Reuploaded and edited 10/25/2022 (still not perfect but better lol)
"Clary look at the screen and tell me what you see." Clary had been with Jace and Jonathan for a few days now, she was pretending to be on their side while trying to figure out how to get Jace out of Jonathan's clutches. She had found nothing so far. Currently Jace was in the shower, Clary had been eating a snack in the kitchen when Jonathan asked her to follow him into another room. She had followed him silently into an office type room. She looked at the screen and she could see her mother, she was running very fast down the street, looking nervous.
"That's my mother, what is this?" Clary asked looking up at Jonathan with a confused look on her face. He could only smirk at her evilly.
"This Clary is my leverage; I have a demon following at all times. If you don't do everything I say from this moment on I will have this demon kill her. After it kills her, it will go after Luke next and then so on and so forth until you have no one left but Jace and I." Jonathan looked at Clary as her face turn from shocked to anger.
"I don't believe you!" Clary shouted while Jonathan picked up a walkie talkie while maintaining eye contact with her the entire time he spoke to an unknown.
"Show yourself so little Ms. Fray here so she can see you on camera." Jonathan said to the unknown thing on the other end of the walkie talkie. Clary watched the screen intently, suddenly she could see something starting to form from behind her mother, something dark stepped out. It was very tall, taller than any human could ever be. It was all black but in the shape of a human. It waved its creepy fingers at Clary before disappearing back into the shadows.
"My mother could fight it off." Clary said back confidently.
"Wanna bet?" Jonathan said still holding the walkie talkie. Clary looked down at her mother on the screen, she didn't look like she was prepared for a battle. Clary was torn but deiced she couldn't risk it.
"Fine I'll do whatever you want." Clary said with an eye roll, not sure what he wanted her to do so bad he had to threaten her like this. He already had complete control over Jace, wasn't that enough?
"Good." Was all he said before he ushered her out of the room. Johnathan brought Clary back into the kitchen and left her with her snack.
"I need to talk to Jace; we'll call you up in a minute." Clary was left alone to fume, aggravated that Jonathan now had one up on her as well. He clearly had something up his sleeve, she was nervous to find out what. She wished Jace wasn't under Jonathan's control and could help her. She sighed and threw away the rest of her uneaten crackers and cheese, she wasn't hungry anymore.
"Clary can you come up here?" She heard Jace call to her about a half hour later, he sounded a little odd, but Clary walked up the stairs to Jace's room only to find it empty.
"We're in here." She heard Jonathan's voice this time; she drifted towards his room and peeked in. Both boys were sitting on Jonathan's bed, Jace looked a little weird as Clary stepped further into the room.
"Come here beautiful." Jonathan said as he patted the spot in-between the two boys, she slowly approached them getting a little nervous. She sat down cautiously, closer to Jace then Jonathan.
"What up?" She asked in an almost whisper as Jonathan smiled at her, it looked creepy on his face.
"Jace has agreed to my plan, like I knew he would I do make all the rules." Jonathan said with a shrug looking at Jace then letting his gaze land back on Clary.
"What plan?" Clary said getting annoyed, this was stupid, and she was starting to get a bad feeling in the pit of her stomach.
"Well, Jace has agreed to share, what's his is mine and what's mine is his after all." Jonathan said but Clary was still confused. Jonathan pushed some of Clary's hair away from her neck and leaned in to kiss her throat, she pushed him away roughly.
"What the fuck are you doing?" She asked with deep venom in her voice.
"Isn't it obvious Clary, Jace has agreed to share you with me." Jonathan said slowly like she was stupid. Clary glared at him for a moment before turning to look at Jace, he refused to meet her eyes.
"Jace look at me." Clary finally said sharply, and he slowly looked into her eyes, he looked sad and far away.
"I am sorry Clary, but he's right what's mine is his and what's his is mine. You are mine so you are now also his." Jace said in a low voice.
"Don't worry we won't hurt you... too much." Jonathan said before going in to kiss her neck again.
"I am not anyone's let alone Jace's to just give away!" Clary said pushing Jonathan away again and standing up this time. Jonathan's eyes flashed evilly for a moment before going back to regular. He picked up his walkie talkie.
"Would you like me to tell Fredrick to take out your mother; I would be more than happy to make that happen?" Clary's eyes budged out as she realized why he pulled her into his office early to show her the creature he had following her mother. He was making sure she would cooperate for this. She felt tears sting her eyes. Jonathan stood up and towered over Clary.
"I promise we will make you feel good." For the third time he pushed Clary's hair back and started kissing her neck, this time she let him not sure what else she could do. She looked over Jonathan's shoulder at Jace; he was looking down at his hands before suddenly standing up and walking over to the pair. Jonathan was leaving a love mark on her neck. Jace took Clary's hand and led both her and Johnathan to the center of the large bed.
"Please be kind, this is her first time." Jace whispered and Jonathan got a wicked smirk on his face.
"Oh, really you two haven't done it yet?" Neither one said anything, and Jonathan took that as a yes. Clary was feeling betrayed by Jace and turned to look down at her hands instead of at either of the two massive boys kneeling in front of her.
"Oh, this is going to be fun." Jonathan said as he started pulling Clary's sweater off. She looked up at this and glared daggers into Jace with hurt eyes, but the person looking back at her wasn't Jace, it was someone else, someone she didn't recognize. Jonathan kissed down her neck and arms; it felt like she was getting burned everywhere his lips touched. He made quick work of her shirt and then she was sitting in front of two boys in her bra. She slowly lifted her arms up to cover her chest.
"Don't" Jonathan breathed as he pushed her arms back down.
"I want to see you, all of you." Jonathan said as he drank in the sight of her half naked body. He started kissing on her stomach, stopping for a second to pull his own shirt off.
"You gonna join in the fun brother?" Jonathan asked looking at Jace for a second before going back to kissing on Clary's stomach. Jace slowly pulled his own shirt off and looked down with sad eyes again.
"Sorry." He mouthed to Clary before he started kissing her neck; then they both pushed her down, so she was lying on her back. She looked up at the ceiling trying to figure a way out of this, tears slid down her face. She felt betrayed by Jace, not really realizing at the moment that he was just as forced as her in this situation. Jonathan started messing with the button of her jeans and she felt sick, was he really going to rape her and make Jace do it as well? She wanted her first time to be special, not with her brother. He slid her jeans down and tossed them across the room when he was done.
"Cute undies." Jonathan remarked as he looked down at her underwear, they were navy blue with pink polka dots and a small bow on the front. She blushed a deep red as Jonathan pulled on the little bow in the front. He then pulled them off her body in one swoop, she sat up shocked.
"Please I am not ready." She begged but Jonathan started kissing up her leg, Jace pushed her down and started trying to kiss her mouth she refused to kiss him back. This wasn't her Jace; she didn't want to kiss him anymore. Suddenly Jonathan's mouth was close to her private area, and she gasped into Jace's mouth and tried to keep her legs closed.
"Do you want me to get the walkie talkie Clary?" Jonathan threated before she finally went slack, and he was able to spread her legs. She felt tears slid down her face as Jonathan started tasting her with his mouth, was this really happening right now? She felt overwhelmed as Jace slid his hands under her back to unlatch her bra.
"You are so beautiful, my Clary." Jace said as he looked down at her naked breasts. Clary had imagined Jace would be her first, but not like this, never like this. Jace put his mouth on one for her breasts and started sucking, it felt good and with the feeling of Jonathan's mouth on her private area she couldn't help the small moan that escaped her mouth.
"Mhm, you like that baby?" Jonathan said down by her pussy as he slipped a finger inside of her, to help stretch her out. He moved in and out slowly and she wiggled a little trying to get him to stop, it hurt. He added a second finger and he started to rub her clit with his thumb. Jace was leaving wet kisses all over her stomach and chest, she felt herself close to something, something she has only ever brought herself to. She moaned without thinking again and Jonathan picked up his speed trying to coax out her climax, Jace lightly bite one of her nipples while using one of his hands to pinch the other. She came loud and long, arching her back and screaming. She had never come like that before in her life, it felt amazing. She was panting and sweating as she came down from her climax, Jonathan moved up to lie next to her and he started playing with her breasts as they were heaving up and down.
"That was so beautiful, and you taste amazing." Jonathan said as he squeezed her breasts lightly. Clary felt humiliated and embarrassed that her body betrayed her like that. Both Jonathan and Jace took their pants off at that point, Jonathan took off his boxers as well, but Jace left his on for the moment. Jonathan pressed his hardness against her stomach. She could feel how large it was and was nervous about what was going to happen next. She was already humiliated by coming so quickly, now she just wished she was anywhere but here.
"Let me get some condoms from my room." Jace said starting to get up.
"No, we don't need them; I wanted to feel all of Clary, without any barriers." Jonathan said stopping Jace by grabbing his arm. Clary looked alarmed and Jace did too. What if she got pregnant, it's not like she was on birth control.
"But Sebastian, getting her pregnant isn't really part of the plan, now, is it?" Jace said a little harshly.
"I say how the plan goes, now take off your boxers and put your god damn cock in Clary's mouth. I know you're her boyfriend and all, but I am going to be her first." Jonathan said as he sat up and pushed Clary's legs apart before putting the head of his penis at her entrance.
"This is rape, you do know." Clary said hoping to taint the moment. Jonathan completely ignored her before slammed his whole cock into her without warning. Clary screamed out in pain and Jace looked angry.
"I thought you said I would get to be her first, and that we would be gentle! That's not being gentle." Jace screamed at Jonathan. Jonathan looked up and glared at Jace.
"Shut the fuck up Jace! You are ruining this; don't make me send you away. Now do what I said and put your cock into Clary's fucking mouth." Jace looked annoyed at Jonathan but slowly crawling back onto the bed. Clary was crying and begging Jonathan to stop.
"I really am sorry Clary." Jace said again as he pulled his boxers down to his knees and put his dick near her mouth. He pushed the head of his cock into her mouth, but she refused to open up her lips. Jonathan noticed what was going on and pinched Clary's nipple until she screamed out in pain and Jace was finally able to push his dick in before she could close it again.
"Play nice and don't bite Jace, or you'll regret it." Jonathan said darkly while pushed in and out of her very hard and very fast. Jace went slower and steadier trying not to choke her, but it felt so good he couldn't help but go a little faster while moaning loudly. Jonathan suddenly came very quickly without warning, crying out Clary's name as he did so. When he was spent, he slowly pulled out of her and laid down next to her.
"Your turn, brother." Jonathan said as he nuzzled into Clary and started lightly kissing on her neck. Jace was a little worried, he didn't want to hurt her down there more then she already was. He could see her blood mixed with Jonathan's cum and he didn't want to do it. Jonathan glared at Jace when he started hesitating.
"Do it now!" He screamed and Jace got himself into position slowly entering Clary. He was very slow and gentle; Clary wouldn't look at him and he was afraid he lost her forever because of this. He came as quickly as he could and when he was done, he pulled out and laid down next to Clary pulling her in close. He could feel her dry sobbing and started patting her head.
"I am so sorry I love you so much Clary, please don't hate me." Jace said the words over and over as he rocked them back and forth. His eyes were tightly close as a few tears came down his own eyes.
"I am going to go take a shower, you two might want to clean up as well. We got some business to take care of, were leaving in an hour." Jonathan said as he got up and headed to his bathroom, shutting the door behind him.
AN- So I am thinking this is a one-shot, but if anyone really likes it maybe I'll add a few more chapters. Let me know what you think!