he said, eyes gleaming. "Not that watered-down pumpkin fizz Remus brought last year."
"I saved your liver," Remus muttered.
"And yet it thrives in spite of you," Sirius replied grandly.
Lily chuckled, leaning back as the carriage rumbled gently beneath them. It felt… easy. Familiar.
"So, what's the new Quidditch lineup looking like?" Peter asked between bites of treacle tart.
The compartment went a little quiet.
"Well," he added awkwardly, "I mean, without—"
He trailed off, as if realizing the words were already halfway out of his mouth. The silence that followed was thick, heavy.
Sirius cleared his throat and gave a lopsided grin. "Let's not start the term on a dull note. We'll win with or without whoever you were about to mention."
Peter nodded quickly. Remus gave Sirius a quiet look, but said nothing.
Marlene cracked her knuckles and said, "I'm going to try out this year. We need someone with flair. That's me."
Sirius raised his eyebrows. "You mean the flair you showed while falling off your broom last year?"
"I was experimenting with aerial choreography," Marlene said, deadpan.
Lily smiled again, letting the chatter wash over her. Outside the window, the sun had started dipping into twilight. Someone mentioned they were getting close to Hogwarts and should start changing.
Sirius was mid-story about a near duel he'd gotten into over a bottle of butterbeer in Knockturn Alley when—
BANG!
A sharp noise echoed from the compartment just down the corridor, followed by the unmistakable clatter of someone falling.
The group fell silent, alert in an instant. Lily and Remus were the first to their feet. They slid the compartment door open and crept toward the source of the noise through the smoke.
There, just ahead—students pressed back against the walls, whispering, frozen.
One boy—Lucius Malfoy—lay on the floor, blood trickling from a gash on his cheek.
Standing above him was a tall figure, sharp and still as a statue. He turned as they approached, messy black hair falling slightly into his eyes, wand still raised.
James Potter.
A pause. Recognition. Shock.
And then, with a rueful smile playing at the corners of his mouth, he said,
"Missed me?"
And that's Chapter 1 wrapped! But don't get too comfy – things are about to get messy. Next chapter, expect drama, revelations, and maybe a few more surprises involving Lucius Malfoy. You won't want to miss it!
